3 ms·
The most effective propaganda has an element of the truth in it. The usual tech argument I see in cases like this are about how important encryption is and how
by ben_w 2y ago
The most effective propaganda has an element of the truth in it.
The usual tech argument I see in cases like this are about how important encryption is and how that can't be given up for law enforcement. That doesn't work so well here, because Telegram doesn't really have a good E2E encryption setup, just the reputation for it.
But even where that argument does hold, people being people, it's completely coherent for 90% of politicians to believe that this specific crime is genuinely the real cause, when the actual cause is something know only to ministers aware of certain state secrets.
For example, compare and contrast:
1. If the real reason is "this specific government is actually banana republic", governments doing this is bad and allows their preferred people to engage in further corruption and destabilisation of said government while spying freely on anyone who would oppose them.
2. If the real reason is "there's several dozen foreign governments and organised criminal groups who are all using platforms like these to try to destabilise us", then it's important to lie about it as much as possible so that those foreign governments and organised criminal groups don't catch on.
Encryption that a nation can't break, does not merely enable free association to organise democratically against the nation, it really does also allow various crimes against the laws of a nation. That includes this specific crime, but that being true doesn't require this specific crime to be the real reason behind the push.
I have absolutely no idea how this is all going to play out. States can't really function long-term if they permit encryption they themselves can't break, it's not stable; at the same time, economies can't function without encryption that foreign states can't break because that's unstable in a different way. And then there's smart dust, coming soon to paint tins near you.
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> If the real reason is "there's several dozen foreign governments and organised criminal groups who are all using platforms like these to try to destabilise us", then it's important to lie about it as much as possible so that those foreign governments and organised criminal groups don't catch on. If this was the real reason then they couldn't be advocating for bills to compromise the security of those systems, because the actual bad guys can perform logical deduction and conclude that the same compromises could be used against them and then switch to some other system. > States can't really function long-term if they permit encryption they themselves can't break, it's not stable This has been the case for quite some time and it's not only completely fine but in line with historical norms. Historically governments didn't have the capacity to intercept communications en masse, and the majority of communication took place in person with no record of what was said outside of the minds of the people in the room. Meanwhile targeted interception will always be available because governments can, in the limit, physically install bugs to record the target's conversations or passwords. And to the extent that you're dealing with a sophisticated adversary that knows how to scan for bugs, you're well past the point that legislating backdoors in messaging apps is relevant because a sophisticated adversary can use already-existent open source messaging systems without them.