8 ms·
Phishers Love New TLDs Like .shop, .top and .xyz
- dmurray 2y ago> new gTLDs introduced in the last few years command just 11 percent of the market for new domains, but accounted for roughly 37 percent of cybercrime domains reported between September 2023 and August 2024. > .com and .net domains made up approximately half of all domains registered...they accounted for just over 40 percent of all cybercrime domains. Hardly earth shattering. .net and .com are still pulling 80% of their weight when it comes to cybercrime. And the article concludes that the main reason the new TLDs are disproportionately used is because you can sometimes buy them cheap in bulk. Maybe the real story here is that the ccTLD registrars, who weren't mentioned, are disproportionately good at deterring cybercrime.
- zinekeller 2y ago> Maybe the real story here is that the ccTLD registrars, who weren't mentioned, are disproportionately good at deterring cybercrime. I think that some ccTLDs requiring positive identification, usually as a side effect of residency or nationality requirements, immensely help here (versus most gTLDs requiring f***-all identification).
- hyperhopper 2y agoI definitely don't want to move to a system where making a website needs both a government and a private corporation vouching for you. That's the worst case scenario.
- reaperducer 2y ago.net and .com are still pulling 80% of their weight when it comes to cybercrime. The article states it's half that. "while .com and .net domains made up approximately half of all domains registered in the past year… they accounted for just over 40 percent of all cybercrime domains. Interisle says an almost equal share — 37 percent — of cybercrime domains were registered through new gTLDs."
- a_gray 2y ago> The article states it's half that. No, the article agrees with dmurray. Read again: 80% of 50% is 40%.
- bloppe 2y agoYou seem to be implying that 80% of com/net domains are used for cybercrime, which is not a sound conclusion from those numbers. You're confusing "percent of all domains" with "percent of crime domains". You can't just divide them to get something meaningful.
- calfuris 2y agoNo, the statement was that ".net and .com are still pulling 80% of their weight when it comes to cybercrime." I read that as saying that .net and .com domains show up in cybercrime 80% as often as would be expected if all TLDs were equally likely to be used for cybercrime.
- lexicality 2y agoHonestly the only "legitimate" use for these TLDs seem to be fediverse/bsky vanity URLs. Everything outside that just looks like a scam, even if it isn't.
- runamuck 2y agoInteresting! Now that you mention it, I did buy a .luxury domain for this purpose - a Gemini server. I also bought a .ski to have a domain with my (polish) last name.
- lexicality 2y agoIt's great to be able to get silly domains for projects, back to the old days of IRC vanity hosts, but can you imagine seeing a link to something like jackets.luxury and going "yeah that seems legit, I'm definitely giving them my card details"
- Symbiote 2y agoThe first English result on Google for a .luxury site is this: https://leon.luxury/ https://leon.luxury/ It looks legitimate, and it's probably enabled Leon to use their business name in the domain. The first American site is https://roughwood.luxury/ https://roughwood.luxury/, it also looks fine.
- qup 2y agoBut then I remember it's just a pointer to 19.124.217.99 and I have no idea if it's legit or not, just like all the .coms.
- digital_sawzall 2y agoYes that is completely normal and the my younger relatives would not even think twice. In the TikTok and Instagram community people are spending billions not only on random domains (like tiedyeshirts.xyz) but often to venmo or zelle listed on profiles. My sister and thousands like her send money to faceless profiles to buy mystery boxes.
- 2y ago
- ErikAugust 2y agoOnce I found I couldn’t iMessage a .xyz link I decided to stay away…
- 15155 2y agoThis would have me staying away from iMessage. What other content is Big Brother not transmitting for my "protection?"
- kevincox 2y agoThis is actually why I moved off of Facebook Messenger. It started blocking random links I tried to send so I moved to something E2E encrypted.
- Ajedi32 2y agoFacebook Messenger is E2E encrypted now (though obviously that's not going to prevent the developer from blocking links unless the client is also open source).
- larrik 2y agoit didn't send, or it didn't linkify?
- ErikAugust 2y agoRight, didn’t send.
- billpg 2y agoGiven that .zip is now a TLD, I completely support not automatically linkifying things that might be links. (If you used "https" and made it a full URL, that's different.)
- drummojg 2y agoI have always thought the infinite proliferation of TLDs was a stupid idea. I'd be enlightened if I could think of one scenario that benefits from it outside of the registrars.
- echoangle 2y agoI would actually think that consumers (of domains) benefit more than the registrars, because there is more competition. If I want a specific word as a domain, there are multiple options of TLD for me.
- edent 2y agoThere are lots of people called John Smith. They all want a domain name. There's only so many variations of jsmith, j-smith, etc you can squeeze into .com, .net, and a few others. Why shouldn't they be able to buy a domain name which contains their name? Is it useful to be able to differentiate between McDonald's the restaurant and McDonald's the legal firm and McDonald's garage? Why shouldn't each of those industries get their own TLD? The original list of TLDs aren't some platonic good written by ineffable sages. It's OK for things to change.
- gruez 2y ago>There are lots of people called John Smith. They all want a domain name. There's only so many variations of jsmith, j-smith, etc you can squeeze into .com, .net, and a few others. >Why shouldn't they be able to buy a domain name which contains their name? I fail to see how johnsmith[insert number here].com is any worse than johnsmith.[insert TLD here]. If anything a number is less likely to get mixed up than tlds, which have confusing pairs like ".tech" and ".technology", or ".engineer" and ".engineering".
- edent 2y agoSurely the number 14 is likely to get misheard as 40. And 13135432 is easily typo'd to 13134532.
- xelamonster 2y agoThe implication that gTLDs are bad and new ones shouldn't be introduced because of this is a bit silly to me. The argument that they somehow have lower registration requirements makes no sense, .shop .top and .xyz registrations involve the exact same amount of verification as .com (none). Prices aren't really that different and plenty of gTLDs are more expensive than traditional ones. Registering a domain is frustrating these days, too many already taken and a lot of them by squatters not even intending to use it. I'd love to see more options personally even if it makes it slightly easier to create a phishing domain. We need better tools than memorizing a domain name to deal with that anyways.
- NotSammyHagar 2y agoI think the issue is you can register a known company name on one of these and plenty of people will think it's legit. Companies have to register on all these random domain to protect themselves. dell.shop, that's probably the dell computer I know, right?
- zanderwohl 2y agoThe people who would fall for that would probably also fall for `dell.computerdealshop.com` though
- 0xCMP 2y agoThey're different. Companies register all kinds of crazy domains and redirect you through them all the time. Why is it crazy that some marketing person at Dell thought it would be cool to link people to 'dell dot shop'? I would check the certificates, but honestly only as a precaution. If the website looks correct that isn't such an insane thing. That is exactly why it's so dangerous and effective versus your example.
- jeroenhd 2y ago> Companies register all kinds of crazy domains and redirect you through them all the time That's the real problem with domain trust these days. Companies go out of their way to make sure you know to only visit official links, and then do stupid stuff like buying vanity domains for one-time deals, or make you click through mailchimp tracking URLs because marketing tracking is more important than your customers falling for phishing. Those vanity domains then end up expiring, and now emails and web links that used to go to an official $brand server are all ready to be swooped up by scammers. Customers never stood a chance. This isn't a TLD problem. It's a shitty company problem.
- neilv 2y ago> John Levine is author of the book “The Internet for Dummies” and president of CAUCE. Levine said adding more TLDs without a much stricter registration policy will likely further expand an already plentiful greenfield for cybercriminals. He's from pre-gold-rush Internet, and still making the net better: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_R._Levine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_R._Levine
- felideon 2y agoOT, but man, I remember reading that book when I was a kid. Then started reading HTML books and, of course, the Llama book.
- smitelli 2y agoThe whole environment of the newer gTLDs just feels… gross. I rarely find a reputable business that is using anything but .com or .co.XX as the primary domain. Putting on my regular-person hat: When I see a billboard or print ad with e.g. `example.travel`, I read that as a social media handle and not a website address like `example.com` would convey. In public perception, dot com means websites. Always has. (Tangentially, the `.sucks` TLD in particular should never have been allowed. How many brands out there have to maintain a perfunctory registration there just to prevent somebody else from doing so?)
- RegnisGnaw 2y agoReally? what about countries that allow just .ccTLD?
- jeroenhd 2y agoI never deal with co.xx to be honest. Most websites I visit are on ccTLDs. Whenever I see a .com link to any local business, I start out by assuming it's a scam website. That said, .app has found plenty of adoption. Tech companies absolutely love .io and .ai is now also gaining popularity. The good American URLs have all been bought years ago so people flock to ccTLDs and gTLDs for new products and businesses. Even .engineering has a few interesting businesses on it these days. As for .sucks, it's clearly a cash grab, but banning it hardly solves a problem. ycombinatorsucks.com is a lot cheaper than ycombinator.sucks, and if ycombinator pre-emptively buys ycombinatorsucks.com, you could just buy ycombinatorisshit.com or ycombinatorisadoodoohead.com.
- Symbiote 2y agoThis is very regional. .co.xx is common in Britain (.co.uk), Japan (.co.jp), New Zealand (.co.nz) and probably others. It's perfectly legitimate for a site linked to those countries.
- craigds 2y agoNZ didn't allow registration of raw .nz domains until 2014 so anything registered before that was a .co.nz or similar. It's still more common than .nz due to inertia / muscle memory I guess. I get weird looks when I give people my (name).nz email address - usually people ask if I meant .co.nZ
- jimmySixDOF 2y agogTLDs also have cost risks like when .tech was taken over by a holding company and then 3x the registration price. Who knows about next year and the year after that.
- dist-epoch 2y agoIf you run a business you can buy the domain for 10 years, right?
- anonymouscaller 2y agoAs much as some gTLDs are known for spam, it's dangerous to generalize certain domains as spam. I used to run a website with a somewhat niche gTLD and it was a headache getting blocked by spam filters who just blocked *.mygTLD
- hoistbypetard 2y ago> John Levine is author of the book “The Internet for Dummies” and president of CAUCE. Levine said adding more TLDs without a much stricter registration policy will likely further expand an already plentiful greenfield for cybercriminals. Holy shit. CAUCE is a name I haven't heard in a long time. He's been around for a while and is one of the good ones.
- paxys 2y agoDomain names becoming cheaper (and having greater variety) is a good thing. Yes that comes with an equivalent rise in scam domains, but the answer isn't to add further barriers to entry for everyone else.
- anticorporate 2y agoMy primary catch-all email domain for accounts is at a silly TLD (.rodeo). My biggest complaint is that some large retailers/services completely refuse to believe it is a valid domain. (I'm looking at you, Walgreens. You blocked me during a pandemic from signing up for a vaccine with my actual email address, which is why fuckwalgreens@myother.domain is now my email in your system.)
- stock_toaster 2y agoI’d guess it was their first rodeo.
- CarpaDorada 2y agoIf you see a phishing link, you can perform a DNS A record request to find their IPs, typically behind Cloudflare. You can report them to Cloudflare. Their WHOIS record will tell you who their registrar is, and again you can report them there too. If they use URL shorteners, you can report those.
- acheron 2y agoon the other hand, new TLDs make ICANN a lot of money, and isn't that the important thing?
- billy99k 2y agoA friend of our family almost got scammed from a .top domain. They convinced her she needed 'tech support' and transferred $30,000 from her savings to checking and tried to get her to go to the bank to get more money. She got suspicious and got new bank accounts and thankfully didn't get any actual money stolen. She's retired and it could have ruined her financially. I don't think she realizes how close she was to this. The software they used bypassed windows defender because it was legitimate software called 'screen connect'. I was able to remove it pretty easily. It looked like a reverse-shell attached to a windows service (small .exe with no front-end).
- 9x39 2y agoCyberfraud is infuriating when we know the victim, and depressing when you look how ripe the target space is, but the TLD is neither the most interesting thing about the crime nor what’s to blame, right? There’s a lot of trust in a namespace system that doesn’t deserve it, although odds are you personally can use it to be immune to scams. What do we do for everyone else?
- xg15 2y agoI wonder if part of the "business model" behind the ever-growing gTLD list is that all the companies with well-known brands essentially have to also register their brand under the new TLD as well if they don't want to risk it being taken by criminals or competitors. Why only make money once by selling apple.com if you can also sell apple.biz, apple.xyz, apple.froom etc ad infinitum?
- undersuit 2y agoUltimately every trademark/company has to buy all the domains under their soon to be gTLDed trademark/company. apple.* takes time to gather revenue. *.apple gathers an infinite amount of money quicker.
- fortran77 2y agoI once worked for a big Hollywood studio and they finally stopped registering their name in every new .tld. They reasoned that if anyone used the domain in a way that is a trademark violation, then they could shut them down in court. Otherwise, they'd be chasing ever-increasing (extortion) rates for each new .tld.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoDunno why he had to single out those 3 TLDs in his title. Doesn't really matter that they're the most registered, there's soooo many TLDs now and all equally susceptible to phishing use because users aren't looking closely enough (nor should they really? nobody even knows what a browser is vs 'the internet') or there's no way for anyone to know what's official etc. We needed more TLDs in general, this is just a side effect of the scale.
- miohtama 2y agoIn the similar note, would be nice to see a number how many of .net and .com domains are squatted?
- Havoc 2y agoI’ve got a somewhat questionable tld for my main email address (really nice short one) So far zero issue - somewhat to my surprise (was expecting delivery issues). Even got some compliments from people that thought it’s great
- torton 2y agoWhen I used to run my own email, .top and .xyz received an automatic -10 on spam evaluation. I can't remember a single legitimate website that I actually used and would have had an account on from these TLDs; all I ever saw was spam.
- a-loup-e 2y agoI see a lot of personal blogs that use .xyz here on HN.
- snats 2y agoI use .XYZ because it was pretty cheap when I bought it
- carbine 2y agoI do too, aesthetically it's great. Unfortunately the rise in phishing from xyz domains means if you use it to send email your deliverability is likely to suck.
- aidenn0 2y agoI use .xyz because I have a very common first and last name, and nearly all of the permutations of them were taken on .net, .com, .org, and .us; .xyz seems to price based on how desirable they think the name is, so I still couldn't get $FIRST-$LAST.xyz for a reasonable price, but I got something close.
- forty 2y agoI thought the same, out of the 5 domains listed, I'm not sure I have used any legitimate website using them, so I might as well block them entirely
- cristoperb 2y agoI hope this sentiment isn't too widespread... I use .xyz for my personal blog and primary email :shrug:
- 2y ago
- moelf 2y agoI love https://frame.work/ https://frame.work/ though
- davb 2y agoI use a .xyz for my personal domain (I could get my real name as the domain, and it was cheap). I use FastMail for email. Deliverability has been fine, with one exception - Radisson Red hotels. I’ve had two occasions in the last year when I’ve needed to email different Radisson Red properties, and both silently dropped emails from .xyz domains.
- annoyingnoob 2y agoI've been blocking .shop, .top, .xyz, and several other new TLDs but only specific TLDs where we see high (or all) spam. For our org, this means I also block .in and .jp in SMTP, as those are almost exclusively spam for us too.
- trollbridge 2y agoWhich makes them particularly useless for a legitimate business since it’s likely they’ll be blocked, and begs the question of if they really have any purpose at all.
- Animats 2y agoIt's open season on suckers. With a new crypto-friendly administration coming in, it's going to get much worse. If you haven't been following this, there's a whole industry pushing "meme coins" via pump and dump operations. Some even admit they are pump and dump operations.
- soygem 2y ago>xyz >new >doesn't mention .zip Krebsisters, it's so over
- notatoad 2y agoit seems like if this is a problem, then the whole domain system is a problem. there's nothing that makes .top or .xyz more problematic than .net or .org. if the assertion is that it's too confusing for people to pay attention to all the parts of a domain name, then why do domain names continue to have multiple parts? let's just deprecate everything other than .com and be done with it.
- solanav 2y agoThe problem is not new TLDs, the real problem with phishings in 2024 is that the free Cloudflare layer allows phishers to be protected from automatic phishing detection tools like the ones I develop at my current job. They also don't offer any programs for trusted third parties so we have to spend a lot of time bypassing and paying for services that skip Cloudflare instead of taking down phishing sites.
- rldjbpin 2y agodomain names are like real estate in a poorly-planned city. the city centre is overcrowded and super-expensive, while the new neighbourhoods in the suburbs are a mixed bag. while some become instant hits and sometimes cost more than inside the city (like .ai lately), while you got these tlds that only bring pain. not to forget you are always leasing, and own nothing in the end.
- that_guy_iain 2y agoI remember once I saw a blog post how a companies internal emails were getting blocked because they were on .xyz and got fixed by moving to a .com. After that I decided to only get .xyz domains for internal usage like infra domains or for internal self hosted apps.
- trollbridge 2y agoThe correct way to identify the entity in the address bar is to display the O= (and country, if it differs from the requester) from the X.509 certificate. URLs following a pattern is not a good way to authenticate a site.
- Symbiote 2y agoFor millions of sites, including this one, that would just show "Let's Encrypt, US".
- trollbridge 2y agoAnd that’s the problem. I know I’m talking to “someone who has convinced Let’s Encrypt, US that they are foobar.com”. I have no idea if I’m actually talking to Foobar, Inc. (incorporated in Delaware, US). There is a standard, reliable register of business entities (typically called “Secretary of State”) and it should be trivial to know if the domain I’m talking to is owned by/part of that entity, that the X.509 matches, and so forth.
- Symbiote 2y agoThat is an EV certificate. They are no longer common. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_Validation_Certificate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_Validation_Certificat...
- cluckindan 2y agoTo someone used to seeing the cyrillic alphabet, .top reads ”tor”.