3 ms·
> “For example a cellular picocell costs from $7,500 to $15,000 whereas a much higher capacity carrier-grade Wi-Fi access point costs around $2,000,” Thanki wro
by jessriedel 14y ago
> “For example a cellular picocell costs from $7,500 to $15,000 whereas a much higher capacity carrier-grade Wi-Fi access point costs around $2,000,” Thanki wrote. “The cost of a Wi-Fi chipset for a consumer device is around $5, whereas 3G cellular chipsets costs around $30.
Won't a cell tower cover at least a couple orders of magnitude more area than a wifi access point? Is this analysis silly or am I missing something?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cdash 14y agoWell he said a picocell which is around an order of magnitude greater range. I am not sure that range is the most important thing as towers become more and more congested I am pretty sure we are moving to smaller and smaller ranges.
- jessriedel 14y ago>Well he said a picocell which is around an order of magnitude greater range [than a WiFi access point]. Ahh, yea, this is the key point. For those who aren't in the know: "A picocell is a small cellular basestation typically covering a small area, such as in-building (offices, shopping malls, train stations, stock exchanges, etc.), or more recently in-aircraft. In cellular networks, picocells are typically used to extend coverage to indoor areas where outdoor signals do not reach well, or to add network capacity in areas with very dense phone usage, such as train stations. Picocells provide coverage and capacity in areas difficult or expensive to reach using the more traditional Macrocell approach." [wikipedia] > I am not sure that range is the most important thing as towers become more and more congested I am pretty sure we are moving to smaller and smaller ranges. Not where I live in New Mexico :)
- natrius 14y agoI think the argument is that a given amount of spectrum has a maximum capacity of data that can be transmitted. Using one cell tower to serve a large area (which means a large number of devices and a large amount of data) caps the amount of data that can be transmitted within that area. There are two solutions to that: use more spectrum or serve smaller areas. If you're serving smaller areas, there are cheaper technologies available than 3G, and they also don't require dedicated spectrum.
- jessriedel 14y agoI see. So this argument is really only directed at urban areas where there is already total coverage but the bandwidth per user is limited because of congestion.
- sp332 14y agoYes, plus the cell network has dedicated bandwidth for each client whereas clients will fight for bandwidth on a wifi access point.
- ef4 14y agoBy that argument, you could also just build one extremely powerful tower and cover a vast region. But that would support far less data, because everyone in the region would be waiting for a turn to broadcast at the same frequency. This is why cellular phones are called cellular phones. The key enabling technology was the ability to divide a large geographic area into many smaller cells. Each cell needs to use different frequencies than its neighboring cells, but you can reuse the same frequencies many times across the wider region. The smaller you make the cells, the more data you can pack into the same set of frequencies, because non-neighboring cells can be using the same frequency concurrently.
- cma 14y agoAlso, each tower has many directional antennas, so one tower acts as multiple cells.
- CapitalistCartr 14y agoWith analog cellular, yes. With digital cellular, several connections can share a given frequency, somewhat expanding the number of connections per tower, although there is still a limit. However, I find that AT&T ignores the pressing bandwidth needs of the customers. During rush hour, no matter how perfect my signal strength, I get terrible data bandwidth. Its not the cell tower, its the connection from there onward.
- jff 14y agoPlus, with a single huge tower, your handsets are fighting the inverse square law as they struggle to pump out enough wattage to keep a connection.