4 ms·
Ouya is going to kill the Kickstarter brand. These guys have no clue how to manufacture any hardware and are seriously underestimating the difficulty of turning
by modeless 14y ago
Ouya is going to kill the Kickstarter brand. These guys have no clue how to manufacture any hardware and are seriously underestimating the difficulty of turning a prototype into an assembly line. There will be many delays and broken promises on the way to a very late and very disappointing final product, and the whole well-publicized ordeal is going to poison Kickstarter in people's minds.
- clamps123 14y agosounds like you're talking out of your ass to me
- pbreit 14y agoDo you have any evidence to support your claims?
- MrMember 14y agoThere are past projects that might make a person wary of an unproven company trying to produce a console. There's the Phantom, which is fairly infamous. And the Open Pandora guys still haven't manufactured enough consoles to even fulfill preorders, several years on.
- drone 14y agoYes, but we're talking about a project being designed by one of the more famous industrial designers in the world, who also works for other hardware manufacturers (Jawbone, for example), and more than likely has a very deep network of hardware manufacturing contacts to draw upon. Just because some projects failed doesn't mean every related project will fail - unless the assumption here is that the only companies capable of bringing a console of any sort to market are MS, Sony, and Nintendo these days.
- MrMember 14y agoYes, but it doesn't hurt to be skeptical. Everyone who pledges should know they're paying for a product that doesn't exist yet and currently has no confirmed games. The project description does everything it can to gloss that over, and even outright lies in some places (like with the Minecraft thing).
- pbreit 14y ago"Everyone who pledges should know they're paying for a product that doesn't exist" Kickstarter defined.
- drone 14y agoReally? How do you know they have no clue how to manufacture any hardware? I can see their pedigree, what do you know about it that the rest of us don't?
- mtkd 14y agoYour entire day is made easier and your life longer because many people ignored comments like this to produce all the services and inventions you now take for granted.
- jiggy2011 14y agoThe problem is, this isn't some crazy mad scientist innovation that people simply don't have to insight to understand. This is a bunch of commodity hardware thrown into a box surrounded by very sketchy details surrounding development,software and the controller.
- wmf 14y agoThe hardware seems like the easy part; can't they just call ASUS? I'm more skeptical about the game ecosystem.
- esbwhat 14y ago"We break things. Julie Uhrman has been in games for a long time, at Vivendi Universal, IGN, GameFly, and other places. Yves Behar is the award-winning designer of Jambox, One Laptop per Child, and many others. There are plenty of other people involved, but some of them would get fired if we tell you who they are." Sounds like they have hardware experience
- modeless 14y agoConcept design and manufacturing are completely different things. I'm talking about manufacturing experience, and they have none. Zero. You can be sure they'd have mentioned it if they did. Let me address their only revealed experience: "Vivendi Universal, IGN, GameFly," those are all 100% software. "[They] would get fired if we tell you who they are", really? They're asking for millions of our dollars and they aren't confident enough to even minimally risk their current jobs by publicly supporting their own project? That's a huge red flag. The console industry is littered with spectacular failures of this type, and I'm before I believe this one is worth investing actual money in I'm going to need more than Yves Behar, Julie Uhrman who's "been in the game industry for years" (exclusively on the software side), and several mysterious people who refuse to even be named.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- AnIrishDuck 14y agoJulie Uhrman is an executive (http://www.linkedin.com/in/julieuhrman http://www.linkedin.com/in/julieuhrman). Yves Behar is a designer (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yves_B%C3%A9har http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yves_B%C3%A9har). Until I hear about the involvement of at least one full-time electrical engineer and embedded software developer, I'll be highly skeptical that they can deliver anything that they promise. Especially in the time frame cited; I've worked in both fields and unless they have experienced full-time engineers and developers working on this right now there's no way they're making the deadline. The "we have a prototype" is at best a vague indicator of progress. Do they have a board designed? Has it been fabricated? Do they even have android running on the hardware they plan on using? If not, are they using off-the-shelf boards? I can't find any Tegra 2 OTS boards available remotely within the price point they list, much less Tegra 3. And the "some of them would get fired if we tell you who they are" is more disconcerting than assuring. If they do have people with engineering/manufacturing/software development expertise these people do not believe in this project enough to leave their day job. That should speak for itself. EDIT: for example, see http://trimslice.com/web/order-direct http://trimslice.com/web/order-direct. Their Tegra 2 board with more modest hardware specifications is only available at more than twice the price point touted for Ouya. Note that this doesn't even include the cost of the custom bundled controller, which is itself a substantial hardware undertaking.
- franzus 14y agoGosh, I hope Kickstarter would go down to be replaced by something that allows non US-citizens to fund projects.
- sirclueless 14y agoOn the other hand, the current generation of game consoles is very underpowered compared to commodity hardware these days. That means that you can probably produce a product that competes with them in specs very cheaply, which Ouya can take advantage of. I really don't think that hardware is going to be their biggest challenge.
- JackC 14y agoCan anyone who's done outsourced hardware comment on how hard that part actually is? I mean, if I met with someone from Foxconn and said, "listen, I need to you to take this 3d model of a plastic case, slam in an Android SoC and some I/O ports and a power supply and have test units ready in two months and another 50,000 ready to go by March, I can give you $80 a piece up front" -- could I plausibly get something of decent quality? What does this process actually require on the retail end in terms of time and money and expertise? Seems to me the controller might be the hard part -- more UX testing, less standard parts. But I'd love to hear from someone who's solved this kind of problem.
- AnIrishDuck 14y agoIt's somewhat amusing to me to see several comments on this thread wave away the actual hardware as an "outsourced design" or "just call Asus". I have to assume it's a result of people not understanding the complexity of modern hardware. First, I've been unable in my (admittedly, cursory) research to discover any prebuilt systems that even come close to their promised hardware specs. So until someone proves me wrong by posting a link to an OTS solution even close to what they're promising, lets assume that the system needs custom design. This is a whole massive can of worms. I have some experience with hardware design (though not as much as a full-blown EE), and I'd ballpark hardware design alone as a half-year effort with multiple full-time EEs. And that's a best-case optimistic estimate. People who work in software don't seem to understand how hard this stuff is. It's not like you can simply take another schematic, slap the new parts you want on, delete the old parts, autoroute it and call it a day. With parts of this complexity there's a whole host of other design issues that come out of the woodwork. High-frequency switching means if one of your autorouted traces is longer than another, you're going to have timing issues. Crosstalk between layers, capacitance and inductance of the wires themselves can wreak havoc on your busses. You need to intelligently design the ground planes, separate your signals (analog and digital components), etc etc etc. These are only the issues I'm aware of. I'm sure people experienced with creating boards this complex can fill me in on more. It's not like a hobby arduino project - hooking up traces to debug problems can increase the capacitance of a line enough to cause a new set of problems. This isn't really directed just towards you, but it feels like a ton of people here are missing how difficult hardware design with components this complex is.