2 ms·
> Disagree that it's easy to pin on "how they were brought up". Indeed. That might play a role, but another less politically charged aspect to look at is just
by eru 2y ago
> Disagree that it's easy to pin on "how they were brought up".
Indeed. That might play a role, but another less politically charged aspect to look at is just: how much effort is the human currently putting in?
Humans are often on autopilot, perhaps even most of the time. Autopilot means taking lazy intellectual shortcuts. And to echo your argument: in familiar environments those shortcuts are often a good idea!
If you just do whatever worked last time you were in a similar situation, or whatever your peers are doing, chances are you'll have an easier time than reasoning everything out from scratch. Especially in any situations involving other humans cooperating with you, predictability itself is an asset.
- tsumnia 2y ago> And to echo your argument: in familiar environments those shortcuts are often a good idea! Only to continue to reaffirm the original post, this was some of the basis for my dissertation. Lower-level practice, or exposure to tons of interactive worked examples, allowed students to train the "mental muscle memory" for coding syntax to learn the more general CS concept (like loops instead of for(int i = 0...). The shortcut in this case is learning what the syntax for a loop looks like so that it can BECOME a shortcut. Once its automatic, then it can be compartmentalized as "loop" instead of getting anxious over where the semicolons go.
- Terr_ 2y ago> Humans are often on autopilot, perhaps even most of the time I wonder what responsiveness/results someone would get running an LLM with just ~20 watts for processing and memory, especially if it was getting trained at the same time. That said, we do have a hardware advantage, what with the enormous swarm of nano-bots using technology and techniques literally beyond our best science. :p
- eru 2y agoThere's another advantage: Humans and human language have co-evolved to be compatible. Language makes no such allowance for the needs and quirks of LLMs. (However to a certain extent we design our LLMs to be able to deal with human language.)
- mistermann 2y agoClimate change and war are excellent examples demonstrating how far Humans are willing/obligated to take this convention.