5 ms·
In the days since RS485, OTA firmware flashing's become the standard, though we could also go back to EEPROMs with the little UV window. Those were the days.
by fragmede 2y ago
In the days since RS485, OTA firmware flashing's become the standard, though we could also go back to EEPROMs with the little UV window.
Those were the days.
- mulmen 2y agoI’m honestly laughing out loud that I have to explain why I don’t want OTA updates on my network hardware.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoI can think of reasonable reasons to not want OTA (it makes some ways of persisting a compromise hard). Now, do you understand why some people very much do want OTA updates, especially on network hardware? (I'll give you mine for free: I want to minimize time and effort required to patch security bugs.)
- mulmen 2y agoAre we mixing terminology? OTA means over the air as in wifi. If I need a firmware update I’ll do it from the management console on a wired network, preferably on a dedicated interface or vlan.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoOkay, then yes we're using the same term to mean different things. I mostly see "OTA" used to describe Android devices downloading updated system images via whatever network they happen to be on at the moment, but I view it as meaning any update installed over the network, ex. iOS updating over LTE, a laptop running apt-get over wifi, or a server pulling .rpm files over fiber from the cache server 3 racks over. And yes, I suppose that last one doesn't literally have "air" in play, but I don't really see a conceptual difference; you can run SSH over wireguard over wifi and LTE and I think that can be at least as secure as plugging a serial cable into the box directly. Obviously the details depend on your threat model, but I really don't think it's likely to matter that much. For a lot of things running openwrt in particular, I'd actually prefer that updating not involve me plugging in a direct line - because ideally the device would auto-update and reboot on a schedule with zero human interaction required, so you get security patches without manual effort. (And a robust A/B + self-test setup or whatever to make that safe.)
- mulmen 2y agoI don’t want my management network exposed to wifi or the internet. OTA as you have described it requires both.