5 ms·
It's mostly not rational. For instance, much of the conversation over the last day has been about Anthem pushing back on anesthesiology pay on the East Coast. T
by tptacek 2y ago
It's mostly not rational. For instance, much of the conversation over the last day has been about Anthem pushing back on anesthesiology pay on the East Coast. That's people angry about their insurers working to make surgeries cost less by employing the literal guideline Medicare uses, and yet people online were overtly suggesting Anthem's CEO be murdered over it. Incoherent.
This won't win me any points in this particular forum, where this opinion (that I strongly hold) is unpopular, but I'm reminded of what someone else said about Net Neutrality: it's a bunch of people suiting up and taking sides on behalf of one group of giant corporations against another group of giant corporations. That's the "health care debate" in the US, where medical staff are paid 2-3x more than they are in other countries, and expensive procedures are prescribed and delivered at drastically higher rates. It's my problem with "Medicare For All", which more or less absolves providers from their role in choking people out with health care costs, despite the leading role they have in this situation.
At any rate: there's no serious theory of change that begins with murdering health care industry people.
- vundercind 2y ago> At any rate: there's no serious theory of change that begins with murdering health care industry people. I dunno. This is the most publicly-united I’ve seen people against the industry maybe ever. Usually they’re separately-angry at the industry in their partisan silos (everyone hates it, more or less—hence the amazingly consistent and widespread reaction) but this has been the closest thing to a bipartisan healing moment since, like, the week after 9/11. Not particularly close to that, sure, but I can’t think of anything closer. If this were part of a theory of change, it strikes me as no less serious than any other I’ve seen. At least.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI think it is the most disgusted I have been with a broad swath of the public in a long time. I dont think anything productive will come of it.
- vundercind 2y agoThe trouble is that nothing productive was going to come of anything else, either. That’s where these reactions come from.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoYes, there is a lot of frustrations. Voters disagree on what they want. That does not justify people to start shooting people when they dont get their way.
- vundercind 2y agoThe thing you don’t like is that the voters do agree they want this, though.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoWant what? I dont think the majority of Americans endorse vigilante murder of law abiding citizens. That is just a vocal and bloodthirsty segment of the online population.
- vundercind 2y agoLiterally everyone I know IRL was like, “nice. More please.” I was actually surprised and heartened to see the initial HN thread, even, was overwhelmingly supportive. This is top of my list for conversation topics to steer things toward when I’m around Republican relatives, so we’ll have something we can agree on. Law-abiding doesn’t mean much when you can kill lots of people for money and remain within the bounds of the law. Killing one such person is definitely far less bad than killing a bunch of people arbitrarily. Yet only one of these cases is illegal, and it’s the better of the two.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoMore please of what? Vigilante murders?
- emeril 2y agomaybe so but it's definitely cathartic and that counts for something
- giardini 2y agoLikely a placebo effect.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI dont think it counts for something good. I think it is giving in to one of the worst possible aspects of humanity. Like people cheering at a lynching.
- emeril 2y agoI suppose though if one of my children grows up to be a CEO of a place like UHC, I'd consider myself to have failed as a parent and would disown them
- bdangubic 2y agoif they are that successful to make it to a point where they can be hired to be CEO of UHC or Monsanto or other axis of pure evil, perhaps they would choose to take their talents elsewhere
- CamperBob2 2y agoThe notion that the providers are the ones sucking up all the money in the healthcare industry is certainly... novel. The majority of people in this particular industry have nothing to do with actually providing health care, just as the majority of employees at a major university have never stood in front of a blackboard.
- tptacek 2y agoIf you look, you can find pie charts that make the point I'm making directly, so no, I don't think it's novel.
- adgjlsfhk1 2y agoThe problem with our health insurance system is that it's insidious. Our doctors spend ~25% of their time filling out information that only gets filled out to try to get insurance to not deny the claims, and hospitals have entire billing departments whose only job is dealing with the billing of our stupid ass system. The problem isn't just the ~15% that the insurance companies take directly, it's that since their percentage of profit is capped, they work to raise prices of the entire health care system so that their 15% cut is bigger. Insurance companies literally negotiate pharma companies to charge a larger amount to uninsured people so they get to take a bigger cut.
- tptacek 2y agoIs that why they make as much as 3x what doctors in other G20 countries make? Hazard pay for the paperwork?
- adgjlsfhk1 2y agoThat's not all of the reason (some of it is higher cost of living, compare G20 vs G7 and the gap narrows a bunch). Some of the reason is because of US education costs, and immigration policies that make it harder for people to come and work in healthcare.
- jmyeet 2y agoI'm honestly not sure if I should attribute this comment to disingenuity, ignorance or just bad faith. > pushing back on anesthesiology pay on the East Coast. Not even close. BCBS was just pushing extra charges onto patients. > insurers working to make surgeries cost less This is laughably ill-informed, I don't know where to begin. The only thing insurers are doing is increasing the gap between what they collect and what they have to pay out. They do this by denying claims. Making the service cheaper has nothing to do with it. > where medical staff are paid 2-3x more than they are in other countries Because medical school is so expensive. Also, doctors spend 3-8 years working for minimum wage (ie medical residency) and the cost of billing and administration is enormous. One study showed a primary care doctor spent $99,000 a year on billing and roughly 25% of ER income spent on the same [1]. The US spends the most per capita on healthcare than any other OECD country, by about 50% (Switzerland is #2) [2] for less coverage, worse outcomes and lower life expectancy. Medicare spends almost all (~98.5%) of its funds on patient care and ~1.5% on admin, compared to 15-25% on admin for private insurers (including Medicare Advantage). It amazes me how concifently wrong and ignorant about a subject can be while having such strong opinions. [1]: https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/finance/study-billing-for-medical-services-costs-huge-amounts-time-and-money https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/finance/study-billing-for-m... [2]: https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/7a7afb35-en/1/3/7/2/index.html?itemId=/content/publication/7a7afb35-en&_csp_=6cf33e24b6584414b81774026d82a571&itemIGO=oecd&itemContentType=book https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/7a7afb35-en/1/3/7/2/inde...
- tptacek 2y agoAnthem proposed to apply the precise guidelines Medicare uses to pay for anesthesiology, including references to those CMS guidelines. Billing for anesthesiology has been a hot button issue: the search you want is [anesthesia surprise billing]. Anesthesiology is one of the highest-paid specialties in American medicine. You cannot reasonably support Medicare and claim that Anthem was doing something unconscionable, because Anthem was adopting Medicare's own policies. Medicare's admin cost ratio is a function of who it covers. Somewhere in the comment history on HN, there's a short writeup I did of how the math works out if you extend Medicare to the whole population; the admin overhead, for obvious reasons, shoots up --- people pay the same amount of money but require far fewer services, reversing the "advantage" Medicare has in the metric currently.
- coldpie 2y agoOkay. So other than getting mad on HN, what do you propose we do to fix the feelings people have about this situation and prevent this happening again?
- tptacek 2y agoI don't think we're going to fix this problem on HN, so I'm content just to point out that a lot of what people are saying about this situation is unfounded.
- coldpie 2y agoI don't either, but people feel this way about millionaires and healthcare execs for a reason, they're not just being cruel for the sake of it. Think about the reasons for it, and try to come up with a solution. That's a way more interesting discussion than getting mad about people being dumb on BlueSky or whatever.
- ertian 2y agoPeople have built a frustrating system for themselves with a century of complicated and messy political decisions (and resulting regulations). They don't have the will or attention span required to solve the various problems via the slow moving & gridlocked political system. So, they take out their frustration on the highest profile participants in the system. Solutions? I'm worried that there aren't solutions. There are only bandaids.
- tptacek 2y agoThere is really basic stuff that we're going to have to do no matter what that doesn't involve restructuring the system, like drastically increasing the number of practicing physicians, which is capped by (you guessed) Medicare, which sponsors residencies. But all we can talk about is payer structure because of a complete fixation on insurance companies as singular villains.
- perrygeo 2y ago> there's no serious theory of change that begins with murdering health care industry people. You sure about that? Show me one theory of change where the oppressed somehow rise above without violence? Even the groundwork for Ghandi's peaceful protest were laid by a strong anti-colonial military force that led assassinations of British military officers. You think Britain left because Ghandi said some profound things and changed their minds? The official position was that continued occupation of India would be met by violent resistance and they retreated. There have been many many examples throughout history of oppressed people rising up with violence against their oppressors. The majority of the substantial changes in culture happen this way - things reach a boiling point and it spills out on the streets. I'm not saying mob justice is an ethical or principled way to instill change. But historically it has been extremely successful.
- tptacek 2y agoYes, I'm sure, in that it's mathematically incapable of solving the problem people have.
- perrygeo 2y agoBullshit. Show me the proof. Given that nearly all successful revolutions against oppressive powers have been backed by violence, I'm curious what you come up with. There is one group, the insurance companies, which have unequivocally stated that they will physically harm other people if it yields marginally higher profits. That's not up for debate, that's the stated business model. It is extra-judicial killing for profit, backed by the state. And when the state abuses their monopoly on power, history shows that people will claw it back as violently as they feel necessary.
- tptacek 2y agoThe proof is that you'd be going to war over a 5% discount in prices, and it's based on an accounting of where the money in our health system goes. Sorry, the numbers here are easy to find and they are unforgiving.
- amyames 2y ago> there's no serious theory of change that begins with murdering health care industry people. To be fair, we’ve never tried it.