4 ms·
Isn't it very typical for an ISP to run their line onto your premises and put the demarcation device on your premises with your power supply etc? Usually there
by immibis 2y ago
Isn't it very typical for an ISP to run their line onto your premises and put the demarcation device on your premises with your power supply etc? Usually there isn't a "their side" where it still works. It's your premises, then up to kilometers of wiring, then the central exchange. Equipment required to terminate the wiring at your end obvious has to be at your end, not theirs.
It's possible that the termination equipment could be a bare SFP and not a big box, but the ISP wants to be able to monitor the status of your connection up to the termination equipment, because that is their responsibility to keep online, and they can't do that if it's just an off-the-shelf SFP. They probably wouldn't agree to do it and still have any SLA.
If there's a physical problem with the box (too big/loud) you can try negotiate for a different box but if you just want control over your network, sorry but that just isn't how it works. Your network starts at the demarcation, and you don't want to be responsible for speaking whatever protocols the ISP is using internally, either. Up to the demarcation, it's ISP internal network, and past that, it's your network, with a standard handover interface like Ethernet.
- kbolino 2y agoThis depends on the technology. When I had a PON connection (FiOS), the ONT belonged to the ISP but was on my premises. However, with the cable Internet I have now (Xfinity aka Comcast), there is nothing between me and the street save a splitter and PoE filter, both of which are passive.
- immibis 2y agoBut you have a cable modem. You either have one provided directly by Comcast or you have one that adheres to their standards. It used to be that you had to get a cable or DSL modem from your ISP. Now, cable and DSL networks are standardized enough that there's a good chance you can get a third-party one to work. It will be the same with PON in time. I think it's fine to be required to use your ISP modem, since different ISPs have different physical layer networks. It starts to suck when they try to force you to use their router. I think in the EU it's actually a legal requirement that if they do, it has to support bridge mode (a.k.a. behave as only a modem).
- jhugo 2y ago> Now, cable and DSL networks are standardized enough that there's a good chance you can get a third-party one to work. It will be the same with PON in time. It’s mostly the same with PON now. I’ve always had success with the FS.com PON SFPs, once I get the necessary information for the connection to program them with (the difficulty of which can vary from “ask the tech installing the connection nicely” to “take apart the ISP-provided CPE and solder wires to the debug console pads”).
- kbolino 2y agoComcast has supported standard DOCSIS modems for a long time now. I have some old ones lying around, but they're too old for modern speeds.
- cyberax 2y ago> Isn't it very typical for an ISP to run their line onto your premises and put the demarcation device on your premises with your power supply etc? Usually there isn't a "their side" where it still works. There is, in my case. Their point of presence is about 800 meters away, and they have a simple switch that aggregates connections. Their optical terminal on my terminal (a switch-sized 1-U rack-mounted box with ANNOYING fans) does all the traffic shaping, authentication, etc. > It's possible that the termination equipment could be a bare SFP and not a big box, but the ISP wants to be able to monitor the status of your connection up to the termination equipment, because that is their responsibility to keep online, and they can't do that if it's just an off-the-shelf SFP. They probably wouldn't agree to do it and still have any SLA. Sure, and having equipment on my premises makes it much easier to debug the issue. But they actually monitor the BGP session state, not the optical path.