2 ms·
As always, and tediously, I want to remind people that the lifetime of the artist should largely be irrelevant in thinking about rewarding the creation of new w
by tptacek 2y ago
As always, and tediously, I want to remind people that the lifetime of the artist should largely be irrelevant in thinking about rewarding the creation of new works. An author writes their most lucrative bestseller when they're 20 years old, makes K dollars; another author writes their most lucrative book at 75, makes N dollars. Why are K and N different? The answer today is mostly that they're not, because the lifespan of the copyright itself is taken into account when compensating the author. Without that system, the 75-year-old author would earn drastically less than the 20-year-old, despite creating the same value.
- alistairSH 2y agoI'm confused... Are you saying the future value of the copyright is priced into the retail sales price of the book and/or % of that paid back to the author (or their estate) as royalties?
- andrewla 2y agoThey are saying that when an author is looking to sell the rights to their work, the price of that work is discounted based on the expected lifetime of the author. So in a parallel universe where the same work is written by a 20 year old and an 80 year old, the 20-year-old artist can sell the perpetual rights for more than the 80-year-old because the new rights holder will get 60 years of protection in the former case and only 10 years in the latter case. I don't think I agree with the GP on the conclusion, but this part anyway seems logically sound to me.
- alistairSH 2y agoHmmmm, need to think through this a bit. Most authors earn more from royalties than anything else, so when discussing "rewarding the creation of new works", that's where my mind went.
- tptacek 2y agoRight, but those royalties are based on the value the copyright owners derive from holding the copyright.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoI think that's backwards. The vast majority of all creative works make no significant profit past the first couple years of release. Publishers pay out based on what they estimate the work is going to make in the first couple of years, and discount the rest to 0. The publisher might know that the work of a 75 year old might actually have some back catalog value, so might be willing to pay for it. For a 20 year old, they don't know that and aren't going to pay for it, even if the copyright they're buying likely has a much longer time frame. If you used a 30 or 40 year old as your young example, I might buy the argument. Taylor Swift's back catalog as a 30 year old is worth hundreds of millions. Taylor Swift's back catalog as a 20 year old likely had an expected value close to zero, and there are very few 20 year olds as successful as Taylor Swift was at that age.
- tptacek 2y agoIt can't be "backwards". You can believe the effect is muted by the new-release window, such that for the majority of all titles --- let's say, for books, the midlist titles --- a drastic reduction in the length of copyright wouldn't impact the comp authors would get from publishers. But you can't logically argue about the sign of the effect. Meanwhile, virtually all of the copyright-driven industries are portfolio-based hit-seeking businesses. The comp for creators prices in some low (1-10%?) probability that a title will be a breakout success. Those returns would in fact be impacted by a drastic reduction in copyright terms. Either way though: none of this matters. The point is that there isn't a logical argument for tying compensation to the lifespan of the author. Authors reap rewards today for returns on their IP that occur posthumously.
- reitzensteinm 2y agoI agree with you, and think copyright should be for a short period disconnected from the lifetime of the author, but _no logical argument_ is taking it way too far. Here's one: Copyright expiration during an author's lifetime directly impacts their incentive to make derivative works, because everyone else can do it too. In a world where Lustbader is churning out The Bourne Pontification, would Ludlum's own sequel be nearly as commercially successful? If the author is dead, no derivative works can be made, so we may no longer want this protection. Does this argument sway me personally? No. Are there workarounds like trademarks? Yes. Does (life + 20) make more sense than max(life,20)? No. But you're being needlessly black and white here.
- lmm 2y ago> Without that system, the 75-year-old author would earn drastically less than the 20-year-old, despite creating the same value. Less perhaps, but drastically less? You'd need to justify that. Even big hits generally make most of their money in their first few years. And creating the same value is also a claim you'd need to justify. Maybe society legitimately prefers works from younger authors; maybe a work from a live author really is more valuable than a dead one. Maybe there are unique things that a living author can do with an in-copyright work they wrote in the past, that increase the value of that work, and we want to incentivise those things.