2 ms·
> it most certainly would materially change your wealth and make you poor - their money would gravitate to equity, yours and your kids equity. Literally making
by WalterBright 2y ago
> it most certainly would materially change your wealth and make you poor - their money would gravitate to equity, yours and your kids equity. Literally making your poor.
That sounds like the "wealth is a fixed pie" theory, where for one person to have more, another must have less.
The proof that is false comes from the history of the US. In the 19th century, it was populated by poor immigrants with nothing more than a suitcase. The US turned into a global superpower. How do you explain that with the fixed pie theory?
- tossandthrow 2y ago> That sounds like the "wealth is a fixed pie" theory, where for one person to have more, another must have less. Dare to elaborate? And absolutely not. If anything, on the contrary, I say that equality is a way to make the pie bigger.
- WalterBright 2y ago> I say that equality is a way to make the pie bigger. Your idea has been tried, literally tens of thousands of times. The pie got smaller. Just in the US alone, 20,000 communes have been formed (they're not illegal). They all failed. Even the diehard communists can't stand living in a commune and sharing equally.
- tossandthrow 2y agoWhat idea? I never proposed any system to obtain equality, merely pointed out that equality as a quality in itself is worth striving for. A lot of people would argue that the American-style capitalism way is the way to obtain equality and I would not oppose that