4 ms·
I think of religions as instruction manuals for running societies, similar to the McDonalds handbook for running a McDonalds joint. So it is not surprising that
by Tichy 18y ago
I think of religions as instruction manuals for running societies, similar to the McDonalds handbook for running a McDonalds joint. So it is not surprising that different religions have different outcomes for societies.
Apart from the lack of data (the article is all just anecdotes, and I am also skeptic because Africa is so big and diverse), I refuse to belive that Christianity is the only way - there must be alternatives... And Christianity might have it's downsides, too - if the author is right maybe it would bring Africa out of an initial inertia, but at what cost for the long term?
- zby 18y agoAccording to Rene Girard there is one thing distinguishing Christianity among other religions - it is not sacrificial (that is not based on scapegoating) - or even it is anti-sacrificial by revealing the scapegoat victim is innocent. I am sure this is a too strong statement - as he could not analyze all existing religions - but the material that he did cover (myths and rituals) is very convincing for me. Personally I am an agnostic or even an atheist - but the more I read of Girard works the more I am convinced about the grand scale of the transformation Christianity has done to our European minds and culture.
- Tichy 18y agoThat's odd because the very word "scapegoat" seems to stem from Christianity. I remember attending a catholic funeral and being really put off when the preacher suddenly started talking about sending the scapegoat into the desert. However, I don't know much about it, never belonged to church and never received much of an education about Christianity. Also doesn't Christianity make a big deal about Jesus sacrificing himself? What exactly do you mean by sacrifices?
- zby 18y agoThat is a rather deep subject and the perhaps the best answer is to redirect you to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ren%C3%A9_Girard http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ren%C3%A9_Girard. But I'll try a short answer here: scapegoat is the name of a general social mechanism - according to Rene Girard it is a way to relieve the violent tention inside a human group. Originally it was with human sacrifices - but later it became ritualized - and one form of this ritualization was using goats in the Jewish religion. According to Girard Jesus was a scapegoat - but the Evangelies tell the story of the scapegoating from the point of view of it's victim - showing the whole injustice of it.
- Tichy 18y agoInteresting, although I must say I suspect he is projecting his own issues onto the world. Like "scapegoating" might have played a big role in his life, so he sees it everywhere (classical psychological mechanism). At least it never appeared so prominent to me, somehow I doubt that it is sufficient to build a theory of human societies.
- gruseom 18y agoThere's more to it than personal issues - it's one of the great socio-cultural insights of our time. Girard's argument is that human societies are originally based on violence and that this violence remains in ritualized form, though it is mostly no longer physical. If you are at all aware of how human communities tend to treat non-conformists, this mechanism won't seem so rare. It's a matter of noticing the symbolic and indirect forms that it takes. For me, it's a great insight because it calls each of us to be vigilant about our own capacity for violence, which goes a lot further than what we would normally label "violence". Edit: you made another interesting point: Also doesn't Christianity make a big deal about Jesus sacrificing himself? I know Girard argues that this is not the scapegoat mechanism but the ultimate exposure of the scapegoat mechanism. I remember thinking this is where he starts to get too clever in defence of his own religion. Certainly it's his cultural analyses, not his religious thought, for which Girard is widely respected. But I think also that his claims about Christianity are bound up with a vigorous defense of Western civilization that in the late 20th century was an intellectually courageous position to take.
- yters 18y agoI don't think that insight is original to Girard. Nietzsche reinterpretted morality along those lines, i.e. the slaves don't have anyone to vent their will to power on, so they vent it on themselves in the form of morality. Freud's development of the ego and id are also along these lines.
- gruseom 18y agoDon't know about originality, but I think you're painting with way too broad a brush there.
- gruseom 18y agoGirard was at Stanford when I was there, and I took one of his courses. He was charming and engaging. I remember once at some learned, oh-so-politically-correct talk he got up and made a comment to the effect that "it isn't allowed to criticize any culture at all, unless of course it's Western culture, and that you can only mention in order to [and here he stood up and kicked the air vigorously] KICK IT DOWN!" It was very refreshing - nobody except a star professor with the equivalent of fuck-you money in academic reputation could have gotten away with it. That being said, with all the respect I have for Girard, I could never escape the feeling that his analyses of Christianity were to a large extent thrice-removed expressions of his own Catholicism. This doesn't invalidate everything he says, but it made me skeptical of his grand theory.
- zby 18y agoAd. Girard and Catholicism - one interesting fact about that is that he started as an atheist (I cannot verify that right now by googling - but I remember it from somewhere) - only later he returned to religion.