4 ms·
Wait, it relies on email address? (quickly reads up on it.) ... and it doesn't have user identifiers other than the email address? That is not reasonable: norma
by saurik 14y ago
Wait, it relies on email address? (quickly reads up on it.) ... and it doesn't have user identifiers other than the email address? That is not reasonable: normal
people (as in, people who don't know much about what they are doing with computers) tend to have piles and piles of email addresses, none of which hold any canonical weight to them: they have email addresses from ISPs, from schools, from work, and they often have multiple email addresses from sevices like Gmail. If they lose track of one they just get another one (as email addresses aren't even important anyway), and they never remember which one they've used with any given site. I've even seen people purposely get a new email address every now and then as their way of dealing with spam and "people I don't want to talk to anymore". They don't think far ahead, so the notion that their email address from school will be retired a year after they graduate and given to someone else doesn't occur to them (and seemingly didn't occur to you either, as it undermines the argument that it is a reasonable way to do password resets): email addresses are about the worst possible (while still plausible) "unique" identifier you could have come up with. :( (And yes: this is coming from someone who has had a single canonical email address for over 15 years: I also run a popular website frequented by tens of millions of users, many of whom are non-technical customers, and I have had to realize that they are nothing like me.)
- geon 14y agoNot to mention that email is really unsecure. A password reset link will be sent as plaintext. Is there at least a way to change the email addredd associated with an account? I can't see anything about that.
- callahad 14y agoWhat password reset link? :) If you're using an email provider with native support for Persona, the only password you have is with your email provider.
- geon 14y agoAh. I hadn't realized it's using the mail server. http://lloyd.io/how-browserid-works http://lloyd.io/how-browserid-works
- etherealG 14y agowithout trying to add more complexity into the system, it would be nice if multiple accounts per email were possible. why not just link them together so any will work in place of another? not sure how you'd help someone find their account if they don't remember the email though.
- ollysb 14y agoHere's what would be great for users, being able to sign in with _any_ of their email addresses and passwords. If you could register all of your email addresses and passwords then login would become as easy as entering the first set of details you think of.
- ciex 14y agoThat's an interesting idea. How would you go about collecting all these emails first though? Would you tell the user to "just enter all email addresses you ever registered" and then send confirmation emails to all of them? I'd imagine this ending with one or two confirmed email addresses and maybe 3 additional unconfirmed ones. When the user then tries to use one of the unconfirmed addresses to sign in — what do you do? Refuse log in because the address is not confirmed? Send another confirmation email to that account and ask the user to confirm it? List those confirmed addresses in the account and ask the user if he wants to sign in with one of them?
- nileshtrivedi 14y agoNo need to send confirmation emails. Let him login with any email address. If the authentication is successful, you let him in. At this stage, it is a new account so give him an option to link this new account with his existing account with your service. If he had already provided all his email addresses with the first account, there is no need to authenticate one more time. Otherwise, simply authenticate once more with the original email and link the accounts if successful.