3 ms·
Even more ridiculous.. the full quote is: "We might be able to setup space mirrors or otherwise increasing the reflectivity of our atmosphere. Obviously, we ca
by grecy 14y ago
Even more ridiculous.. the full quote is:
"We might be able to setup space mirrors or otherwise increasing the reflectivity of our atmosphere. Obviously, we cannot hope to both keep pumping CO2 in the atmosphere, and correct for it afterward: this could quickly become economically infeasible."
In the context of killing the planet and the entire human race, we still mention a plan could be "economically infeasible".
Jeez.
- CamperBob2 14y agoSigh. We're not going to "kill the planet," or the entire human race. Humans adapt. That's what we do. That's why we won. Such hyperbole endangers vital rational discourse on the subject.
- allardschip 14y agoA run a way process in which we loose all life on earth is not something I have read a lot of proof for. However, adapting to a changed climate may not be a pretty phase for the human race.
- mistercow 14y ago>We're not going to "kill the planet," or the entire human race. Humans adapt. That's what we do. That's why we won. That is very close to the "fine tuning" argument often employed by creationists. It is entirely possible that humans have, in fact, merely been phenomenally lucky to have survived so far, and that the fact that we find ourselves as members of such a phenomenally lucky species is easily explained by the anthropic principle. If you take all of the intelligent critters out there in the universe that are capable of discussing their adaptability, a pretty big chunk of those critters are going to be members of civilizations that got very lucky over the ages and managed to produce large cumulative populations, while a very small proportion will be critters from short-lived civilizations. Indeed, holding constant whatever level of adaptability we actually have, it is reasonable to assume that we are among the luckier of the civilizations at that level. So no, we can't just assume that we're going to leap over any hurdle that comes our way.
- oelewapperke 14y agoSure we can. We just should understand what any adaptation means : killing 90% of the human race. But when it comes to extinction, we can be pretty sure that's not going to happen. Is 90% dead much better ? Probably not for the economy.
- anthonyb 14y agoExcept that there are civilisations which have died out due to overexploiting their environment, or the climate changing and killing off their agriculture. That's two risks. You can add others now which haven't previously been possible, such as disturbing your ecosystems to the point where there's another mass extinction looming, or changing the climate to the point where you spark famine, wars, lack of water, etc. That's where all of the rational discourse backed by evidence (aka. science) is pointing.
- anthonyb 14y agoI tend to give people the benefit of the doubt, and read economic arguments like that in the sense of "we will need to spend a large chunk of our civilisation's energy/material output to do this", not "Oh noes! My small, green pieces of paper!" The thing that I worry about with the economic arguments is that the climate and/or ecosystems will reach a tipping point before we get to the point where we need to do something, and that chunk will be > 100%.