6 ms·
I was one of the earlier folks to put down a pledge for this thing, because it seems like something I'd like to develop for. However, I pulled it back today bec
by eropple 14y ago
I was one of the earlier folks to put down a pledge for this thing, because it seems like something I'd like to develop for. However, I pulled it back today because of the lack of a dev story for it. I was told by the Ouya official twitter account to just "develop on another Android device", which is a very shallow answer given the huge differences in gameplay between a touchscreen device and a gamepad device (and that gamepad-api isn't really viable yet). That suggests that they don't take the craft of game development seriously, and to me that doesn't bode well for the platform.
When they have development resources that show me that they're taking developers seriously, I'll revisit it (and doing so is fairly cheap for me; I'm using the always-awesome libgdx, which has Android support already). But my initial experience has been pretty bad, and I'm questioning their competency right now to the point where I can't give them money.
- lnanek2 14y agoYou can use an Xperia Play, which has slide out game controls, although ICS + Bluetooth controller would be a better route. Almost no games will ever be written for Ouya alone anyway, they'll just be written for Android in general and if Ouya is lucky have a few small tweaks for them like hiding the on screen controls. I've seen games ported from gaming handhelds to Android and the porting company didn't even add support for the D-Pad buttons on some Android devices. Just tossed in on screen touch controls and that is it. Game developers just won't, in general, put much time at all in customizing the game for a specific Android device.
- eropple 14y agoWithout further information about their controller (and the rest of their environment, really), I'm hesitant to just jump right in. And, sure, most developers won't put time in to customize a game for a specific platform, but I'd personally be ashamed if I didn't make it good on every platform I say I support. If it isn't done well, I'd rather not do it, know what I mean? I'm not even sold about supporting the Nexus 7 I've got, because I don't know yet whether I can make it awesome enough. Trash-flood games ruined XBLIG and make finding worthwhile games on the iOS App Store and Google Play way harder than it should be. I won't contribute to the pile of crap.
- sciwiz 14y agoI thought Android 4.0 (ICS) had gamepad support. During ICS launch last winter, they demoed it with XBox controller.
- eropple 14y agoYeah, I went back and edited that--Android 4.0 does have gamepad support, but that doesn't mean it supports Ouya's and I want confirmation that it does, as well as details about a lot of other developer-specific stuff. The Kickstarter feels very consumer-focused, which is great but they still need to have games to sell to people.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoYou make a good point in your posts, but... It raises the question of how this kind of project should be handled. Should they have developer docs ready before fundraising? In the end, that's what it would take to answer your questions. I'm not taking a side on that, it's quite possible that the answer is "Yes, they should have that level of documentation ready." Just thinking about what's best for this kind of Kickstarter.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI think it would help them avoid some common problems if they did have developer documentation prior to the kickstarter launch, that said though it wasn't clear from their page what they were seeking the funding for exactly, and that is where i decided I couldn't participate. Either the funding is "to develop the platform and make it available for developers to write games" or "to get the platform we've developed into production so that games written for it will have a wide audience." If its the former then there is a much bigger gamble here, they may not be able to make it compelling enough to actually be a competitive game platform. If its the latter then they should have the 'big' pieces in place software wise and the remainder might be just refinement. Reading their collateral and listening to their pitch I think it is more if A than it is B but I would love to hear differently. I keep trying to remember the DirectX guy who created a company to make 'game develoment for the masses' and then faded away, damn my aging neurons.
- bryne 14y agoThis is pretty telling. You're right on all points from a developer's perspective, and their line seems to be nothing more than "we're leveraging the big, wide, Android game ecosystem!" I think anyone with hardware or Android game development experience should be healthily skeptical of the tall promises and minimal explanation coming out of this Kickstarter. I love a good chunk of optimism as much as the next guy who loves games, but the fervor seems to really be distorting reality and setting up an inappropriately adversarial tone to these HN discussions.
- cpuspin 14y agoActually, I think they are trying to keep it simple. The Kickstarter pitch doesn't seem written for the developer crowd. The copy is jargon-free and well written (I'm a copywriter so I know a lot about good copy and jack about Android game development). And guess what, their pitch is hitting the mark. It's working.
- eropple 14y agocpuspin: You appear to be hellbanned, though I'm not sure why. But to reply to you--their pitch may be "working" in the sense that they're getting pledges, but the amount of the pledge totals is pretty clearly not going to generate a profit. Without the app store, they're not going to be making money. Without developers, they're not going to be selling anything in their app store, which you need to have populated with games by early 2013. Six to nine months is already not a lot of time to put together a game, so you really, really want to get developers excited for and working on your stuff right effing now. That's where they're falling over. And it is literally-literally as important as getting the consoles to consumers.
- jiggy2011 14y agoYes, this is what worries me too. If they wanted to reel developers in on this what they should be releasing like right now is some documentation for developers. Since the hardware is not released yet they should be showing developers how to emulate as-close-as-possible to this on a regular PC (including which commodity joypad you should be testing with) so they can be confident that their game will only require minor tweaking when the final hardware is released. OT: It seems to be very easy to get HellBanned from HN which makes it seem pretty cruel. You only need a handful of people not to like your first few posts to effectively kill your chances of contributing to the community and potentially wasting a lot of your time. Perhaps a system like , you can only downvote comments from users under a certain karma threshold if you also flag them as trolling/spam
- jiggy2011 14y agoI agree, there seems to be a bit of handwaving over whether this is something that is designed for existing android games or whether you are supposed to be developing new ones for this. I'm not a games programmer , but I would certainly be interested in building a small simple game for this and having at least a demo ready for the console launch. It's interesting that you mention LibGDX as something that could work well here. Let's say I want to build a game that is designed around joypad control would my best bet be to build a game with LibGDX using the lwjgl backend (for PC) and plug in an xbox pad to test the gameplay? What about testing performance? Slightly OT: LibGDX seems to have relatively scant documentation in terms of examples of significant working code so it is difficult for me to think about how to best structure the code for the engine. Are there any books that cover this specific to LibGDX? I can't find any.
- badlogic 14y agoHope this helps http://libgdx.badlogicgames.com/documentation.html http://libgdx.badlogicgames.com/documentation.html there are quite a few demo games we have in the repo, tests as well as third party oss games you can look at.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI've seen that page before , but didn't notice the code repos listed there. Thanks.
- eropple 14y agolibgdx is extensively javadoc'd, but best-practices materials are pretty weak. It's something I'd like to contribute to at some point, but I'd like to get my own stuff going first. The bigger issue right now, as far as libgdx on Ouya would be, is that libgdx doesn't support controllers yet. But badlogic (who also replied to you--he's the main dev behind libgdx) seems to have some ideas on that one. I wanted to start in on writing a gamepad extension to their input system last night, but pulling down a clone with git-svn took most of an hour and I ran out of time. =)
- 14y ago
- badlogic 14y agoI already tried to get in contact with them, no reply. My optimistic assumption is they are overwhelmed with the response and need time. My pessimistic assumption is that they don't care for apparently small fish like libgdx. Thing is that we power more Android games than Unity or AndEngine according to AppBrain [1], that has to count for something. They need developers, we can get them those if they let us in early. On the other hand it's probably more important to get the marketing sping going with Unity or Notch. We'll see. edit: [1] http://www.appbrain.com/stats/libraries/details/libgdx/libgdx http://www.appbrain.com/stats/libraries/details/libgdx/libgd...
- jiggy2011 14y agoI would certainly hope you would be higher up on their list of priorities, in fact if I was in their shoes I would be contacting you. If I develop a game for this, using LibGDX seems like a no-brainer because even if this is a total flop I can at least pivot it into a PC game.
- munificent 14y ago> I was told by the Ouya official twitter account to just "develop on another Android device", which is a very shallow answer Well, how deep of an answer were you expecting on twitter? Instead of trying to infer what the 140 character limitation suggests, maybe email them?
- rektide 14y agoMy biggest fear is Ouya being anything other than another Android device that runs Android software. I'm terrified the company tries to create their own platform, rather than just creating a very solid reference hardware that'd be ideal for Android gaming. The completely non-standard gamepad with display is a terrifying hint that Ouya is trying to do their own thing, not build a good solid ecosystem device.
- gergles 14y agoThere is no display on the gamepad.
- sneak 14y agoI figured that out in 20 seconds of watching the video when she said "write your own programming".
- bawb 14y agoWhere is this tweet from @playouya? I looked through all of their over 200 tweets and there's no quote: "develop on another Android device."