4 ms·
This is actually a pretty serious legit concern that I'm surprised we haven't seen a proper solution for. I feel like there should be some sort of trusted cert
by malandrew 14y ago
This is actually a pretty serious legit concern that I'm surprised we haven't seen a proper solution for.
I feel like there should be some sort of trusted certificates or other method to determine whether or not you can trust the access point and alert the user when they may be moving sensitive info over that network.
- Retric 14y agoJust use an encrypted tunnel and your safe.
- r00fus 14y agoIf a Van near the hotspot spoofs the network name running the equivalent of BlueCoat, even SSL traffic can be silently monitored or tampered with. The problem is 99% of folks don't know how to setup a stunnel and the remaining 1% understand the performance implications of being paranoid all the time.
- yuhong 14y agoNot if you don't ignore cert warnings.
- y0ghur7_xxx 14y agoWhy? You would use tls anyway with any service you think is even remotely important to you.
- prophetjohn 14y agoYeah, malandrew probably would. But what about the 95% of the world that has no idea what TLS is?
- flatline3 14y agoThey're already hosed, a borrowed SSID isn't going to do much more harm.
- trotsky 14y agoFor a variety of reasons it doesn't really matter if you authenticate the hotspot if the rest of the traffic goes in the clear as unless you also do key exchange as part of the authentication and then use it for protecting your traffic someone could just forward the authentication to a real box and then take over or simply hijack your connection after you've authenticated. There is also the problem of wide deployments like coffee shops making it pretty easy to steal certificates. WPA Enterprise / WPA2 Enterprise with PEAP (and several other flavors) includes a server certificate as part of the authentication process that you can validate before supplying your credentials. While it's not perfect, you can run public wifi with WPA2 Enterprise and just set the login to guest and a blank password (and say that in the ESSID). That allows anyone to connect but still allows them to authenticate the hotspot and have a fair level of protection from session snooping or hijacking. Realistically future versions of 802.11 should use some type of system like that for unprotected connections, but they don't seem very interested.
- yuhong 14y agoYea, EAP-TLS was one of the oldest EAP methods, and the client certificate is actually optional per the spec, though most supplicants require it (using a dummy cert is the workaround).