5 ms·
Mozilla Persona (AKA BrowserID) is exciting stuff. However, it doesn't seem to have changed much since the last time it hit Hacker News [0]. There are websites
by Flimm 14y ago
Mozilla Persona (AKA BrowserID) is exciting stuff. However, it doesn't seem to have changed much since the last time it hit Hacker News [0].
There are websites that have chosen Persona as an authentication method. We now need to see the following two pieces implemented:
- It needs to be implemented in the browser's GUI, like in this old screenshot [1]. People will be able to see the usability and security benefits of having a standardised way to log in that's built-in into the browser. Could we at least have a Firefox extension or a nightly build of Firefox that does this?
- At least one email provider needs to be a Persona "ID provider", which would eliminate the need to create a Persona password and to click on a link in an email. My guess is that getting Gmail to support this would be slow work, why not try persuading smaller email providers like Fastmail to be the first to openly support Persona?
Fortunately, Persona does work even without these two pieces, using fall-back servers and a shim. But most of the benefits of Persona are only valid once the browser and the email provider deliberately support it.
[0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2764824 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2764824
[1] - http://i50.tinypic.com/2ptyv80.jpg http://i50.tinypic.com/2ptyv80.jpg
- Flimm 14y agoAs explained in another comment, the second item is already part way there through another workaround. Ctrl-F "bigtent".
- callahad 14y agoMuch has changed, but we haven't written about it yet. We're working on it. This post to HN caught me by surprise. The new design went live, but we weren't planning on announcing things until early next month. Trying to stabilize and polish the new APIs, etc. Native support should be coming in Firefox 17, albeit off-by-default. Native support will be enabled on phones running Boot2Gecko, which ship in Q1 next year.