11 ms·
I find this "double-dipping" nature of TV networks somewhat offensive. First, 50% of the programming is advertising (20 minutes content, 10 minutes ads). Then
by jrockway 14y ago
I find this "double-dipping" nature of TV networks somewhat offensive. First, 50% of the programming is advertising (20 minutes content, 10 minutes ads). Then, they make someone pay for the privilege of delivering that advertising to my house? It's completely nonsensical because DirectTV is providing Viacom with a valuable service: fucking satellites orbiting the earth! And then Viacom wants DirectTV to pay them. I just don't get it.
(My bank started doing the "double dip" thing too. Every item in my Bank of America statement now contains a "relevant" ad. I don't know why this bothers me, but it does. I already pay transaction fees and interest. Must you also try to show me irrelevant ads?)
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoSorry to be pedantic, but 20min content, 10min ads would be one third, not one half, of the programming.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 14y agoIt's one third of the total, but it's one half when added to the original.
- zaguios 14y agoThe correct way to say it would be there is a 2:1 ratio of content to advertising. By saying 50% of the programming is advertising you are including advertising in what you consider programming, making the statement false. This is still just nitpicking at the details, your original point is still valid.
- jim-greer 14y agoSo if there were 15 minutes of ads on a 30 minute show would you say their programming is 100% ads?
- dpark 14y agoDid you know that the human body is 150% water?
- Terretta 14y ago20 mins programming, 10 mins ads; ads are not programming, but are as long as 50% of the programming.
- dpark 14y ago> ads are not programming So then it's not 50%. It's 0%. "Hear that, HBO? Our programming has no ads at all!" 10/30 is not 50%. That's just completely broken math, and the people trying to justify the claim sound ridiculous.
- Terretta 14y agoYet 10 mins of ads to every 20 mins of programming makes ad time exactly 50% of the program time. Funny how that works.
- dpark 14y agoNo, it's not funny how it works, because it doesn't work like that. If the ads are not part of the programming, then there are 0 minutes of programming that are ads, and so 0/20 minutes of programming are ads, or 0% of the programming time is ads. On the other hand, if you consider ads part of the programming, then there are 10/30 minutes of programming that are ads, so about 33%. (It actually closer to 8/30, but whatever.) In no sane mathematical world does 10/30=50%. You're changing the definition of "programming" in the middle of your math, which doesn't work. You could say that the ads are "50% AS LONG as the program time", but this is different from your claim, and it's still much less clear than simply saying program to ads ratio is 2:1.
- Terretta 14y agoIn your rebuttal, you failed to quote me accurately: "Yet 10 mins of ads to every 20 mins of programming makes ad time exactly 50% of the program time." I have the word "time" after program, and the word "time" after ad. You and the others attacking jrockway are being deliberately obtuse when it was clear what he meant. Granted, he didn't express the "claim" as accurately as one would need if programming or writing a formula on a board. But hyperbole such as "in no sane mathematical world" falls flat if you can't quote accurately yourself. The formula you just tried to rebut was time a = 10 mins, time b = 20 mins, making a = b * .5 --quite sane.
- cududa 14y agoFor one, ads aren't the only revenue stream for network television, nor has it been for decades. Second, standard viewing time is 23 minutes and 7 of ads. How in the hell does 10 minutes of a 30 minute time slot equate to 50% of the programming schedule? Can you help me understand your math? Third, how in the hell is your BofA statement analogy relevant to anything? Is it your opinion that anytime you 'feel' something is done to you unjustly, it's all exactly the same?
- Terretta 14y ago20 mins programming, 10 mins ads; ads are not programming, but are as long as 50% of the programming. I thought his math was quite clear. (Think 50% markup, not 50% off.) And 23/7, 22/8, 20/10, 18/12, 17/13... There are shows with all these ratios.
- dpark 14y ago"50% of the programming is advertising" is not the same thing as "the advertising is 50% as long as the programming". The first includes advertising in the programming. Maybe this idiom works in some other languages, but not in English.
- S201 14y agoThe networks aren't "double-dipping". Your cable bill pays the cable provider and ads pay the content provider; different organizations, different sources of revenue. A much better explanation from a reddit commenter: http://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/pz8kz/til_cable_did_not_have_commercials_until_around/c3tgl2g?context=1 http://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/pz8kz/til_cab...
- res0nat0r 14y agoIt is a bit annoying around here lately that people are being downvoted for stating a fact. Sorry other people don't agree, but it doesn't make what you've cited wrong or not a valid comment.
- jrockway 14y agoThe disagreement is that DirectTV isn't paying Viacom enough money. ``Viacom wants more money, specifically, "a fee increase of more than 30 percent, amounting to more than $1 billion in additional costs over five years," according to Bloomberg.'' I'm not complaining about DirectTV charging customers, I'm complaining about Viacom charging DirectTV. If anything, DirectTV should be charging Viacom!
- TeMPOraL 14y ago> I'm not complaining about DirectTV charging customers, I'm complaining about Viacom charging DirectTV. If anything, DirectTV should be charging Viacom! But isn't it that DirectTV, cable companies, etc. have expensive infrastructure that is completely worthless without content to put through it? Whereas networks can always go somewhere else, find other ways to deliver their content? It would seem to me that DirectTV is more dependent on Viacom than the other way around - thus comes the direction of money flow.
- sgk284 14y agoUPS doesn't pay Amazon to deliver my goods. Viacom needs the largest audience possible to maximize ad revenue. It simply won't be able to make any content without the viewership. Viacom should be paying DirectTV for building the infrastructure to enable them to have larger viewership, enabling Viacom to have increased ad revenue. In other words, if I own a thousand content websites and monetize them by running my own ad network across them, it would be non-sensical for Google to pay me to use my websites in their index, even though Google would be useless without being able to link to websites.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoWhat's your satellite worth with nothing that people want to watch going through it?
- jrockway 14y agoNothing. What's your content worth if nobody can see it?
- waterlesscloud 14y agoQuite a bit since there's other routes of distribution. And there's why the sat company pays the content provider.
- corin_ 14y agoThere's also other content to put through their satellites though...
- fpgeek 14y agoIt's not really double-dipping. Plenty of the ads you get during the Daily Show are sold by your television provider (DirecTV, Comcast ...), not by Viacom. You could easily think of it as Viacom charging DirecTV for that valuable ad space (which they don't sell directly because it makes sense to let the TV provider customize a slide for its audience - usually local ads for cable, but I'm sure DirecTV has their levers, too).
- hyperbovine 14y agoYou should really consider a credit union. I haven't had a bad banking experience in 15 years. I could sit here for an hour writing about all the great ones I've had. Every time I heard these horror stories about Chase, BofA, etc. I just shake my head in amazement.
- jrockway 14y agoI don't bank with them anymore, I only have a credit card there that I use for all my recurring payments. (I use Schwab and AmEx for everything else. Not a credit union but good enough.)
- zanny 14y agoMandatory FSF Credit Card Plug: https://www.cardpartner.com/affinity/app/fsf https://www.cardpartner.com/affinity/app/fsf :P
- zimbatm 14y agoChrome is not supported... https://www-aolv44p.myappro.com/approonline/v44/umb/co/DenyBrowser.htm https://www-aolv44p.myappro.com/approonline/v44/umb/co/DenyB...
- nooneelse 14y agoSimilar feelings here. Each time a bank I've been with has been bought/merged into larger and larger ones, my side of the value exchange has been eroded. Most people's banking would benefit from a dose of subsidiarity.
- tokenadult 14y agoFirst, 50% of the programming is advertising (20 minutes content, 10 minutes ads). Is that a typo? Or hyperbole? Isn't ten minutes of advertising for every twenty minutes of programming what we call "33 percent advertising"?
- alexqgb 14y agoActually, a 22/8 split is the norm, making a half hour slot 26.6% ads.
- dvanduzer 14y agoOne could accurately say that the commercials during a traditional half hour television program are 50% as long as the show itself. Sometimes statistics lie, but more often they tell the truth in a fashion similar to a math test where every problem is designed to trick you.
- yaix 14y agoOr the programming is only the real content and ads are not content -> 50% of 20 minutes is 10 minutes.
- dpark 14y agoIf ads are not programming then they are zero percent of the programming, by definition. If you see three birds and four squirrels in your backyard, are the birds 75% of the squirrels? (Are the squirrels 133% of the birds?)
- keithwinstein 14y agoIt's an arms-length negotiation by sophisticated parties. Some cable channels (like CNN and ESPN) can command big fees from network operators because consumers expect that these channels will be available on a cable or satellite system. Some cable channels (like, probably, Animal Planet) have to pay the operator for the privilege of being carried. Some cable channels (like HBO) are able to produce higher-quality content _because_ they have the benefit of predictable revenue from subscriptions and are not as dependant on advertising or per-show viewership. But it doesn't do much to sit outside the negotiations and decide that you are offended by how the deal shakes out. Which way the money flows depends on the relative bargaining positions of the two parties. Yes, DirecTV is providing Viacom with a service -- operating the satellites and dealing with individual consumers and billing them. But Viacom is also providing DirecTV with a service: producing TV programs and channels (including Comedy Central) that consumers want to watch and are the reason they subscribe to DirecTV in the first place!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- batgaijin 14y agoI don't know, should Mconald's make blood pressure medicine?
- alanfang 14y agoThe same could be said for the internet. You pay for the connection but websites still show you advertisements.
- abraham 14y agoYour analogy would work if ISPs payed money to the websites but for the most part they don't.
- TheCondor 14y agoThe numbers are staggering, they pay for potential viewers too, not actual ones. Viacom pushes to have "basic cable" include their networks so they end up in more homes and then charge per home. Regardless of if they are even watched. We are ready for ala carte channel pricing or maybe metered pricing, thing is they know that 80% or more of their content is crap. Channel volume has been their big selling point. The true irony here is this is Viacom, dozens of crap networks all buoyed by literally, maybe, three shows... I haven't paid much attention for a while but dish and dtv also nickle and dime for locals, hd vs sd, the number of TVs etc. all while broadcasting maybe a dozen home shopping networks and who knows how many that have more than 8 hours of paid programming a day.
- yaix 14y ago> Must you also try to show me irrelevant ads? Its your choice.