3 ms·
My company is one of the early adopters of Persona/BrowserID. You can see our dual-auth (with Facebook) system here: https://www.voo.st/ https://www.voo.st/
by stickfigure 14y ago
My company is one of the early adopters of Persona/BrowserID. You can see our dual-auth (with Facebook) system here:
https://www.voo.st/ https://www.voo.st/
We've been live for several months now in the Real World - our userbase (amateur athletes) is primarily nontechnical. About half of our users choose Persona/BrowserID and half choose Facebook. We were initially concerned about the BID login flow (in particular, the immediate email roundtrip) but it hasn't been a problem and the UX has been refined quite a lot over the last month or two.
For a mass-consumer audience, the combined FB/Persona solution is excellent:
* Facebook unquestionably has the slickest auth experience, even eliminating the followup name/sex/bday questions. However, a significant percentage of the world (possibly > 25%) either Hates Facebook or wants to keep their Facebook account isolated. This is unlikely to change in the near future and could even get worse depending on what sleeping dogs Zuckerberg decides to kick next week. We don't have the option of alienating the FB haters and we wouldn't want to anyways.
* The Persona UX is good and rapidly getting better. BigTent integration with gmail, yahoo, hotmail will bring one-click login to those users. A native experience is being built into browser chrome. All this is coming without me having to write code. It may not be as slick as Facebook, but I like where this train is headed.
* Integration is simple compared to writing a username/password system. The API is incredibly easy to work with. Dual-auth with Facebook is a little more complicated, but a complete Persona-based auth system is a question of hours, not days.
* The fact that identity is just an email address makes it easier to integrate with existing login systems. In our system, you can log into the same account with both Facebook and Persona as long as the emails match. No, email is not a perfect identifier, but even nontechnical users understand it immediately and really - what other option is there? "What email address did I use?" is a lot better than "What weird combination of letters and numbers did I use as a login name?"
* Support on the Mozilla dev-identity list has been fantastic.
We're pretty happy. Honestly, I don't ever see myself writing another username/password login system ever again. Persona is less work for a better UX.
- dabeeeenster 14y agoOK so I tried to sign up to your site with BID and am pretty confused: I'm using Chrome. Don't know if that affects things. Anyway. Hit Browser ID, asks me for my email address. OK fine, add that in. It then says (quickly, and temporarily as it's an AJAX load), that it's looking up my email provider (Google Apps). It then asks me for my password. So now I'm totally confused. I've not signed up with your site or BID before, so I dont know if it wants my GAPPS password or a new password. I don't feel like I want to put in my GApps password, as there is no Google branding anywhere and the URL is not Google. So I try putting in my GAPPS password, because I use 2 factor, and it doesn't work. Most likely because I use 2 factor, and I can't authenticate with just my standard GAPPS password. So it failed. I guess I'm an edge case as most people don't enable 2-factor on their Google account, but I was still really confused when it asked for my email password. EDIT: Same thing happened with Firefox version whatever the latest one is. I'd say it's completely confusing, all in all.
- jstalin 14y agoI just tried it and once I entered my email address, it then asked: "Next, choose a new password you'll use when you sign in with Persona." Not sure why you're confused.
- jackalope 14y agoFrom https://developer.mozilla.org/en/BrowserID/ https://developer.mozilla.org/en/BrowserID/ "Website operators still get a verified email address for their users, and users only have to remember a single password. BrowserID is also intuitive, since email addresses are commonly understood to be associated with identities." Mozilla is really stressing the "email address/single password" concept. If they really mean "email address/separate dedicated Persona password" then they should make this clear.
- callahad 14y agoThe language around the number of passwords you need is really hard to get right. If you have suggestions, please let me know. In a world where every email provider supports Persona natively, Persona truly is a "no new passwords" authentication system, since it delegates to your provider. If your email address isn't supported, Persona asks you to create a single new password at login.persona.org. You can then add many other unsupported addresses, without needing more passwords. So it's an "at most one new password" system.
- uvtc 14y agoSimply always refer to the Persona password as "Persona password". > In a world where every email provider supports Persona natively, Persona truly is a "no new passwords" authentication system, since it delegates to your provider. I don't know what this means. I won't give Persona my gmail/yahoo-mail email password.
- callahad 14y agoYeah, it's confusing. If your email provider is supported, your browser talks directly to your email provider, without Mozilla in the middle. We don't want your passwords, honest! :) You can try out the supported email provider workflow by signing up for a dummy account at eyedee.me, and then using that account to sign in at, say, 123done.org.
- mathijs 14y agoCoincidentally I've asked a question about login system just two days ago (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4225270 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4225270) where I mentioned BrowserID as one of the options. Apparently I hadn't properly checked out BrowserID/Persona because I thought of it as an OpenID replacement, not an email+password login replacement. I'm positively surprised to see that you found a 50-50 balance between BrowserID and Facebook; I expected a lower pickup rate on BrowserID. So, I guess I've decided what login system to use for my project(s). Thanks for the information.
- nnethercote 14y agoThanks for the detailed description! Nice to see actual experiences rather than speculation. "a significant percentage of the world (possibly > 25%) either Hates Facebook or wants to keep their Facebook account isolated." And some people don't even have a Facebook account. Around 6 billion people, last time I heard :)