8 ms·
AI helps researchers dig through old maps to find lost oil and gas wells
- thuuuomas 2y agoThe negative tone of some comments here betrays that techno optimist suggestion that tech will solve environmental issues. Clearly, the incentives just aren’t there!
- DrillShopper 2y agoTech has caused more and worse environmental issues than it has ever solved.
- juujian 2y agoSad thing is that researchers and NGOs are policing away at old wells on a shoestring budget while the original operators have made off with lots of money. Extract the profits, socialize the damages...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Dah00n 2y agoWell, that is the American way.
- juggyjutt5 2y ago[flagged]
- BlueTemplar 2y agoAlbert, such a helpful guy !
- m3kw9 2y ago[flagged]
- heyitsguay 2y agoAI gonna help identify forgotten environmental hazards.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- postepowanieadm 2y agoOne day, when I have too much time and too much money, I will make a roguelike with map converted from old maps.
- schlauerfox 2y agoDon't let dreams be dreams, start small, the minimum. One map, one screen. Just a toy for yourself. A little effort expended repeatedly yields compound interest.
- physhster 2y ago[flagged]
- cpursley 2y agoAs if the outgoing one doesn’t also need shitloads of energy? Airforce 1 and The Beast don’t run on butterfly wings…
- twojacobtwo 2y agoI think the parent post was referring to the anti-environmentalist aspect of the new administration. They're not going fund remediation efforts while attempting to dismantle the EPA.
- physhster 2y agoThis is to cap forgotten wells, not exploit them again...
- LinuxBender 2y agoAlso worth checking the unforgotten ones. When I was a child my grandparents would take me to one of the beaches that had many capped wells and we would kick the rusted lid off and throw rocks inside for the sounds. Either that or they were eye-balling it to see if I would fit.
- cpursley 2y agoWild! LA? Are there ever beach caveins?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bastloing 2y agoYeah they're pro AI and pro business. Sounds about right.
- karim79 2y agoThat's the ticket! I've always known that AI will save us all.
- alephnerd 2y agoThe same methods have also been used to identify archeological sites [0]! [0] - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-36015-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-36015-5
- spydum 2y agoI think this is cool but this is mostly being used to find leaky old forgotten wells. Not tap unused or forgotten wells. This is purely risk avoidance, which usually means it won't get much attention or funding.
- alephnerd 2y ago> which usually means it won't get much attention or funding Leaky wells are a legal and insurance liability, which has a downstream impact on the financing of a drilling project.
- dowager_dan99 2y agoThey are also a huge, unfunded public liability in many jurisdictions, like mine (Alberta). Companies disappear but their rec-rem responsibilities last forever.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoYou have to find them to make the case to fund the remediation. Quantify, calculate, and communicate the risk and cost, then action.
- dylan604 2y agoFine them at rates that dwarf whatever cost it would take to fix them. That would be the motivation necessary. Tell them they have 30 days after being notified before the fines start. Someone else on some other thread mentioned the ideas of exponentially increasing fines. Do that here. Of course, the company has to still exist
- Dah00n 2y ago>Of course, the company has to still exist The system in place in the US means they mostly do not. A fund holding the amount of money it would take to clean up whatever you do on the land should be mandatory. Leave the land as — or better — than you bought it. Of course, that's very un-American.
- jofer 2y agoThis is super useful, but it's a bit disappointing to see map digitization called "AI". I mean, sure, these are methods broadly in the computer vision realm and that gets referred to as "AI" sometimes. But at the end of the day, this is "find all unfilled black circles of a specified diameter on these images". It's amenable to (and has been done by) traditional computer vision methods for a long time. There are certainly a lot of cases where a CNN type approach can perform better than traditional computer vision and there are always improvements to make. However, I think it's a bit odd to treat this type of use case as some sort of AI breakthrough that wasn't possible or wasn't frequently done in the past. Why can't normal standard work have a press release? Why do we need to play pretend and add buzzwords just to make things sound "cool"? ...But that's just me being a bit bitter, perhaps...
- lovich 2y ago> Why can't normal standard work have a press release? Why do we need to play pretend and add buzzwords just to make things sound "cool"? > ...But that's just me being a bit bitter, perhaps... Were you complaining as heavily about OCR or Markov chains ever being referenced as AI in their hay day? The term “AI” is in an infinite treadmill and the day it stops being useable as a time sensitive reference is probably the day it surpasses humanity and becomes its own State
- a_wild_dandan 2y agoYou can make highly accurate predictions of what contrarians will say by assuming that they define AI as "whatever computers can't do yet." LLMs aren't truly intelligent. [No True Scotsman fallacy...] They don't really reason. [A distinction asserted without giving a falsifiable definition of reasoning...] They're just next token predictors! [Which must be mutually exclusive with intelligence, I suppose?] Etc, etc, etc. Find your favorite pretext to dismiss modern AI, ignore the holes in the argument, and satisfyingly conclude that it's all smoke and mirrors. Consequently you see hilarious takes from skeptics, like comparing today's enormous investment in AI to when people sold blockchain cartoon monkeys. Or claiming that modern models aren't useful for anything, as if they exist in an alternative reality where hundreds of million of people don't use them daily, and there's no incessant firehose of new tools/products/results discussed in news/social media constantly.
- hilbert42 2y agoIt seems to me this approach could also be used for other aspects of mining. For instance, in Australia where I live there are many old gold, opal and other mines that have long been forgotten but which remain dangerous. Most are unlikely to emit toxic or greenhouse gasses but they're nevertheless still dangerous because they're often very deep vertical shafts that a person could stumble across and fall in. These old mines were likely closed over when they were abandoned but often their closures/seals were made of wood that has probably rotted away over the past century or so. It stands to reason that AI would be just as effective in this situation.
- mschuster91 2y ago> Most are unlikely to emit toxic or greenhouse gasses but they're nevertheless still dangerous because they're often very deep vertical shafts that a person could stumble across and fall in. That's a problem in Germany as well [1] - particularly in NRW, where most of Germany's mining activity is concentrated for centuries. About two or three times a week an old shaft collapses somewhere in Germany, leading to sinkholes - there's tens of thousands old mine shafts in the country and information on a lot of the legal ones got lost in one of the two world wars, and on top of these come quite the lot of illegal operations. Usually the damage is in some remote area, some forest or whatnot, but in some rare cases, entire buildings vanish or have to be condemned. [1] https://www.stern.de/gesellschaft/bergbauschaeden--zehntausende-alte-stollen-sind-einsturzgefaehrdet-7937914.html https://www.stern.de/gesellschaft/bergbauschaeden--zehntause...
- creshal 2y agoAnd for a long time, it was legal to have fun constructs like "so the mine entrance goes horizontal for a bit until the main shaft starts right under the local orphanage", so sinkholes can be all sorts of fun.
- HdS84 2y agoIn Mendig (Eifel) there is an enormous mine for millstones which was in us for the whole middle age until the 19th century or so. Most people just dug down from their Celler and the whole city stands on enormous caverns.
- dukeofdoom 2y agoHow long until AI can dig through old rabbit holes and come out with Mossad connected US politicians?
- jaggederest 2y agoThis is a fun thing to think about - historical reconstruction. In the extreme, you end up with something like Accelerando[1]'s "resimulated" people - people recreated and resimulated in full fidelity from any and all available history, but who may never have actually existed. A bit like an AI hallucinating people. [1] https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelerando/accelerando.html https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/acceler...
- eichin 2y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8QWxJhna8Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8QWxJhna8Y shows off some of the efforts of https://welldonefoundation.org/ https://welldonefoundation.org/ to actually do something once they find them - which also puts more emphasis on the abandonment part (specifically the industry irresponsibility involved in allowing them to become hazards in the first place.)
- bluSCALE4 2y agoPeople should be confronted and shamed if their ancestors did this and they won't do right by them.
- oaththrowaway 2y agoWhy do I get the blame and shame for something my grandparents might have done wrong?
- agf 2y agoIf and only if you are still benefiting from that wrong, or others are still suffering for it.
- tharkun__ 2y agoThat's a very slippery slope. How do you define "benefit"? Your dad swindled thousands of "investors" out of their retirements and left you millions. You are benefiting from this and the children of the "investors" are suffering. Your great-grand-dad swindled thousands of "investors" out of their retirements and you inherit a business empire. You are benefiting from this and the hundreds of great-grand-children of the "investors" are also suffering. They could've had inheritances but they didn't and work at Walmart. You can trace your lineage to Thomas Jefferson who apparently owned 600 slaves over his lifetime. You still benefit from him having been a president and a wealthy man. You should have to trace ancestry of those slaves and compensate their current living family members.
- bluSCALE4 2y agoThough headlines like these annoy me since we, the people, are being pressured to change our way of life when there are bigger fish to fry, I'm glad we trying to fix things within our control. Things like this shouldn't even be studied, they should be addressed aggressively and fixed so we can get a clearer picture of what we as individuals are responsible for.
- pjc50 2y agoStudy is the necessary predecessor to fixing.
- candlemas 2y agoI don't know what they mean by AI but this reminds me of an old fortune: *** Special AI Seminar (abstract) It has been widely recognized that AI programs require expert knowledge in order to perform well in complex domains. But knowledge alone is not sufficient for some applications; wisdom is needed as well. Accordingly, we have developed a new approach to artificial intelligence which we call "wisdom engineering". As a test of our ideas, we have written IMMANUEL, a wisdom based system for the task domain of western philosophical thought. IMMANUEL was supplied initially with 200 wisdom units which contained wisdom about such elementary concepts as mind, matter, being, nothingness, and so forth. IMMANUEL was then allowed to run freely, guided by the heuristic rules contained in its heterarchically organized meta wisdom base. IMMANUEL succeeded in rediscovering most of the important philosophical ideas developed in western culture over the course of the last 25 centuries, including those underlying Plato's theory of government, Kant's metaphysics, Nietzsche's theory of value, and Husserl's phenomenology. In this seminar, we will describe IMMANUEL's achievements and internal architecture. We will also briefly discuss our recent efforts to apply wisdom engineering to oil exploration.
- 1kaizen 2y ago[flagged]
- yieldcrv 2y agoIf anybody likes treasure hunting, there are lots of lost gold mines too You can come across the land parcel claims sometimes by families that don’t have the capital to mine
- rwmj 2y agoI found out Red Hat is now using AI to dig through git commits in large upstream projects to find out what new features were added and removed, to direct downstream QE efforts. It's done with a human review afterwards. Kind of interesting, not sure yet how well it'll work in practice.
- throwaway2037 2y ago> downstream QE efforts What does this phrase mean?
- rwmj 2y agohttps://www.redhat.com/en/blog/what-open-source-upstream https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/what-open-source-upstream
- uz44100 2y agoAI seems to be everywhere these days. That was gonna happen one day. This is gonna be really interesting in coming days.
- _heimdall 2y agoWe really need a more clear definition of what "AI" means. What the article describes sounds like it could have been built with 10 year old image processing tools and basic algorithms crunching the large amount of sensor data used to identify potential wells. What makes this tool AI rather than an algorithm? Or machine learning?
- acdha 2y agoComputer vision is AI, it’s just not an LLM: a computer is performing work like our brains do. Your argument is basically what Bertram Raphael was saying in the 1970s: “AI is a collective name for problems which we do not yet know how to solve properly by computer”.
- gosub100 2y agoSome CV is AI, like "identify pictures of cats", but not straightforward filters in an algorithm such as "narrow the bands of visible light to those that make existing mineshafts stand out, then scan the entire continent recording the top 20% of matches for this value (with some wiggle room to account for variants)". That is very much manual intelligence
- lm28469 2y agoIt's simple: AI is what you call it when it's useless / when you don't know what you're talking about / when you're looking for investors money. When it becomes useful it gains a name, like "computer vision", "machine learning", "natural language processing", "image generator"
- _heimdall 2y ago> Researchers used the AI algorithm to scour four counties of interest that had substantial early oil production – Los Angeles and Kern counties in California, and Osage and Oklahoma counties in Oklahoma – and found 1,301 potential undocumented orphaned wells. So far, researchers have verified 29 of the UOWs using satellite images and another 15 from surveys in the field; It would be really helpful if they called out how many potential wells were inspected and couldn't be verified. Are they confirming at 100% or 10%?
- dc0848 2y agoCould it help me find my keys I lost this morning?:))
- TuringTourist 2y agoThere is a (likely small) chance that you lost your keys in an unknown or lost oil/gas well. So yes, in theory.
- fulafel 2y agoAs we regulate AI with concerns energy and emissions, wouldn't this be the low hanging fruit to forbid first?
- reflectiv 2y agoI was a developer at Shell a couple years back and led a project where we were using nascent GPT-1/2 to process and search over mountains of documents. It was a fun project where I wrote a complex/fancy UI for a stratigraphic filter and indexing system... Seems this is just a natural progression...neat.
- tikkun 2y agoThat's pretty cool that Shell was such an early adopter. Who led the adoption of GPT-1/2 there - a developer, you, a VP, someone else?
- reflectiv 2y agoAI in general at the time was led by a VP and a particular group (that was AI tech specialized) under him. The initial idea came about from them. We were trying to find new ways of using AI to research new sources of crude at the time. Another AI project I worked on there was a chemical tank use estimation and refuel application which used tank sensors, previous use history and some other metrics to pre-purchase and deliver product to keep tank reserves above a certain threshold. For context, all of this was circa 2018-2021.
- tikkun 2y agoThank you for answering!