3 ms·
> the improvement was largely down to reconstruction efforts partly funded by the US via the Marshall Plan Most of the improvement was in Germany, which receiv
by WalterBright 2y ago
> the improvement was largely down to reconstruction efforts partly funded by the US via the Marshall Plan
Most of the improvement was in Germany, which received far less MP money than Britain and France.
Postwar prosperity correlates with the level of free markets. Germany embraced free markets up until 1970, Britain and France did not.
- WhereIsTheTruth 2y agoThey served as bases to spread the American culture through music and cinema and later with the industry through the coal and steel community, to create a single and unified market The US did not want to create competition, but to break monopolies and to create a unified market for its industrial complex The remnants of that goal are visible today with Big Tech
- ashoeafoot 2y agoThat manchester capitalism with different decorations rhetoric does not hold up to scrutiny. In particular when you hold it against current examples of economic colonialism like the chines lend & own campaign in Africa .
- almaight 2y agoWithout an army or control over territory, it cannot reach the level of colonization. African countries often default on their debts.
- ashoeafoot 2y agoThe army is provided by the local dictator or by playing different ethnic groups against one another.Britain never had enough soldiers to conquer India , but india had. Same for Russia .
- WalterBright 2y agoMy dad was part of the occupation of postwar Germany. The bases were there to protect Germany against the Soviets. I remember once on the autobahn around 1970, and a fighter came by hedgehopping at high speed. He was a few feet off the ground, and looked like just under Mach 1. The citizens didn't particularly like the noise and disruption, but they understood the need for the Air Force to train hard. I also remember touring East Berlin (yes, East Berlin) in 1969. Going through Checkpoint Charlie and seeing the Wall is plenty convincing of the need for the US military being there. France, on the other hand, didn't much care for the US military bases and wound up pushing them out. BTW, the US Military was pretty thorough in making sure US personnel and military families behaved like guests in Germany, as they were invited guests. Ever since the Berlin Airlift, the US was friends with Germany. The Americanization of Germany came later. I recall visiting a shopping mall in Germany in the 2000's, and you could not tell you were in Germany rather than in any suburb in America. Shopping malls did not exist there in 1970.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>BTW, the US Military was pretty thorough in making sure US personnel and military families behaved like guests in Germany, as they were invited guests. Ever since the Berlin Airlift, the US was friends with Germany. All the more sad that the chief component of Japanese animosity towards Japan-stationed US forces are sexual crimes, particularly in Okinawa where the Marines especially don't seem to know how to keep their dicks in their pants. There have been at least two incidents just this year if I recall, and that's just of the ones we know. I really can't blame the locals wanting Americans to get the fuck out, security be damned.
- WalterBright 2y agoThat is indeed sad. Such crimes against the locals should be severely punished. I found out many years later that if I had committed a crime like shoplifting in Germany, my father would have been cashiered. The military took their guest status very seriously. An officer who could not control his family was not fit to be an officer.
- adamc 2y ago
- danielbln 2y agoSaying Germany embraced the free market is not correct. Germany under Erhard had a social market economy (even during the "Wirtschaftswunder*, the economic miracle). While some free market principles were followed (price liberation, free trade) and it was certainly more market liberal than France at the time, it still came with substantial protection (universal healthcare, strong labor protections and unions, anti monopoly regulations etc.) The situation back then was decidedly _not_ what the term "free market" (of the libertarian variety) would imply today.
- WalterBright 2y agoNobody claimed it was a 100% free market. But it was quite a bit more free than the other MP recipients. And the results showed.
- danielbln 2y agoDefinitely, just wanted to make sure that no one who's passing by your comment thinks that post-war Germany had some gung ho modern definition style free market.
- nitwit005 2y agoEast Germany did better than its peers in the Soviet block, and West Germany did better than its peers outside of it. People love to point at policy, because it's a thing we can control, but the most important factors are often cultural issues we both don't control, and don't entirely understand.
- nativeit 2y agoI assume you’re referring to West Germany? Can such comparisons even be drawn for only half of an otherwise largely occupied nation?