7 ms·
Groupon Shares Tumble to Record Low
- kno 14y agoThese guys should have taken the 4 billion from Google. Their unfair advantage is pretty much inexistent that leave them extremely vulnerable to any competition.
- bluedevil2k 14y ago$6B I thought it was, but what's a few billion amongst friends.
- rabidonrails 14y agoWasn't that Bernie Madoff's catchphrase? :)
- incongruity 14y agoI think it actually says more that Google was willing to pay that much... for what, exactly? As for the merits of not taking the deal, I think we should be clear – the early investors and many early employees have done alright and most likely won't be losing their shirt like any of the recent investors: http://allthingsd.com/20110602/where-did-groupons-billion-dollars-go/ http://allthingsd.com/20110602/where-did-groupons-billion-do... Also, fwiw, this post seems to be fairly well thought out and it is clearly from before the IPO, so it's worth looking back on with fresh eyes: http://shortlogic.com/post/6142108636/groupon-ipo-pass-on-this-deal http://shortlogic.com/post/6142108636/groupon-ipo-pass-on-th...
- tokenadult 14y agoA great line from the Short logic analysis: "At the moment, it’s costing them $1.43 to make $1, and it doesn’t look like it’s getting any cheaper." This was the kind of thing that thoughtful business analysts were noticing in the weeks before the Groupon IPO: the company didn't have a sensible earnings model, even if it had "revenue" that dug it deeper and deeper into a hole.
- BlackNapoleon 14y agoI was thinking the SAME thing. That says a lot about google.
- incongruity 14y agoIndeed. Where's the IP? It's not like there's anything of value in Groupon – customers? no lock in/low switching costs. Vendors? Every small business person I've heard talk about their experience with Groupon has said they'd never use it again.
- ZanderEarth32 14y agoNot sure why this is getting up voted. Hasn't Groupon taken a hit every day this week, and pretty regularly for the entire year?
- tatsuke95 14y agoRemember, this was the fastest growing company of all time, gone from a billion dollar+ IPO price of over $30, down to $7 in a matter of months. Sheer evaporation of capital. Promoted by many of the usual suspects of the tech scene. I find it to be an incredibly interesting business case study.
- tptacek 14y agoThat doesn't change the fact that it's very easy to have a "record low" when there's only a year of history for your stock.
- dredmorbius 14y agoIt's a bit harder to have a record low if, you know, your company's valuation grows post-IPO. All pop. No star.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm not sure I'm smart enough to know what this comment means.
- dredmorbius 14y agoThe only upward growth of the company was at its IPO. It popped. It never produced a star. All flash, no fire. Sizzle but no steak. A failure to deliver.
- unreal37 14y agoSerious question. Does capital really "evaporate"? I mean, the value of the entire company has gone down when measured by the stock price, but the stock price is just a report of the latest trade. If you and I trade 1 Share of Groupon for $1, we didn't just wipe billions of dollars in capital away. Maybe I lost money selling you that 1 share, but Groupon still has the cash in the bank from it's IPO, all other investors still own the same percentage of the company, revenue remains the same, profits remain the same --- so the stock transfer between you and I didn't really change anything fundamental about the company did it?
- bluedevil2k 14y agoEveryone pointed to the ponzi scheme nature of the Facebook IPO, but Groupon's IPO really should be the standard of the ponzi scheme IPO. The investors and owners of the company knew the entire revenue model would collapse in on itself, and the only way to make money on the whole thing before it all disappeared was to IPO - sell this worthless POS to someone else and let them hold all the shares when the bubble pops. The nature of the ponzi scheme is that the last people in get hurt the most - sounds remarkably like this IPO. The very nature of the IPO itself should have raised red flags to everyone (just as Facebook's did). Early investors are all dumping shares, founders are dumping shares - in lieu of insider trading laws, it's the surest sign that something is amiss. You really think if the company was expecting the same massive growth that the only people with the insider knowledge of that happening would be selling shares? You think John Rockefeller was selling shares of Standard Oil?
- herval 14y agowhat's "ponziesque" about the Facebook IPO?
- KaoruAoiShiho 14y agoAccording to him, if your company ever loses value, it becomes a ponzi scheme.
- jessedhillon 14y agoThe investors and owners of the company knew the entire revenue model would collapse in on itself, Is it me, or has the standard of proof on HN dropped to immeasurable levels? What's that? Hmm? Oh no, I didn't say anything, not me. Just doing my part in the two minutes hate against anyone who isn't an engineer. We all know engineers are the unappreciated man-gods oppressed by the investor class. Boo investors! Hiss!
- pessimizer 14y agoNobody mentioned engineers. It was a statement about more savvy investors with insider knowledge screwing less savvy investors without insider knowledge. Your criticism is like accusing somebody calling out unscrupulous used car dealers who sell lemons of hating people who own cars.
- tlrobinson 14y agoZNGA is also at their all time low.
- danko 14y agoIf there's any joy to take from this (beyond pure, uncut schadenfreude), it's that news articles like this have permanently stemmed the tide of Groupon imitators that saturated every conduit of the tech media in 2011. I do fully believe that Groupon (and Living Social) will survive -- albeit as much more modestly sized companies -- but the sea of imitators should evaporate except for a very select few in well-entrenched niches. And that's fine, they serve their purpose, and they do have a legitimate market in which they can make money and deliver value. The rest of us can treat their product as an established commodity and move on.
- staunch 14y agoI'm not sure what the right price is for Groupon, but I still believe it's got massive potential. It could serve the same purpose that AdWords does online but in the physical world, which is a far larger market. The thing that seems to be holding them back is that they're simply not executing at a super high level yet. It seems like they scaled the business by doing everything the same way but at higher volumes. They need to move to a self-serve model so they can get rid of the overhead of having 10,000 sales/writer employees. They need to simplify their product down to the primary use case. They have at least four products currently: Featured Deal, Now!, Goods, and Rewards. Unfortunately I do predict doom and gloom for them. It would be so hard for them to make the changes required that it's most likely they will not be able to do it. Andrew Mason isn't in the kind of position Zuckerberg is in from a control perspective, which means he'd probably get fired for trying to do this stuff.
- vladd 14y agoMost of their small business owner clients lack decent knowledge in computers in order to be self-served by Groupon, otherwise they would have used AdWords or Drupal by now and would have had their own coupons. But in a couple of years from now, with voice recognition and voice synthesis, I can see e.g. Google having phone bots that are good enough to automate the process (and have human operators just for 10% of the cases where things go bad). Part of the flow is not really automate-able: it involves hearing from the owner the products they have and writing a pitch on Groupon.com that fits the overall theme and style of the site. But it can still be done faster probably if owners were to leave that info with clever phone bots rather then being hand-hold while walked though every stage of the process.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- staunch 14y agoI think the future of Groupon is something closer to what Google Local wants to be. A place people can turn to when they want to get lunch, a massage, or get their oil changed. I think the daily deal thing, which started Groupon, is not nearly as interesting as this. They could drop it entirely. I believe business owners could absolutely handle it themselves, if you made it really simple. The primary interface could be a smart phone, so it would work for any business. Made it dead simple. It shouldn't take more than 5 minutes to put up your daily ad.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- xanadohnt 14y agoGroupon needs to fail. The faster the better. Often the small business owners that are attracted to Groupon's service are not technologically savvy. They become starry eyed with the promise of new customers, business (and - ultimately - money), and don't grasp what's at risk. It's typical for a business owner to have a wholly negative experience with a Groupon sale. "Grouponers" have a certain DNA. And that DNA is at odds with what Groupon promises. "Attract new customers" - NO, most only go to the merchant for that single, highly discounted, offering, never to return. "Attract collateral business" - NO, studies show grouponers rarely purchase beyond the sale item. "Make lots of money during the sale because you'll get a guarantee number of X buyers" - NO, Groupon keeps such a large percentage of the sale (50%) that most sales operate at a loss to the merchant. But there are more systemic issues with Gropoun, merchant, and employee relationships. Again, the DNA of a grouponer - being that of a deal thrift - often leads to a strained relationship between employees and grouponers. No use in fostering good rapport with the customer; you'll never see 'em again. Tips will be small (again, deal thrift), upselling is improbable, etc., all leading to employees often becoming resentful toward grouponers. All this leads to a large net negative to the small business owner. Groupon is a well disguised parasite. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/45398235/ns/world_news-europe/#.TsuORXNcKfZ http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/45398235/ns/world_news-europe/#.... http://www.riverfronttimes.com/2011-10-13/news/groupon-fail-st-louis-local-harvest-yelp/ http://www.riverfronttimes.com/2011-10-13/news/groupon-fail-... http://crosscut.com/2012/04/11/business/22198/Groupon-When-will-misery-stop-for-everyone/ http://crosscut.com/2012/04/11/business/22198/Groupon-When-w...
- maratd 14y ago> "Grouponers" have a certain DNA. And that DNA is at odds with what Groupon promises. > Again, the DNA of a grouponer - being that of a deal thrift - often leads to a strained relationship between employees and grouponers. This is insulting and frankly, just bullshit. The overwhelming majority of the businesses on Groupon are failing. Of course I'm not going to be back. They won't be there! Out of the businesses that aren't failing, you can put them in these categories: new location for an established business, new business, experiences (like tours, hot air balloons, etc.), confused business. I have experience with all of these. 1. New location. There was a restaurant that I like that opened a new location. They had a groupon. I already knew they had great service and excellent food. I went on a groupon, had the experience I expected. Did I return to that location? No, I prefer the other one because it's closer. But now I know about it and if I'm in that neighborhood, I know I can go to that location and have the same excellent experience I expect. 2. New business. These mostly suck. Because they're new and don't know what they're doing. Out of all the ones I went to (and I went to many), I would only go back to one. It was a chain, so they had fewer variables to juggle. 3. Experiences. These are flip of the coin. Some are excellent, some suck, but regardless ... once I had an experience, I'm not going to have it again. That's boring. They know that. Most of the groupons for these are structured so that they make their money on the first round. 4. Confused business. There's only been one like this. A fantastic restaurant. I bought 2 groupons and went there twice. I have no idea why they did it. The place was packed, service great, food amazing. It was voted Groupon of the year in my area (NYC) and they had it again ... so I bought 2 more and went there 2 more times. Will definitely come back many, many times. Groupon is going down the toilet. That's because there are fewer and fewer of the above businesses on it. Now it's 99% failing businesses. Unless I already know the business or I'm traveling, I'm not going to touch Groupon. That's after almost 50 groupons purchased.
- steveplace 14y agoNobody has yet mentioned the absolute drubbing that tech/semi stocks in general have taken. Sure there's some company issues but don't forget market correlations that occur when an entire sector takes a hit.