3 ms·
Hard disagree. The aftermarket is stronger than ever. V8s have been replaced by turbo engines which respond much more dramatically to modifications than any N/
by Aurornis 2y ago
Hard disagree. The aftermarket is stronger than ever.
V8s have been replaced by turbo engines which respond much more dramatically to modifications than any N/A V8.
There are numerous enthusiasts cars to pick from across manufacturers.
Tuning companies operate globally. People get their tunes from obscure companies in Europe.
ECU protections are being cracked regularly. Even “unhackable” ECUs are getting tunes year after year.
Stick shift options are available on a lot of enthusiasts cars. They’re slower, but people can get them if they want.
I’ve been hearing talk about the death of the car aftermarket for a decade, but every time it’s really just someone lamenting that it’s changing. I think people just get upset when the car scene of their younger years is no longer the popular scene (Mustangs and Camaros with V8s and stick shifts)
- bluedino 2y agoThe American V8 was a high performance product at an entry level price. During the last couple years the Dodge twins got ridiculously expensive (the Challenger 392 is now almost as expensive as the Hellcat was in 2016). The problem with the turbo engines is they are way more expensive to do anything with and they come in expensive cars. BMW, Audi really being the only things that are 'fast'. Subaru, Kia, VW are all pretty much low-level performance. And then you have really expensive stuff like the Nissan GT-R. Turbo engines have been around for a long time, they're nothing new. And they have always been part of the car scene. But again, the lower price options aren't really competitive, they were at least close in the 2000's. And again, the Ford ECU has been out for two years and nobody has cracked it.
- _yb2s 2y agoI disagree on both of these. Turbo engines are usually much cheaper to tune- most of the time you can substantially increase the power with just more boost. More serious power requires a bigger turbo and bigger injectors which is still cheap and easy - an afternoon install with the engine still in the car. Tunable turbocharged European sports cars cost next to nothing once they’re a decade or two old.
- bluedino 2y agoYou need more than just a tune for reliability and real power. Sure you can get a cheap boost but everyone is going to realize they need to add hard parts like downpipes and intercoolers. Then you get into drivetrain issues. And you're talking about a very, very small group compared to the old days when the hobby was more popular. Honda Civica and Ford Mustangs were such a hugely popular vehicle to modify.
- _yb2s 2y agoIt’s all a matter of the vehicle and what your goals are- sure at some point you need to modify everything else, but a turbo car gets a lot further to start with for a lot less money. I grew up tuning old Volvos and Mercedes and they were so well made and undertuned from the factory you could just about double the horsepower for next to nothing and they were still reliable. Early on they even used massively oversized turbos that had a ton of lag but could really have the boost cranked up. European cars, especially older ones tended to be heavily overengineered - with the drivetrain, cooling system, suspension, brakes, etc. massively oversized compared to Japanese and American cars.
- bluedino 2y agoSure - but my point is the hobby is nowhere near as popular/mainstream as it was before
- ethbr1 2y ago> undertuned from the factory This seems to be a big component of then vs now. Previously companies lacked precision modeling and simulation and so often simply overbuilt parts. Now, costs have been cut and fuel efficiency standards are much higher, so systems are more tightly engineered from the factory.
- willis936 2y ago> Tunable turbocharged European sports cars cost next to nothing once they’re a decade or two old. I'd like some specific examples (I'm in the market for cheap sports cars). Keep in mind RWD is part of the definition of a sports car.
- _yb2s 2y agoI agree- I’m active on forums and in the “scene” of modifying turbocharged European cars. It’s alive and well and the DIY technology has come so far from 20 years ago- now with totally open source fuel injection systems, etc. People are doubling and tripling the power on cars you can buy cheap on Craigslist, and they still hold up well.
- sourcepluck 2y agoAny recommendations on where to best locate this scene? Forums, etc. Sounds intriguing.
- _yb2s 2y agoDepends on what car you're interested in- take a look at vwvortex.com, pelican parts and rennlist (for Porsche), audiworld, turbobricks (Volvo).
- jmb99 2y ago> V8s have been replaced by turbo engines which respond much more dramatically to modifications than any N/A V8. While technically true, it’s not the same. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve owned (and enjoyed!) both, but a highly strung big-boost inline 4 is not the same as a big V8. The instant throttle response, torque for days wherever you are in the rev range, the noise, nothing else can match it. If you want concrete evidence of this, look at the sheer variety of cars that become more fun with a big V8. Yeah, a corvette is an awesome sports car, but the same engine turns grandpa’s Buick into a genuine enthusiast car (Impala SS). You can’t put a 300HP tiny inline 4 in a comfy sedan and expect it to become fun, it just becomes a bit faster. And anyone who’s ever modified American V8s knows how easy they are to get power out of. Yeah, you can turn up the boost on a 2.0T for a few hundred bucks, but for double that you can take a 260HP 5.7L from the 90s (that costs $500 to buy a whole ‘nother engine, by the way, if you blow it up), slap on some heads and a cam, and make 400HP and 400lb-ft of torque - or more if you don’t mind sacrificing a bit of streetability. Or spend like $5k on heads, cam, an intake port job, and some eBay turbos & manifold and make 550/500 for a few years until you want more, turn up the boost, and blow it up. Or go even cheaper and spend a grand on eBay turbos & manifolds and do nothing to the engine, and still make like 400HP. Anyways, long/rambling way of saying turbo 4s don’t replace V8s. Pretty much the only similarity in their behaviour is that they both ICEs. People that love V8s won’t be swayed by “but the turbo 4s make just as much power!” because that’s not what they care about.
- ericd 2y agoHow about intensely torquey EVs? Except for the sound, they seem like they’d be just as fun, even better throttle response than N/A. I guess there’s not the same hackability, though.
- jmb99 2y agoNot the same hackability, but also limits. If you want to make, say, 1500HP, that’s 1120kW. Assuming even a pack voltage of 900V, that’s still 1240 amps that has to be dealt with. Wiring/interconnects have to be huge and water cooled, as do the batteries (if they can even handle 1100+kW discharge), motors will probably have to be water cooled, and you definitely wouldn’t get more than a few runs in before everything is heat soaked. And enough cells to be able to sustain 1100kW for even 6-10 seconds is going to weigh a lot, probably more than an engine + drivetrain + fuel.