3 ms·
Counterpoint: radio, even independent/college rock radio in the heyday of independent/college rock, sucked ass compared to what we have now.
by tptacek 2y ago
Counterpoint: radio, even independent/college rock radio in the heyday of independent/college rock, sucked ass compared to what we have now.
- dylan604 2y agoCounterpoint: no it didn't. Independent/college radio was full of music (even if you didn't care for it) that was curated by people that gave a damn. They are/were better than whatever your algo thinks it can do.
- tptacek 2y agoI have significantly more and better sources of human curation now than I did when I was listening to college radio.
- dmonitor 2y agoSelf-curated or do you have a good source for human-made playlists?
- tptacek 2y agoI feel like basically all I listen to is human-made playlists and recommendations from humans? RYM might be a good place for you to start, but you can also just do the obvious thing of starting from a couple playlists you like and finding other playlists by the same people. Eventually you'll find people who seemingly do this full-time. Really weird for me to see people talking about how bad "the algo" is. Do people just open up Apple Music or Spotify and tell it "find stuff for me to play"? I know that's a thing it will do, but it never occurred to me that I'd actually want it to do that.
- ziddoap 2y ago>Do people just open up Apple Music or Spotify and tell it "find stuff for me to play"? I know that's a thing it will do, but it never occurred to me that I'd actually want it to do that. I do this with Apple Music. And, to be honest, "the algo" has been really good. The "create a station" feature has introduced me to a few dozen artists at least.
- SllX 2y agoThere are an endless number of playlist mixes on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Music. I usually go for the YouTube ones because that will introduce me to music I’ve never listened to before, such as this one I discovered some some 5 to 6 years ago I still pull up when I want to listen: https://youtu.be/DbHa-pllnDU https://youtu.be/DbHa-pllnDU If you want human curated music, you can have that. If you want an algo-driven mix, you can have that too. I flip between both and playlists I put together for myself.
- dylan604 2y agoI'd posit that at least part of those better sources might still get some of their recommendations from a station from somewhere even if you don't realize it.
- tptacek 2y agoI really doubt it.
- lxgr 2y agoCompared to what? Radio does convey a sense of locality and connection that nothing else quite replaces for me (including web radio). There's something unique about browsing the FM (or AM, where still available) in an unknown place, seeing whether you can still get the same station the next day on a road trip etc, and knowing that some people in the general area are listening to the exact same thing at the same time. Long distance listening on shortwave can also be quite fun, although fewer and fewer countries are still active there. It's still fascinating to hear your home news an ocean away with just a small wire, a handheld radio, and no network whatsoever! Obviously I wouldn't trade Spotify for it, but I'd still be sad to see it go.
- tptacek 2y ago"Obviously I wouldn't trade Spotify for it" pretty much sums the whole thing up.
- lxgr 2y agoSeems like a false dichotomy to me. Why wouldn't there be room for both? Personally, Spotify has replaced CDs and MP3s much more than radio, also.
- tptacek 2y agoI didn't pose a dichotomy. I said one thing is better than the other. If enough people disagree, the crappier thing will survive regardless. I don't think they do, though, which is why terrestrial radio is dying.
- lxgr 2y agoThe implied dichotomy being "for enough people, streaming is so much better than radio that they'll completely forego radio", or maybe "see, even you prefer Spotify over radio". But that's not how it works. Even I, a single person, can very frequently listen to Spotify and occasionally listen to radio. I don't have to trade one for the other completely! > If enough people disagree, the crappier thing will survive regardless. I don't think they do, though, which is why terrestrial radio is dying. Is it really dying, or stabilizing at a lower-than-before-Spotify-but-non-zero rate? Listening rates in Germany and Austria have been pretty stable over the last 20 years, for example.
- alecco 2y agoAll the TOP XX lists were completely made up by the music industry. And even many pirate radios were promoting their friends mostly. But to be honest, now they got the grips on Spotify. And all the fake views on YT (like the making of "Despacito"). The music moguls are ruthless.
- csomar 2y agoI don't think the medium (voice) is what sucked since podcasts are all the rage now. I think the difference (at least for me) is that with podcasts I get much less ads and much less garbage and straight the content I want. ie: I want a techno beat radio. The traditional radio will keep cutting with ads and worse with someone who thinks I want to hear his voice announcing the song; or cutting to talk about something related/unrelated but that's not what I am looking for.