3 ms·
I tried for a few minutes to find the HN thread where somebody refuted the "handwriting is better than typing" for fact recall claim. OTOH, IIRC, - EEG measur
by westurner 2y ago
I tried for a few minutes to find the HN thread where somebody refuted the "handwriting is better than typing" for fact recall claim.
OTOH, IIRC,
- EEG measures brain activation. It takes more of the brain to hand write than to type, and so it is unsurprising that there is more activation during a writing by hand activity than during a typing activity.
- Do brain connectivity or neural activation correspond to favorable outcomes?
- Synaptic pruning eliminates connectivity in the brain; and that is presumably advantageous.
- Hyperconnectivity may be regarded as a disadvantage in discussions of neurodiversity. Witness recall from a network with intentional hyperconnectivity; too distracted by spurious activations?
- That's a test of dumb recall, which is a test of trivia retention.
- Is rote memorization the pinnacle of learning? To foster creative thinking and critical thinking, is trivia recall optimization ideal?
- (Isn't it necessary to forget so much of what we've been taught in order to succeed.)
- Is spaced repetition as or more effective than hand writing at increasing recall compared to passively listening?
- With persons who have injury and/or disability that prevents them from handwriting, do they have adaptations that enable them to succeed despite "having to" type instead?
- We don't hand write software; though some schools teach coding with pen and paper (and that somewhat reduces cheating, which confounds variance in success and retention).
- We write tests for software; we can't efficiently automatedly test software for quality and correctness unless the code is typed.
- Does anything ever grade, confirm, reject, or validate handwritten notes?
- Are there studies of this that measure recall after typing, and then after handwriting, too?
Edit: A, measure, B, measure; AND: B, measure, A, measure
- ElFitz 2y ago> I tried for a few minutes to find the HN thread where somebody refuted the "handwriting is better than typing" for fact recall claim. You would have found it, had you written it down. Kidding aside, is this the one? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42288545 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42288545
- westurner 2y agoThe one I recall had citations, I think