4 ms·
Why it took a long time to build that tiny link preview on Wikipedia (2018)
- weberer 2y agoI'd like to see a similar write-up for dark mode. It took 20 years and it still says "beta" even though its basically switching a CSS template. Its a pattern I've seen over many different websites, so there must be a common reason.
- bawolff 2y agoThe answer is somewhere between - nobody really cared enough to try until the last few years, combined with allowing users to write their own css means there is a very long tail of content that is assuming light mode which needs to be fixed.
- kemayo 2y agoMostly, there's a large amount of CSS that has been written over the years that assumed it was on a light-colored website. In mediawiki itself, in mediawiki extensions, in gadgets and userscripts, and in site-specific overrides across all the Wikiprojects. Most annoyingly to deal with, sometimes hardcoded into pages -- table formatting on wikipedia is often using inline styles to get specific background colors, for instance. You can see a few hundred tickets about dark-mode related issues if you're curious what's been done and why it's still in beta: https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/maniphest/query/8zofdVSnraVd/ https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/maniphest/query/8zofdVSnra... (I work for Wikimedia. I didn't work on dark mode, beyond a few minor adjustments to components I do work on to be compatible with it.)
- weberer 2y agoWow, that link is a great resource. Thanks for the info
- throwaway314155 2y agoIs this the same link preview that Eliezer Yudkowsky claimed to have invented first on the Lex Fridman podcast?
- kemayo 2y agotl;dr it's the same feature he's talking about, but also he's wrong in a very Yudkowsky way. I was curious about this so I hunted it down: https://youtu.be/AaTRHFaaPG8?si=NbIe3hBSovvOQA-G&t=4483 https://youtu.be/AaTRHFaaPG8?si=NbIe3hBSovvOQA-G&t=4483 He speculates that Wikipedia got the idea from Arbital. Insofar as I can tell, that seems to be a wiki-like website that started around 2015 -- I had never heard of it, so it might be older? That does predate this specific implementation of popups on Wikipedia, which is from 2018. The fun context here is actually discussed in the article -- the genesis of the Wikipedia popups was a community gadget on Wikipedia (Navigation Popups) that's from much earlier. Oldest version I could casually dig up on Wikipedia is from 2007. Unless Arbital is vastly older than I think (older than LessWrong itself, which is from 2009), the chain of inspiration is presumably in the other direction. Or completely independent. The article is, overall, about why it took so long to go from that working example to something more robust.
- throwaway314155 2y agoFor me, the idea that one could even lay claim to having "invented" a feature like that is very suspicious. Surely it was discovered independently by several people and the stakes are so low in any case that it just felt like Yudkowsky trying to get technical credit for it by having it edited into his wikipedia after regurgitating it on a popular podcast (or something similarly shady and ultimately petty). The actions of a man who is insecure about his lack of accomplishments (aside from having money and using that money to prop himself up).
- baggy_trough 2y agoHorrible feature.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- agnishom 2y agoCan you please share with us what is so bad about this feature?
- genter 2y agoIt's extremely annoying to have shit randomly popping up to cover what I'm trying to read. It's so annoying that I can't comprehend how anyone can't find it annoying.
- hackernewds 2y agoI agree, however pop-ups are the worst
- bawolff 2y agoPersonally I love them, but fyi you can disable by clicking the wheel icon https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Page_Previews#Logged-Out_Users https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Page_Previews#Logged-Out_User...
- genter 2y agoThanks, in my 34 years sitting in front of a computer, I never learned that you can change settings.
- Tyrannosaur 2y agoYour tone comes across as sarcastic, yet I cannot believe you haven't met at least several people who have used computers for 34+ years who didn't know you can change some basic setting.
- tekchip 2y agoThis sort of thing is a dang nightmare. Perk your mouse in the wrong place or scroll and stop at the wrong place with your mouse over the page and all of a sudden you're not reading what you were reading. This is happening all over the place on the web and an apps. Sometimes it's moderately useful like this looks like it could be but sometimes it's just completely superfluous.
- nayuki 2y agoAgreed, and I'm not the only one to think this. The hover previews are SO DISTRACTING because I move my mouse around when I read an article, and I also like to select text to visually maintain my reading position. I have accidentally clicked into the previewed link quite a few times before, forcing me to hit the back button to compensate.
- somishere 2y agoI quite like this feature - so much so I've been pushing to build something similar out at work. The main missing piece is mobile / touch. Not sure if anyone's aware of iterations that solve for this?
- block_dagger 2y agoThank goodness for OpenGraph.
- dang 2y agoRelated: Why it took a long time to build that tiny link preview on Wikipedia - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27260304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27260304 - May 2021 (27 comments) Why it took a long time to build the tiny link preview on Wikipedia - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16901599 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16901599 - April 2018 (243 comments)
- underwater 2y agoI wonder why they didn’t do the obvious thing for a crowd sourced site and introduce a manual way to define this content. CMS’s for news publishers have distinct fields for link title and thumbnail images (appearing on the linking page) and article title and hero images (appearing on the destination page). This seems redundant until you consider that the context for linking pages and the article page are different. Having clean summaries for each page on Wikipedia seems like it would be useful in many places.
- brudgers 2y agoI guess 2018 must be when I blocked wikipedia with noscript. I am sure some people find the feature useful, I did not...and as a bonus I don't get the requests for money. YMMV.
- gwervc 2y agoEnshitification is slower on Wikipedia than elsewhere, but sadly still happening. I'm still upset about the language button that cause me one additional click instead of the direct links on the left menu.
- bawolff 2y agoFwiw,if you are logged in you can switch your skin in Special:preferences to bring the old look back.
- dylan604 2y agologged in? do people that are not editors do that?
- bawolff 2y agoI mean, if you hate the new skin enough, seems like a valid reason. Not really any downside. Remember my log in has an expiry of about a year so you don't have to be continously logging in. Banner ads are not shown to logged in users which is nice. Wikimedia doesn't really do tracking of reads, so dont have to worry about that (i mean, i suppose web servers have logs, but that is true if logged out too). I suppose maybe its slightly slower since only logged out views are handled by geolocated servers so there is a bit more latency if you aren't in north america.
- Izkata 2y agoIf you don't want to log in you can add ?useskin=vector to any wikipedia URL to get the same. There's a few others as well and they have a bookmarklet you can add to just click on to switch the current page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Skin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Skin