6 ms·
I wonder how successful this will be beyond the kickstarter. I think this will partly depend on who has been donating. How many of these are developers who wan
by jiggy2011 14y ago
I wonder how successful this will be beyond the kickstarter.
I think this will partly depend on who has been donating. How many of these are developers who want this to develop on, how many are hackers who want some nice open hardware to build something else on top of and how many are general gamers who just want a new console?
It's possible that they ship the kickstarter units once they have finished development but that is more or less it and actual orders0 drop quickly to almost nothing.
The incumbents have several advantages over this:
They have deep wallets and are able to subsidize their consoles heavily (and already do). For example they could offer a sale price for an XboX at around the time that this is released so that the price difference becomes negligible.
They have retail space, even though many would say that retail is dying. Walking past a high street shop that advertised a particular product will certainly increase the perceived legitimacy of that product in the public eyes. They can also use this hook to wrestle things like this out of the physical retail space.
It's going to be hard to persuade AAA developers to develop for this, partly because it is so "hackable".
If this does gain some popularity then it's likely that neighbourhood teenage geeks will do a nice business in taking these consoles, putting custom firmware on them to bypass whatever DRM and installing hundreds of torrented games on them, for some ridiculously cheap fee like $30. XboX gets around this problem by deliberately making this difficult and risky (having to do a hardware mod, risking loss of XboX Live service , voiding warranty on a device with perceived reliability issues).
As an example of this a PayTV service was launched in the UK some years ago but the hardware was made very easy to hack so it was possible to make it able to subscribe to all premium channels without paying for them. They eventually went out of business because the majority of their customers had hacked boxes.
All the titles they are gunning for appear to be indie titles, the problem is that most successful Indie titles will end up on Xbox etc anyway since MS , Sony etc are enabling digital distribution. Unless this can get a massive install base it's likely that Indie devs will only target it as a secondary platform and will concentrate on XboX etc first.
It's difficult to think of a way to sell this device on it's merits to an "average consumer" beyond being slightly cheaper than an XBox (but not cheaper than a second hand one). The only pitch I can think of would be "you can run pirate games on this". Piracy is also a big part of the reason that the PC was such a successful games platform, I remember the arguments at school between console and PC gamers and one frequently trotted out in favour of the PC was "the hardware costs more , but the games are free because we just copy the disks".
- warfangle 14y agoIt might be interesting if they use some of the over-target kickstarter money to fund some indie titles themselves.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI think that money might be better spent producing a very solid and simple game development framework or engine to help encourage developers onto this platform. It would also be nice to encourage a culture of developers providing tools for their games (level editors etc) so that games could get large re playability on this console vs XboX where you are mostly restricted to pay-for commercial DLC.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoThe biggest question I have- Say it goes crazy and they sell 100,000 units via KS. Is that enough of an install base to make it work? Would developers target a platform of only 100,000 users? How would they get more users?
- jiggy2011 14y agoDepends on those users I guess. If they are enthusiastic gamers with high disposable incomes then yes that probably makes the platform viable (or at least has a chance to). If instead they are a mixture of geeks who want to hack the hardware and low income families who are likely to run pirate games or buy relatively few games then no. Basically it's the same situation as with iOS/Android phones. iOS has a smaller install base but the base they do have is generally more profitable. It will also depend on how difficult it is to port existing titles to this console. This will manifest itself in terms of controls (for existing touch screen games) and in terms of software compatibility. Hopefully also, games developed for this will be trivial to port to a regular Linux distro.
- wmf 14y agoenthusiastic gamers with high disposable incomes Isn't that a subset of the existing Xbox/PS3 market, in which case developers would be better off targeting Xbox. The market for Ouya has to be people who are willing to spend some money on a console but not $300; it's not clear that such a niche exists.