2 ms·
I don't see what they are trying to achieve with free access here. Probably the same thing they're trying to achieve with free streets, trees, parks, and so on
by jrockway 14y ago
I don't see what they are trying to achieve with free access here.
Probably the same thing they're trying to achieve with free streets, trees, parks, and so on: making the city more livable for those that pay taxes there. (And trust me, we pay a lot of taxes.)
- ChuckMcM 14y agoFair enough, I think you can make a reasonable argument that network communication is a basic city service like sewers and sidewalks, so why wouldn't that argument also require a taxpayer funded phone service? If you go the whole basic service argument then not only do you provide a wifi hotspot but you also provide a way for someone to browse the web, send and receive email, and maybe chat at these same kiosks. If you don't provide that then you run into the social justice argument that you are discriminating against the poor who can't afford a smartphone or laptop to hop onto the 'free' WiFi in favor of the rich. Whereas if you charge for the access and dump that money into the general fund (after expenses of course) then its a service fee that achieves a socially acceptable taxation of people with more disposable income to provide services to those without. So do you see my confusion?
- jrockway 14y agoAll I can tell you is that's not how the world works. My taxes pay for a ton of things I can't use; I don't have a car, so I can't drive through the Lincoln Tunnel. That doesn't mean it's not in society's best interest to pay for it anyway.
- apgwoz 14y agoWoah! I didn't realize you were a New Yorker! If you can make it, you should come by the next Hack and Tell on the 25th! http://meetup.com/hack-and-tell http://meetup.com/hack-and-tell
- jrockway 14y agoYeah, I moved here in January :) Hack and Tell sounds pretty cool, I'll try to be there. Thanks for the invite!