3 ms·
It can't be "backwards". You can believe the effect is muted by the new-release window, such that for the majority of all titles --- let's say, for books, the m
by tptacek 2y ago
It can't be "backwards". You can believe the effect is muted by the new-release window, such that for the majority of all titles --- let's say, for books, the midlist titles --- a drastic reduction in the length of copyright wouldn't impact the comp authors would get from publishers. But you can't logically argue about the sign of the effect.
Meanwhile, virtually all of the copyright-driven industries are portfolio-based hit-seeking businesses. The comp for creators prices in some low (1-10%?) probability that a title will be a breakout success. Those returns would in fact be impacted by a drastic reduction in copyright terms.
Either way though: none of this matters. The point is that there isn't a logical argument for tying compensation to the lifespan of the author. Authors reap rewards today for returns on their IP that occur posthumously.
- reitzensteinm 2y agoI agree with you, and think copyright should be for a short period disconnected from the lifetime of the author, but _no logical argument_ is taking it way too far. Here's one: Copyright expiration during an author's lifetime directly impacts their incentive to make derivative works, because everyone else can do it too. In a world where Lustbader is churning out The Bourne Pontification, would Ludlum's own sequel be nearly as commercially successful? If the author is dead, no derivative works can be made, so we may no longer want this protection. Does this argument sway me personally? No. Are there workarounds like trademarks? Yes. Does (life + 20) make more sense than max(life,20)? No. But you're being needlessly black and white here.