2 ms·
>Au contraire. Most executives will justify their pay packages by saying they shoulder all of the risk. Feels like a strawman, or at least a misunderstanding o
by gruez 2y ago
>Au contraire. Most executives will justify their pay packages by saying they shoulder all of the risk.
Feels like a strawman, or at least a misunderstanding of what "responsibility" is. Shareholders are willing to pay dearly for executives not because they need a fall guy in case something go wrong, they do so because someone in that position can easily fuck up the business, and therefore it's worth paying extra to get someone more qualified (at least in theory), so that doesn't happen. It's not any different than you not picking the cheapest guy on cragislist to housesit when you're on vacation. The premium isn't because you want a fall guy to sue in case your house burns down, it's so you don't end up with a guy who fucks up your house while you're away.
- thmsths 2y agoYou're assuming it must be one OR the other. Why can't it be both? If you're rewarded for your good decisions, it seems normal to also be punished for the bad ones, in a proportional manner.
- gruez 2y ago>Why can't it be both? I wasn't making a normative claim, only disagreeing with OP's characterization that executives' pay packages are justified by the threat of going to jail. >If you're rewarded for your good decisions, it seems normal to also be punished for the bad ones, in a proportional manner. FAANG engineers are paid pretty well. Should they go to jail (or even fined 5-6 figure sums) for bugs they're responsible for?
- thmsths 2y agoBugs are simply not comparable to losing 2 aircrafts and killing hundreds of people, furthermore FAANG engineers have little impact on the org individually. But we already have that kind of threats for malpractice in several fields, if an engineer or doctor makes a mistake resulting in injuries or death they will be held responsible financially and sometimes criminally.
- gruez 2y ago>Bugs are simply not comparable to losing 2 aircrafts and killing hundreds of people Software bugs caused 900 miscarriages of justice and "at least four suicides"[1]. The Crowdstirke bug caused millions of machines to go down and bililons in damage[2]. Sure, that might not compare to crashing 2 planes, but it feels entirely arbitrary to exclude those two cases. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal [2] https://www.cio.com/article/3478068/counting-the-cost-of-crowdstrike-the-bug-that-bit-billions.html https://www.cio.com/article/3478068/counting-the-cost-of-cro... >FAANG engineers have little impact on the org individually Sounds like the "Responsibility will turn out to be so diffuse that no individuals will be found to be liable" excuse a few comments up. FAANG engineers are 100% responsible for memory corruption bugs that they introduce.
- ipython 2y agoOne could argue the societal harm from social media could be directly linked to mass events such as https://www.wired.com/story/how-facebooks-rise-fueled-chaos-and-confusion-in-myanmar/ https://www.wired.com/story/how-facebooks-rise-fueled-chaos-..., https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0014292121001252 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00142..., and more. The diffuse nature of the after effects of faang engineers actions make them harder to prosecute, but potentially much more devastating than even the tragedy of two airline crashes.
- thmsths 2y agoI don't necessarily disagree (although it is extremely hard to quantify the effects of small but widespread harm). But what I am saying is that the FAANG engineer is NOT responsible. The CEO is.
- sensanaty 2y agoYou won't find me disagreeing with tossing Zucc in jail and losing the keys.
- lenerdenator 2y agoShareholders couldn't care less if someone fucks up the house. Most corporate shares in the US are held by retirement and pension funds. Those funds are run by people who are paid to make sure that they can divest from a position relatively quickly and with minimal loss in value. Many of them diversify their holdings and are perfectly fine with someone screwing the company so long as it bumps the number at quarter's end. Jack Welch is an excellent example of this. For further evidence, see how the market reacted to the murder of United Healthcare's CEO yesterday. The stock barely moved when the news broke and is still up for the month as of about half-an-hour ago. That's not the behavior of a market that sees the CEO as a watchful guardian of assets and a risk-bearer of corporate decisions; it's the behavior of a market that sees everyone as utterly disposable. The only reason they're down today is because speculators are beginning to worry that they'll run out of executives to refuse to enter into the marketplace of sane solutions to America's healthcare cost crisis.
- gruez 2y ago>Shareholders couldn't care less if someone fucks up the house. Most corporate shares in the US are held by retirement and pension funds. Those funds are run by people who are paid to make sure that they can divest from a position relatively quickly and with minimal loss in value. Many of them diversify their holdings and are perfectly fine with someone screwing the company so long as it bumps the number at quarter's end. Jack Welch is an excellent example of this. Activist investors and private equity are a counter to this. If it's really true that companies are ineptly run that all it takes is for someone who cares to turn it around, it should be easy to make a bunch of money by buying a company, exercising the tiniest of shareholder pressure over management, and then selling it after the company's turned around. Moreover, this strategy working would mean it's possible to get above average returns, which all institutional investors would be interested in. The board of Harvard isn't going to be very happy with their investment manager if Stanford is getting 1.5x returns by exercising good corporate governance. That's not to say corporate governance is prefect for all companies. The fact that activist investors exist at all suggests some companies at least are performing below average, but the claim that "Shareholders couldn't care less if someone fucks up the house" is delusional. >For further evidence, see how the market reacted to the murder of United Healthcare's CEO yesterday. The stock barely moved when the news broke and is still up for the month as of about half-an-hour ago. That's not the behavior of a market that sees the CEO as a watchful guardian of assets and a risk-bearer of corporate decisions; it's the behavior of a market that sees everyone as utterly disposable. counterpoint: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-08-13/new-starbucks-dream-ceo-swings-30-billion-in-market-value https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-08-13/new-starb...