4 ms·
I think the article explains it nicely: they generate steady losses, and he's getting older; if he dies, he doesn't want his successors to have to unwind the li
by tptacek 2y ago
I think the article explains it nicely: they generate steady losses, and he's getting older; if he dies, he doesn't want his successors to have to unwind the liabilities.
It's ~2025. What is a popular music terrestrial radio station at this point other than a vanity project?
- pie420 2y agoAn institution of culture. something the new money tech elite dont seem to understand. modern society is desperately missing the concept of noblesse oblige
- IncreasePosts 2y agoThere might be a better way to implement noblesse oblige than provide 30,000 people a 39th option for hearing rock n roll music.
- jprjr_ 2y agoFM radio is dead and has been for years. I haven't seriously listened to FM radio since I got a portable CD player and that was in the late 90s. I can't imagine anybody trying to get into it now. Why would I subject myself to obnoxious ads every few minutes and music I don't like when I can just listen to what I want, when I want, ad-free? AM radio is still going with conspiracy talk and maybe sports radio? I honestly don't know, I've never given AM radio a real listen. Sometimes I get nostalgic for the radio. I remember calling in to stations and requesting songs, contests, morning zoo hosts, and so on. But it's probably not coming back.
- gazook89 2y agoI’m not trying to argue the point, but I listen to FM about every day, or at least every day I’m in the car. It’s much easier for me than getting music from my phone going, even with Bluetooth. And I have come to the conclusion that I like talk intermixed with music, even if the talk is an ad. It’s weird, I never thought that’d be the case, but I do. In fact, I wish I could easily mix my music library into my podcast library— specifically, interrupt podcasts with music (maybe replace the ads with a single song). I also like how easy it is to switch channels to something different. I could do that with CarPlay or something too with my own music, but then I probably have to actually think about it (when I should be thinking about driving). And for people who care about live music events (shows etc) it’s a great way to find out about those things, particularly if your city has a good public radio station and not just iHeartMedia. I’m not sure I Love radio, but I would probably really miss it if it wasn’t in my car.
- inferiorhuman 2y agoDunno where you are but local radio programming disappeared in most markets years ago. Even in the Bay Area. All of what you've said about radio content was true a decade or more ago, but much less true now. And for people who care about live music events (shows etc) it’s a great way to find out about those things Big stations promote big acts, sure. But that's easy enough to find information on elsewhere (e.g. Youtube). Smaller stations (e.g. KXSF, KPFA, KZSU) out here promote smaller venues but I'm typically out of range and end up listening to their content via the good old internet. I’m not sure I Love radio, but I would probably really miss it if it wasn’t in my car. There was a time I would (late 90s, early 00s) but now? Not so much. The ratio of music to ads has gotten awful. Even stations that have ostensibly gone back to their roots like KITS are a pale imitation of their past glory. Like they'll wear the meat suit of genres that were previously popular but make sure to mix it with plenty of mediocre top 40 and a suffocating amount of ads.
- gazook89 2y agoI don’t really listen to radio while traveling so I’ll take your word for it. In Minnesota we gave The Current, part of MPR family of stations which is pretty good from what I hear (about its status nationally, though always some one will say it “used to be better”). And yeah, that’s ONE station. Probably another part of it for me is that most of drives are probably considered short, the longest trip is usually 20-30 minutes depending on traffic and that’s only a few times a month. If I was doing hour long commutes, it’d be podcasts all day.
- HeyLaughingBoy 2y agoThat "most markets" does a lot of heavy lifting. In the MSP area my two main radio stations are both public radio. The state's MPR (Minnesota Public Radio) station and The Current, which is basically what the GP described for the Twin Cities region. I don't know if I'd go so far as to say that I'd miss them if they were gone. OK, I really like listening to Terry Gross and Kai Ryssdal but besides that it's just nice background audio.
- 2y ago
- eichin 2y agoSome time in the early 2000's I heard a Microsoft ad, on FM radio, for FAT32. I turned off the radio and basically never turned it on again (and made sure my next car had mp3 player support.)
- talldatethrow 2y agoAs someone who doesn't listen to the radio in FM or AM, does it really make sense to comment on your thoughts regarding how often and why it's listened to by most people? You're not one of them. I've owned CDs since the early 90s. I e owned several good MP3 players. I have several USB drives with music on them. I haven't touched any of those in about a decade, and instead listen to the radio every day.
- vlowther 2y agoGive monthly donations to your local NPR affiliate. Most of them have decently middle-of-the-road biased news, and a few have really good music programming (looking at you, KUTX).
- sourcepluck 2y agoExcellent, agreed. Nothing is sacred except "the grind", it appears, yes. No value exists outside viewcount, or listenercount, or whatever metric the media uses. Your comment reminds me of something I read yesterday, an allusion that mathematician Gian-Carlo Rota made to what he called "Kultur", in this remarkable interview https://sgp.fas.org/othergov/doe/lanl/pubs/00326965.pdf https://sgp.fas.org/othergov/doe/lanl/pubs/00326965.pdf. The context is different, but I think your usage is in line with his in the interview.
- tptacek 2y agoYou can write as many paragraphs of this stuff as you like but I don't think that's going to get people to retain long-term 7-8 figure liabilities on their books. If there's even a notion of a system of "noblesse oblige", everybody has been defecting from it except for King.
- sourcepluck 2y agoWhen you say "everbody", you're referring to a modest percentage of people, and even for those people, it's only true some of the time. The real world is full of people doing stuff that is not explained whatsoever by notions like increasing profits in account-books. People do economically disastrous things like have dogs, go on holiday, they get their nails done twice a month, waste half their Sunday doing their Gran's hedges, and etc etc. They have babies, and often someone stays at home with the baby, losing boat loads of money in many cases if you calculate what they could earn if they worked full time and put the child into a cheap daycare. Not to mention all the hours spent in amateur sports clubs, and ukulele groups, and pipe bands, and sometimes, they even run radio stations, and blogs, and maintain software, and make little robots, just for a laugh. The notion of everyone going around calculating everything to maximise income all the time is a fairytale certain people tell themselves to convince themselves they're the real mavericks, the hard ones who don't flinch from reality. The motivation for the deception is clear, but unfortunately, it's patently false.
- khana 2y ago[dead]
- bawolff 2y agoThere are plenty of cultural institutions in the modern world that are basically run as a charity. I think the elite understand this just fine they just don't view some random rock radio station as a cultural institution.
- klodolph 2y agoAh yes. If he dies.
- codpiece 2y agoAnd if he remains dead...
- michaelwilson 2y agoLet's just hope we're not on his "People to Haunt" list.
- sjhatfield 2y agoKEXP
- caust1c 2y agoSo happy they expanded to the Bay Area after living in Seattle for a few years!
- xnorswap 2y agoI've been listening to them on KEXP.org for a decade or more now. It's a little odd tuning into "the morning show" in the afternoon, but it's good radio, and so much better for discovering music than any of the alternatives here. 6 Music can be as good, but it never quite got over the "death" of the UK indie music scene and sometimes feels more like a tribute act to it's former self. As I speak the heaviest tracks in rotation are from Bon Iver and Doves, and while both are great acts, they're not new bands. Overall the discoverability is way down, and fairly often I'll find new music, even music from UK+Ireland, via KEXP, rather than from the media here.
- bagpuss 2y agogive Do You Radio a try, former NTS guys went out on their own, all available on mixcloud so you can flick through bits you don't like https://doyou.world/ https://doyou.world/
- indigodaddy 2y agoRadio Paradise is also still pretty good for discovering new music..
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- into-ruin 2y agoXRAY.fm in Portland is another
- 2y ago
- disantlor 2y agoWFMU
- RobRivera 2y agoHeritage project, source of joy and soothing, an opportunity to ply your intellect on radio tech? Vanity project seems like such a misnomer. When I think of vanity project, I think of Bender building a tomb in his honor a million cubits high with fire eyes saying 'RE MEMBER MEEEEEE'
- khana 2y ago[dead]
- stevage 2y agoA valuable community service appreciated by thousands of people? The opposite of vanity.
- tptacek 2y agoGiven how people consume music today, I stand by "vanity", and I think King agrees.
- talldatethrow 2y agoI think he'd agree more with Passion Project not vanity.
- tptacek 2y agoSure. Either way: not a thing sustained for its utility. I think running independent rock radio stations is admirable. It sounds fun. But if it's losing him millions of dollars, obviously, he should immediately stop doing it.
- xemdetia 2y agoDepending on the market it is still possible to be profitable. There is still a market even though it is narrow and most stations solve the problem like how Stephen King did- you have multiple stations to increase inventory.
- dylan604 2y agoSomething that can be received without a data plan
- jprjr_ 2y agoBefore we had data plans we had MP3 players, CDs, tapes. I guess what I'm getting at is - for a lot of us the radio was already dead before streaming was an option.
- dylan604 2y agoYes yes, you can find any little thing to add as an argument to support "I don't listen to radio", but a lot of us still listen to radio. Sometimes, you want to find something other than what's in your mp3/CD/cassette collection. Growing up, there were very specific shows that I would listen to specifically for being introduced to something (whether it was new or old and just new to me). Radio did not become a bad experience to me until Clear Channel/Comcast bought up all of the non-indies and made it greater than 80% chance that you'd hear a commercial whenever you tuned into any given station. I'd also suspect that your "a lot of us" sounds really big in whatever echo chamber you find yourself
- tptacek 2y agoYou listen to it, but presumably you don't support it, since it's dying, right?
- dylan604 2y agoYour presumptions are almost as bad as when you assume. Actually, they're better since you can leave the "me" out of the assu prove to be. I've supported my community station KNON since I was in high school. Might have missed here or there, but I've contributed to them longer than anything else. The only thing dying in this thread are the 3 stations King runs, and whatever notions you thought you had on me.
- 2y ago
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> What is a popular music terrestrial radio station at this point other than a vanity project? More's the pity.
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- dredmorbius 2y agoTerrestrial radio: an immensely effective political propaganda tool. (May involve more than just music, but music is good earbait.) "The Divided Dial: How Conservative Talk Radio Came to Dominate the Airwaves" (6 part podcast, transcripts available, originally published Nov-Dec 2022) <https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/divided-dial https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/divided-dial>