5 ms·
How Typing Transformed Nietzsche's Consciousness
- exprofmaddy 2y agoThis story is also told in Nicholas Carr's bestseller 'The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains' https://www.nicholascarr.com/?page_id=16 https://www.nicholascarr.com/?page_id=16
- namaria 2y agoSmall nitpick > It took hold of human consciousness 3,000 years ago and changed it, with the written word representing thought itself. Writing is at least about 5500 years old.
- setopt 2y agoSounds like they count from approximately the origin of the first “alphabet” (including vowels), while writing itself is much much older. Btw, I recommend anyone who hasn’t looked at it before to read up a bit on the history of writing. It shocked me a bit that writing has only been independently invented 4 times in known human history (Egypt, Middle East, China, Mesoamerica), with all other writing systems being either inspired or derived from nearby systems. The English/Latin alphabet, for example, is a distant descendant of the Phoenician abjad, which itself was ultimately derived from Egyptian Hieroglyphs. Some traces are left today, like the letter “A” looking a bit like an up-side down bulls head with horns… because it actually descends from the hieroglyph for bull. Interestingly, Arab, Hebrew, and Indic scripts are all derived from the same Phoenician ancestor, despite how different they all look today…
- codpiece 2y agoThank you, this is fascinating! Do you have any recommended reading?
- setopt 2y agoUnfortunately, I don’t recall exactly which sources I read on this, it was many years ago. I just recall that it started as one of those “wild link chases” on Wikipedia and ended up deep in some downloaded textbook PDFs :) But I do recall enjoying diagrams such as this illustrating how different modern alphabets are related via historical counterparts (there are similar diagrams showing how Hebrew and Arabic emerges from Phoenician, as well as comparisons to runes): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brahmi_script#/media/File%3ASanskrit_Brhama_English_alphabets.jpg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brahmi_script#/media/File%3A... I also rather enjoyed reading about the history from Hieroglyphs, to Hieratic, to Phoenician (as well as Phoenician history in general). But unfortunately, don’t recall where. Start with Wikipedia :)
- codpiece 2y agoThanks! I used to have an old dictionary that traced the evolution of the letters, it was quite cool. There is a book 'Textual Scholarship' by Greetham that goes deep on the more modern letterforms like Uncial. I haven't cracked that in a while.
- rpastuszak 2y ago> Interestingly, Arab, Hebrew, and Indic scripts are all derived from the same Phoenician ancestor, despite how different they all look today… Same with Thai or... Mongolian - a not so distant cousin of Aramaic! The fun thing about Mongolian is that to notice its similarity to Aramaic, you'll need to tilt your head by 90 degrees. Compare this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongolian_script#/media/File:M_injinash.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongolian_script#/media/File:M... With this: https://www.avesta.org/fonts/index.html https://www.avesta.org/fonts/index.html Now look at the first picture again and tilt your head. I’m a bit embarrassed to admit that, although I studied Middle Persian and Avestan (both of which rely on a variant of Aramaic), it took me almost 15 years to notice that. Now, it’s impossible to unsee.
- namaria 2y ago> It shocked me a bit that writing has only been independently invented 4 times in known human history In the middle east alone there are several ancestral writing systems that can't be traced to a single origin.
- setopt 2y agoSource and examples? Note the focus on "independently" invented, and that I said "inspired or derived from nearby systems". There are many examples of writing systems that were made "from scratch" but only after contact with other civilizations that were already writing - e.g. the Korean Hangeul was designed from scratch, but only after millenia of Chinese literacy in Korea; and the Cherokee syllabary was designed from scratch, but only after centuries of contact with Western colonizers including access to their existing writing tools. If this is the kind of process you meant you meant with "multiple ancestral alphabets", I completely agree. But those were not "independent" inventions of "writing" as a concept. The idea of denoting ideas/sounds on paper is much harder to invent than the specific symbols mapped to each idea/sound. My understanding is that the consensus in the literature is that all writing systems in the Middle East were either derived from an existing writing system, or created from scratch after prolonged contact with neighboring civilizations that could already write, where these historical lines can be drawn all the way back to Hieroglyphs and Cuneiform. I believe there is little evidence to suggest multiple inventions of writing as a concept by isolated groups in the region. As for major writing systems that are still in use today across Europe, North Africa, the Middle East, and much of Asia, there's even less variety: I believe most of them are ultimately descended from Phoenician.
- madaxe_again 2y agoYes, however Sumer were unique in hitting upon the idea of glyphs representing sounds, rather than ideograms, which seem to develop fairly frequently and independently. It did take the better part of 1500 years for them to make that breakthrough, but the result was enormous, and allowed the storage and transmission of information with much greater efficiency and nuance.
- jauntywundrkind 2y ago> To be precise, he purchased a top-of-the-line portable Malling-Hansen writing ball, which was sent specially to him from its inventor in Copenhagen. Wikiepdia link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hansen_Writing_Ball https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hansen_Writing_Ball
- etyp 2y agoNietzsche is a very interesting example since there is a very obvious shift in his philosophy from The Birth of Tragedy to, say, The Gay Science. I understand the argument that the style of writing noticeably changes, and I'd be okay attributing that to "automated writing," but a lot of the shift in Nietzsche's work feels like a pretty drastic shift in ideology. I'm not convinced that shift entirely, or even largely, comes from the shift in medium.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- _yb2s 2y agoI wouldn’t consider it a shift as much as a development- he kept landing on new ideas that built on his previous ones. Focusing on his writing style rather than the ideas themselves feels a bit like bikeshedding to me. He claims he would come up with most of his ideas on walks and only later sit down to write about them- the process, according to him, was not central to the development of the philosophy- only the surface level presentation of it.
- killjoywashere 2y agoTyping has a certain reward function to it: that snap-snap-snap is satisfying. I wonder if he just got addicted to it?
- rationalfaith 2y ago[dead]
- quantadev 2y agoFor someone who writes all day every day, their ability to explore ideas is somewhat limited by the speed of their writing mechanism (hand v.s. machine), because they're not really "just sitting and thinking" most of the time but trying to "capture each thought" before moving to the next idea, which is laborious and slow. So simply by being able to move faster along the process means you can fit more ideas into your short term memory, because you're traversing thru the ideas at a faster rate. Once you can fit more ideas in, then each idea can have room to become more complex. I think that's the "mechanism" (pun intended) by which your consciousness/intelligence improves simply by being able to write faster. It's probably partially also why stimulant drugs can make people appear more intelligent. The faster you move thru ideas, the more information you can fit into working/reasoning memory. It's the same thing as lengthening the "context window" in an LLM btw.
- golly_ned 2y agoI don't think this holds. That means given we have fast typists, our thinkers today should be way better than the ones who wrote by quill and ink. I don't think that's the case.
- quantadev 2y agoI think for mathematicians and certain fields, reading/writing can be slow without effecting productivity, or creativity, but when it comes to a "writer", speed is key. But you make a good point, because for example Newton invented Calculus but only had a quill.
- ahmedfromtunis 2y agoThe author dedicated more than 95% of the article to telling us that the typewriter changed Nietzsche's consciousness, but only a few sentences to vaguely describe what those changes were. And even then, what was described was more of a stylistic element, rather than a substantial one. I would've loved to see more concrete examples of the evolution of Nietzsche's writings and ideas pre- and post-typewriter adoption, and maybe what does that mean for Nietzsche's legacy as a whole.
- dang 2y agoThis article might be better: Friedrich Nietzsche and his Typewriter – a Malling-Hansen Writing Ball http://www.malling-hansen.org/friedrich-nietzsche-and-his-typewriter-a-malling-hansen-writing-ball.html http://www.malling-hansen.org/friedrich-nietzsche-and-his-ty... (via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6100076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6100076, but no comments there)
- quantadev 2y agoYeah the title was a little Click-Baity, compared to what it really contained.
- madaxe_again 2y agoI think it’s far more likely that his blindness influenced his writing style than his choice of writing implement. If you can’t go back and read what you just wrote, it results in a concision of thought - formulate a sentence in your mind, transcribe. Repeat. When you can read back what you’re writing, it lends much more scope for punning, for long, tangential sentences - as the paper becomes your short term memory. This holds particularly true for a not only blind but aging mind, with a slowly diminishing capacity for short-term recall. So, did the typewriter turn him into a machine-man? No. His blindness mandated a modification to his mode of expression, and the transcription technology he chose. I can’t help but think of the allegory of the tightrope walker and the jester, reading this.
- stuart73547373 2y agoi thought he was only blind in one eye
- _yb2s 2y agoThis is only an analysis of the surface level presentation style of Nietzsches work… not the ideas themselves, which he claimed he came up with while walking, not while writing. I can’t help but suspect that the author was unable to understand or evaluate the ideas themselves- which has been mostly the case with all of the English language translations as well- it’s hard to understand a translation when the translator did not. Carl Jungs seminar on Zarathustra is in my opinion the best presentation and analysis of Nietzsche’s ideas in English- because Jung actually understood them.
- HKH2 2y agoHow should one read Nietzsche without learning German?
- _yb2s 2y agoThere are no really easy answers there... What I referenced above is the book I recommend, "Jung's Seminar on Nietzsche's Zarathustra." It is a transcription of academic lectures Carl Jung gave on Nietzsche- where he offers his own semi-translation and interpretation of the meaning. I cannot think of a non-arrogant way to say this, so won't try (Nietzsche sure wouldn't have): but Nietzsche was an extremely smart person with subtle ideas, and most people- including academic translators that are supposed to be experts on his work, simply cannot understand his ideas, and therefore cannot translate them properly. One needs to be able to relate to his ideas from personal experience and (for lack of a better word) spiritual development, and also be able to appreciate complex nuance to really get it. This is confounded by the fact that Nietzsche had an obtuse style on purpose- he actively wanted his work to be exclusive, and not easily understandable, and actually often tried to be misleading or confusing on purpose. Carl Jung had a deep understanding of Nietzsche, that none of the English language translators have. I have read all of his work, and it took me quite a while, including reading Jung's seminars to really feel I could grasp the bigger picture of his ideas. And once I did, I could clearly see that the translators who had translated and commented on his work were really only getting at the surface, and not really understanding- and then also choosing the wrong words when translating as a result, which was making it even harder to understand. Also, if you are going to directly read his work, don't read Zarathustra first as it is an especially hard read- it is written in the style of an ancient religious text and not philosophy- The Gay Science would probably be my recommendation.
- medo-bear 2y agoOf course, Nietzschean teaching is not identical with the official ideology of Hitlerism. It cannot be because Nietzsche stopped thinking on the eve of imperialism: for him the age of imperialist barbarism is still a dream of the future, while fascist ideology arose as a repulsive product of decay of developed imperialism. This difference in periods also determines the difference in intellectual and aesthetic level. Nietzsche is a man of broad and varied culture, in contrast to the ignorance of Hitler or Goering, the boastful half-education of a Rosenberg or Goebbels; For all his mannerisms, he is a witty and important stylist who – albeit often problematically – has nevertheless worked creatively in language, in contrast to the barbarization and rape of the German language under Hitlerian tyranny. In addition, one could also point out many individual deviations. Nietzsche always despised anti-Semitism. Despite all these conceptual, aesthetic, and moral differences, Rosenberg rightly named Nietzsche the ancestor of German fascism. For Nietzsche carried the glorification of barbarism into German philosophy, and the more justly one assesses his intellectual abilities, his cultural-critical work, the more clearly one must see that the change he made created the basis for that reactionary development in German ideology, from which fascism then drew its intellectual arsenal. - George Lukacs, Nietzsche and Nazism
- ValentinA23 2y agoIn other words, only he who acknowledges unflinchingly and without any reservations that murder is under no circumstances to be sanctioned can commit the murderous deed that is truly — and tragically — moral. To express this sense of the most profound human tragedy in the incomparably beautiful words of Hebbel’s Judith: “Even if God had placed sin between me and the deed enjoined upon me — who am I to be able to escape it?” “Tactics and Ethics” – 1919 … we Communists are like Judas. It is our bloody work to crucify Christ. But this sinful work is at the same time our calling: only through death on the cross does Christ become God, and this is necessary to be able to save the world. We Communists then take the sins of the world upon us, in order to be able thereby to save the world. Quoted in Daniel Lopez, "The Conversion of Georg Lukács" Dionysus versus the “Crucified” there you have the antithesis. It is not a difference in regard to their martyrdom—it is a difference in the meaning of it. Life itself, its eternal fruitfulness and recurrence, creates torment, destruction, the will to annihilation. In the other case, suffering—the “Crucified as the innocent one”—counts as an objection to this life, as a formula for its condemnation.—One will see that the problem is that of the meaning of suffering: whether a Christian meaning or a tragic meaning. In the former case, it is supposed to be the path to a holy being; in the latter case, being is counted as holy enough to justify even a monstrous amount of suffering. The tragic man affirms even the harshest suffering ... Dionysus cut to pieces is a promise of life: it will be eternally reborn and return again from destruction. The will to power
- StefanBatory 2y agoI remember reading about this in the past, but wasn't the main reason for this his syphilis and not the typewriter?