3 ms·
Splash pads are fountains of fecal material; CDC reports 10K illnesses
- taeric 2y agoI can't bring myself to be surprised on this? It turns out, animals have default behavior that is just not healthy. Humans aren't specifically bad on this, I don't think? Excited to see studies on how well different intervention strategies work.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bookofjoe 2y ago>Assessment of Enteric Pathogen Shedding by Bathers during Recreational Activity and its Impact on Water Quality (March 2000) https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1010000230103?cjdata=MXxOfDB8WXww&utm_medium=affiliate&utm_source=commission_junction&utm_campaign=CONR_BOOKS_ECOM_GL_PBOK_ALWYS_DEEPLINK&utm_content=textlink&utm_term=PID100017430&CJEVENT=07c84c96b25611ef8357016a0a82b824#citeas https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1010000230103?cj...
- jpm_sd 2y agoPretty sure this is the grossest thing I've ever read on HN! Chlorination isn't sufficient: "maintaining germ-killing chlorine concentration is especially difficult for splash pads because the jets and sprays aerosolize chlorine, lowering the concentration. Still, in most splash-pad linked outbreaks, standard chlorine concentrations aren't enough anyway."
- bookofjoe 2y agoConcur. So much so I almost didn't submit it because of the "Ick" factor.
- lionkor 2y ago> Another possible solution is to have "single-pass" splash pads that don't recirculate water. Yeah, do that. Or do ozone and UV and filters and all the things. It is absolutely wild to me that this is in any way surprising to someone. It also did not need the weird descriptions of who has stuck poop where and how it ends up in the water - simply stating that kids inevitable poop in the water is kinda enough to understand the problem.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoSufficient filtration as part of recirculation solves this. Imagine what we could have had in our communities if we hadn’t wasted $3,000,000,000,000 on Iraq.
- amluto 2y agoI wish you luck finding a commercially available filtration system, suitable for high volume recirculating water like a splash pad, that will reliably remove pathogens. A properly maintained (good luck!) DE filter might do the trick, but they’re messy enough that they’re banned in large parts of the country. Cartridge filters are usually rated at 10 microns, which is nowhere near good enough.
- mattmaroon 2y agoYou don’t filter the pathogens. You filter debris and kill the pathogens with UV, chemicals, etc. It would not be hard to make a significant improvement by just adding UV sterilization.
- jaredhansen 2y ago[flagged]
- optimalquiet 2y ago> Imagine what we could have had in our communities if we hadn’t wasted $3,000,000,000,000 on Iraq. What we would've had was $3,000,000,000,000 less debt, and still no splash pad filtration. The Iraq war was put on the credit card.
- bloomingeek 2y agoWe'll never know if we would have had splash pad filtration if the Iraq invasion didn't happen. What we do know is we were lied to by a presidential candidate and many of our solders were either killed or broken and many many Iraqis died because of that lie. Oh, and greed.
- amluto 2y ago> In 2023, the CDC recommended new health codes that call for "secondary disinfection" methods to keep Crypto at bay, including disinfection systems using ozone or ultraviolet light. Another possible solution is to have "single-pass" splash pads that don't recirculate water. UV seems straightforward, even as a retrofit — a UV sterilizer is not terribly expensive or large, and it can be installed downstream of the filter without any other complication. (UV works poorly in cloudy water, which is why it goes after the filter.) Ozone is a mess. The concentrations of ozone that disinfect are also dangerous for people, so you need a “contact chamber” to let the ozone react, and you want to avoid spraying highly ozonated water at children. It also seems like it might be useful to sterilize the filter every night — those filters can surely end up quite full of cryptosporidium oocysts that will live for a long time. I don’t know what one would sterilize it with, though. Maybe chlorine dioxide?
- RicoElectrico 2y agoWhat about iodine? It is not as volatile as chlorine.
- amluto 2y agoI’ve never heard of anyone disinfecting a pool with iodine. Bromine is used sometimes. But it doesn’t seem like it would help much: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11990150/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11990150/ In any case, IMO the volatility issue is a bit silly. Chlorine is indeed volatile, but chlorinated cyanurates are not, and one can, and should, have cyanuric acid mixed in with one’s chlorinated pool/splash pad water to “stabilize” the chlorine. (They do decrease the effecacy of the chlorine at any given concentration, but they make up for it by making it much easier to maintain an appropriate concentration.) And one can buy a (moderately expensive!) system to monitor and control, closed-loop, the chlorine concentration in the water, so maintaining an appropriate chlorine level in a public pool is not actually that hard. The real problem here is that cryptosporidium is hard to kill.
- rootusrootus 2y agoI agree, maintaining a pool is super easy. My assumption with the splash pad is that there must be some complication introduced because of the aeration of the water, and maybe the cycle time. Aside from raising the PH, maybe it makes it tough to keep the chlorine levels up even with CYA. I wonder if it would be feasible to build a splash loop that had an intermediate tank which could maintain better control over chlorine levels for a predictable amount of time that would make sanitizing reliable.
- trimbo 2y agoA classic: Small Town's 'Cryptosporidium Daze' Fails To Attract Visitors https://theonion.com/small-towns-cryptosporidium-daze-fails-to-attract-visit-1819565675/ https://theonion.com/small-towns-cryptosporidium-daze-fails-...
- dboreham 2y agoWell now I know what a splash pad is. Nothing like a one time pad.
- chankstein38 2y agoI clicked on the article to find out what a splash pad was too lol I was still confused for most of it until I realized the first picture wasn't a kid throwing up it was a kid standing on one of those things where water shoots up from the ground, which is apparently a splash pad.
- bloomingeek 2y agoLast year my wife and I visited the teamLab digital art museum in Tokyo. It was awesome! https://www.teamlab.art/e/tokyo/ https://www.teamlab.art/e/tokyo/ When you first enter the building, you put your belongings into lockers, including your socks and shoes. After some instructions, you walk up a slightly inclined ramp that has a wonderful heated river of water about ankle deep. I realized this warm river of water was actually cleaning our feet! Shortly thereafter, you enter a room that has a very spongy/pillowy floor, thus drying your feet. To my surprise, the whole process almost gave me an icky feeling. :)
- jrootabega 2y agoEnjoy everyone's foot fungus.
- djtango 2y agoThe Japanese take cleaning seriously. The other day I was at a hotel and I saw the hotel front desk staff cleaning the elevator door track late at night. Their approach to floors and feet is one of my favourite things about Japan. No shoes in the house. No slippers on the tatami. Designated slippers for the toilet. Completely thought out and sane. Traditionally the Japanese life revolves around the floor - you eat sitting on the floor and you sleep on the floor. As such they built very strong processes around maintaining clean floors. Shoes in the house is insane. Dogs (and humans) regularly excrete on the surfaces you walk on. Studies have found people who drive regularly traipse in lead around the house coming from petrol refilling. I find the rest of the world's approach to feet and shoes completely upside down. An old roommate explained to me that only after you walk around your home barefoot do you appreciate how clean your floors are and more importantly how clean your feet are.
- rootusrootus 2y agoConversely, only after you walk around your home barefoot do you appreciate that a critical reason for shoes is because humans created unnaturally flat surfaces to walk and stand on. The best answer is a dedicated pair of shoes for indoor use, but my guess is most people would find that too inconvenient.
- fwip 2y agoIt seems like 60 outbreaks over 25 years really isn't that many, with 10K illnesses and 0 reported deaths. As a comparison, every year in the US, over 20,000 children are hospitalized due to the flu, and over a hundred die. I know the denominator is different - most children are exposed to potential flu vectors, while only some visit splash pads - but I think this article mostly sounds scary because poop is gross.
- alex_c 2y agoOK, this is incredibly gross, and I don't want to downplay it. But it's worth pointing out this is over 25 years of data, or around 400 recorded cases/year.
- sjsdaiuasgdia 2y agoAlso worth noting that there can be incidents where a massive number of people are infected in a short span. > with the largest sickening over 2,000 water frolickers in one go. Lots of people experience isolated events of food-borne illnesses for a variety of reasons. But when a restaurant gets 2000 people sick in a short time frame, we shut it down...and correctly so! The average annual rate is not terribly informative for making effective public health decisions because it smooths out most of the interesting bits.
- alex_c 2y agoFor public health decisions I agree, but I'm not making those decisions. For private health decisions (should my family go to a splash pad or not) the average rate, or chance of infection from one visit relative to other activities, would be more relevant. Still gross though!
- Retric 2y agoThat’s the number of cases being directly linked to a specific cause, it doesn’t mean that the actual number was 400/year. It’s like someone trying to estimate how much violence exists from watching the news. You’re likely to see major incidents, but you can only estimate the actual total. I wouldn’t be surprised if it was well over 10k/year, but the CDC is conservative with their numbers for good reasons.
- postscapes1 2y agoAfter seeing how many porta potties at playgrounds never have their hand sanitizer filled, I have come to grips with fecal matter being a part of the gig
- scandox 2y agoMeh. They're enormous amounts of fun and my kids spent many happy hours in the one in Nice without any ill effects. It's a big dirty world.
- Cumpiler69 2y agoExactly. Your used toothbrush sitting wet in your bathroom is full of fecal matter.
- rootusrootus 2y agoWhich can be mitigated significantly, if desired, by using bleach tablets in the toilet tank. That has knock-on consequences, but they are manageable.
- Cumpiler69 2y agoI think microplastics are more likely to kill me before the fecal matter in my toothbrush.
- rootusrootus 2y agoI thought microplastics are still more of a hypothetical health hazard than a proven one? In any case I don't think there is any need to choose one over the other.
- prpl 2y agoNot everyone, I live in a victorian house with a separated shitter.
- rootusrootus 2y agoThat's common in contemporary houses as well.
- declan_roberts 2y agoProbably better for their immune system in the long run.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stevenhubertron 2y agogood way to build up a robust immune system.
- boringg 2y agoI feel like what the lesson is going to be if it goes to the larger public --> (1) Municipal funds which will go way overboard to try and resolve this - well past any meaningful value and (2) people not using them anymore for beyond reasonable level of concern.
- p0012042024uy 2y ago[dead]
- dopamean 2y agoThis make me glad that the splash pads I take my kid to reek of chlorine.
- rootusrootus 2y agoFun fact - well maintained pool water has barely a detectable scent of chlorine. If you go to a pool that reeks of chlorine, what you are really smelling are chloramines. That is the result of chlorine combining with pee and other stuff. It's one of the reasons a poorly maintained pool is so irritating for your skin and eyes. I sympathize, though, with the maintainers of public pools. A nearly constant bather load comprised mostly of children emptying their bladders at will. It's probably a losing battle. And then periodically one of the little brats will poop in the water. God bless the maintenance guy who has to fish that out and then shock the pool into the safe zone again. Yuck.
- hammock 2y agoSolution: don't. drink. the water. I never understood, both as a child and now, all the kids that swim in a pool with their mouth open, constantly ingesting and spitting out water. Can you not swim with your mouth closed? Do you have a nasal obstruction?
- rootusrootus 2y agoWell maintained pool water is pretty close to as safe as drinking water, so I wouldn't worry much about relatively small amounts ingested. But at a splash pad with recirculating water, or a popular public pool with a lot of bathers ... yuuuuck.