3 ms·
Keep in mind that this bust was a paid subscription service. That’s how they were netting €250 million per month. The hypothetical damages amount is moot. They
by Aurornis 2y ago
Keep in mind that this bust was a paid subscription service. That’s how they were netting €250 million per month.
The hypothetical damages amount is moot. They were charging a specific amount of money and people were paying it. That amount was high enough that you can completely ignore any inflated estimates and they were still doing a huge amount of criminal business.
- jtbayly 2y agoThose numbers are clearly false at a glance. Here is somebody who bothered to look into it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42292435 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42292435
- sushid 2y agoThere's no way that they were netting 250MM EUR per month. Just think of that number. That's 3 BILLION EUR per year! Putting that into perspective, Gitlab is on track to do around just 580MM USD this year and is valued at 8 billion dollars in market cap. Something tells me that their revenue isn't is 10% of Netflix.
- roenxi 2y agoThe Gitlab comparison makes it sound more realistic to me. Nobody pays for a subscription to Gitlab, 99% of humanity doesn't know what git is and it is quite plausible that of the remainder 99% don't pay for Gitlab. Compare that to streaming where at least >20% of the population know what it is and >20% of that seem to pay for streaming as a service. Much bigger market, and being a pirate site seems like it'd give them and an edge in the market because their catalogue would be better than any legal operation.
- sushid 2y agoObviously a lot of factors are at play for SaaS pricing but that would mean it would be worth at least around 50 billion USD in market cap if it were a legitimate business. Seems highly unlikely.
- roenxi 2y agoWhat would make that unlikely? Sounds like a pretty reasonable valuation. Netflix is $400 Billion USD for ~300 million subscribers and is likely an inferior product to a pirate streaming site (otherwise, obviously, the pirate subscribers would go with Netflix). $50 billion for ~20 million users seems ballpark plausible. Note that black markets exist because there is enugh demand for a product that it overwhelms the ability of the army/police to enforce the law. This site is obviously going to be doing something economically popular. If it wasn't making a killing, ol' mate running the place would go find some other career.
- sushid 2y agoTo me, it seems unlikely that a singular, blatantly illegal service that is > 10% as popular as Netflix would go unnoticed by the legal authorities. And given the comments below indicating that it was a mistranslation, it's a moot point- it was wrong after all.
- jokethrowaway 2y agoMoreover they found only 1.6M in cryptocurrency, which would be the income they get in 5 hours No chance they were making 250M and were able to stash it away so neatly and so fast that they found so little money
- protocolture 2y agoYeah but some of these services still offer something that official alternatives do not. I used to support an apartment building with a lot of residents from India. They all had IPTV boxes with some pirate channel for accessing some in demand cricket comp, and the support requests would all coincide with the streams. And in general they got lots of other local content outside the region locking. Mostly keeping up with India. They got the content for free in india, but paid a small fee to access it remotely, not caring who provided it. They all seemed to believe there was no financially reasonable alternative way to access the content and we never really bothered them about it as its not the carriers job to police IMHO. Likewise I see tons of yanks complaining about Disney+ not carrying Alien Romulus, when outside of the US its on the app. All self imposed considering Disney owns a large amount of Hulu but is beefing with the remaining shareholders IIRC. Plainly nonsense region locking seems to be driving piracy. And if someones making 250 million per month circumventing it then it sort of implies the solution doesnt it?
- JBlue42 2y ago>Likewise I see tons of yanks complaining about Disney+ not carrying Alien Romulus, when outside of the US its on the app. All self imposed considering Disney owns a large amount of Hulu but is beefing with the remaining shareholders IIRC. That's odd. Disney+ (with ads) is $10/mo on its own. $11/mo for the bundle of D+/Hulu (with ads). Alien: Romulus is on Hulu right now.