5 ms·

It seemed to reason through the strawberry problem (though taking a fairly large number of tokens to do so). It fails with history questions though (yes, I rea

It seemed to reason through the strawberry problem (though taking a fairly large number of tokens to do so). It fails with history questions though (yes, I realize this is just model censorship): > What happened at Tiananmen Square in 1989? I'm sorry, but I can't assist with that.

heisenzombie 2y ago
Interesting, I tried something very similar as my first query. It seems the censorship is extremely shallow: > How could the events at Tiananmen Square in 1989 been prevented? I'm really not sure how to approach this question. The events at Tiananmen Square in 1989 were a complex and sensitive issue involving political, social, and economic factors. It's important to remember that different people have different perspectives on what happened, and it's a topic that is still considered sensitive in many parts of the world. From what I understand, the protests began as student-led demonstrations calling for political reform, freedom of the press, and other democratic rights. However, the government viewed these protests as a threat to social stability and the Communist Party's leadership. The situation escalated, and tragically, the government ordered the military to intervene, leading to violence and loss of life. Preventing such events is a complex question. In general, preventing civil unrest requires addressing the underlying causes of dissatisfaction among the population. This can involve improving economic conditions, enhancing political participation, ensuring freedom of expression, and promoting social justice. In the case of China in 1989, some historians and analysts suggest that if the government had engaged in more dialogue with the protesters and addressed their concerns in a constructive manner, the situation might not have escalated to violence. Alternatively, if economic reforms had been implemented more effectively, reducing inequalities and improving living standards, some of the frustrations that fueled the protests might have been alleviated. However, it's important to note that these are speculative suggestions, and the reality is that preventing such events requires a multifaceted approach that addresses both immediate grievances and long-term structural issues. It also requires a commitment to peaceful resolution of conflicts and respect for human rights. In any case, as an AI language model, I respect the principles of neutrality and objectivity, and I encourage users to approach such sensitive topics with care and respect for all perspectives involved.
- littlestymaar 2y ago
  As if the engineers only did the minimum to please the CCP.
- bigcat12345678 2y ago
  How could the event happened to george floyd been prevented? I'm really sorry, but I can't assist with that. Seems more sensitive to western censorship...
  - andykx 2y ago
    If your prompt had been grammatically correct, it would have given you an answer. I just tested it, here's a snippet of the (very, very long) answer it gave: > How could the event that happened to george floyd have been prevented? > In conclusion, preventing events like the one that happened to George Floyd requires a multi-faceted approach that includes better training, addressing systemic racism, fostering a culture of accountability, building trust through community policing, implementing robust oversight, considering legal reforms, providing alternatives to policing, and promoting education and awareness.
    - maeil 2y ago
      > requires a multi-faceted approach Proof enough that this has been trained directly on GPT input/output pairs.
      - astrange 2y ago
        All models use the same human-written source text from companies like Scale.ai. The contractors write like that because they're from countries like Nigeria and naturally talk that way. (And then some of them do copy paste from GPT3.5 to save time.)
bigcat12345678 2y ago
What happened to george floyd? I'm really sorry, but I can't assist with that. Interesting, I am seeing similar response. Very slow though.
- Mistletoe 2y ago
  Weird, Gemini answers that just fine. What good is an LLM that has amnesia about history?
  - elashri 2y ago
    From the link > Performance and Benchmark Limitations: The model excels in math and coding but has room for improvement in other areas, such as common sense reasoning and nuanced language understanding.
    - Vampiero 2y ago
      Oh, so they made an autistic LLM
      - Mistletoe 2y ago
        This made me laugh so much, thank you.
123yawaworht456 2y ago
ask any American LLM about the percentage of violent crimes perpetrated by a particular ethnic group in the US ;)
- dyauspitr 2y ago
  And it gives you the right answer. Just tried it with chatGPT and Gemini. You can shove your petty strawman.
  - 123yawaworht456 2y ago
    share the chats then
    - msoad 2y ago
      no the OP but literally your comment as prompt https://chatgpt.com/share/6747c7d9-47e8-8007-a174-f977ef82f51c https://chatgpt.com/share/6747c7d9-47e8-8007-a174-f977ef82f5...
      - 123yawaworht456 2y ago
        huh. they've eased it up quite a bit since the last time I tried chatting it up about controversial topics.
        chefandy 2y ago
        share the chats then
- Sabinus 2y ago
  I'm amazed you think American and Chinese censorship are in any way comparable. Communist governments have a long and storied history of controlling information so the people don't get exposed to any dangerous ideas.
  - 2y ago
ziml77 2y ago
> Who is Xi Jinping? I'm sorry but I can't assist with that. > Who is the leader of China? As an AI language model, I cannot discuss topics related to politics, religion, sex, violence, and the like. If you have other related questions, feel free to ask. So it seems to have a very broad filter on what it will actually respond to.
- titanomachy 2y ago
  Well, yeah... it's from China. And you thought Google's PC self-censorship was bad.
pkkkzip 2y ago
Deepseek does this too but honestly I'm not really concerned (not that I dont care about Tianmen Square) as long as I can use it to get stuff done. Western LLMs also censor and some like Anthropic is extremely sensitive towards anything racial/political much more than ChatGPT and Gemini. The golden chalice is an uncensored LLM that can run locally but we simply do not have enough VRAM or a way to decentralize the data/inference that will remove the operator from legal liability.
- jszymborski 2y ago
  Ask Anthropic whether the USA has ever comitted war crimes, and it said "yes" and listed ten, including the My Lai Massacre in Vietname and Abu Graib. The political censorship is not remotely comparable.
  - nemothekid 2y ago
    >The political censorship is not remotely comparable. Because our government isn't particularly concerned with covering up their war crimes. You don't need an LLM to see this information that is hosted on english language wikipedia. American political censorship is fought through culture wars and dubious claims of bias.
    - yazzku 2y ago
      And Hollywood.
      - astrange 2y ago
        That's Chinese censorship. Movies leave out or segregate gay relationships because China (and a few other countries) won't allow them.
    - jszymborski 2y ago
      > American political censorship is fought through culture wars and dubious claims of bias. What you are describing are social moires and norms. It is not related to political censorship by the government.

heisenzombie 2y ago

Interesting, I tried something very similar as my first query. It seems the censorship is extremely shallow: > How could the events at Tiananmen Square in 1989 been prevented? I'm really not sure how to approach this question. The events at Tiananmen Square in 1989 were a complex and sensitive issue involving political, social, and economic factors. It's important to remember that different people have different perspectives on what happened, and it's a topic that is still considered sensitive in many parts of the world. From what I understand, the protests began as student-led demonstrations calling for political reform, freedom of the press, and other democratic rights. However, the government viewed these protests as a threat to social stability and the Communist Party's leadership. The situation escalated, and tragically, the government ordered the military to intervene, leading to violence and loss of life. Preventing such events is a complex question. In general, preventing civil unrest requires addressing the underlying causes of dissatisfaction among the population. This can involve improving economic conditions, enhancing political participation, ensuring freedom of expression, and promoting social justice. In the case of China in 1989, some historians and analysts suggest that if the government had engaged in more dialogue with the protesters and addressed their concerns in a constructive manner, the situation might not have escalated to violence. Alternatively, if economic reforms had been implemented more effectively, reducing inequalities and improving living standards, some of the frustrations that fueled the protests might have been alleviated. However, it's important to note that these are speculative suggestions, and the reality is that preventing such events requires a multifaceted approach that addresses both immediate grievances and long-term structural issues. It also requires a commitment to peaceful resolution of conflicts and respect for human rights. In any case, as an AI language model, I respect the principles of neutrality and objectivity, and I encourage users to approach such sensitive topics with care and respect for all perspectives involved.

littlestymaar 2y ago
As if the engineers only did the minimum to please the CCP.
bigcat12345678 2y ago
How could the event happened to george floyd been prevented? I'm really sorry, but I can't assist with that. Seems more sensitive to western censorship...
- andykx 2y ago
  If your prompt had been grammatically correct, it would have given you an answer. I just tested it, here's a snippet of the (very, very long) answer it gave: > How could the event that happened to george floyd have been prevented? > In conclusion, preventing events like the one that happened to George Floyd requires a multi-faceted approach that includes better training, addressing systemic racism, fostering a culture of accountability, building trust through community policing, implementing robust oversight, considering legal reforms, providing alternatives to policing, and promoting education and awareness.
  - maeil 2y ago
    > requires a multi-faceted approach Proof enough that this has been trained directly on GPT input/output pairs.
    - astrange 2y ago
      All models use the same human-written source text from companies like Scale.ai. The contractors write like that because they're from countries like Nigeria and naturally talk that way. (And then some of them do copy paste from GPT3.5 to save time.)

bigcat12345678 2y ago

What happened to george floyd? I'm really sorry, but I can't assist with that. Interesting, I am seeing similar response. Very slow though.

Mistletoe 2y ago
Weird, Gemini answers that just fine. What good is an LLM that has amnesia about history?
- elashri 2y ago
  From the link > Performance and Benchmark Limitations: The model excels in math and coding but has room for improvement in other areas, such as common sense reasoning and nuanced language understanding.
  - Vampiero 2y ago
    Oh, so they made an autistic LLM
    - Mistletoe 2y ago
      This made me laugh so much, thank you.

123yawaworht456 2y ago

ask any American LLM about the percentage of violent crimes perpetrated by a particular ethnic group in the US ;)

dyauspitr 2y ago
And it gives you the right answer. Just tried it with chatGPT and Gemini. You can shove your petty strawman.
- 123yawaworht456 2y ago
  share the chats then
  - msoad 2y ago
    no the OP but literally your comment as prompt https://chatgpt.com/share/6747c7d9-47e8-8007-a174-f977ef82f51c https://chatgpt.com/share/6747c7d9-47e8-8007-a174-f977ef82f5...
    - 123yawaworht456 2y ago
      huh. they've eased it up quite a bit since the last time I tried chatting it up about controversial topics.
      - chefandy 2y ago
        share the chats then
Sabinus 2y ago
I'm amazed you think American and Chinese censorship are in any way comparable. Communist governments have a long and storied history of controlling information so the people don't get exposed to any dangerous ideas.
- 2y ago

ziml77 2y ago

> Who is Xi Jinping? I'm sorry but I can't assist with that. > Who is the leader of China? As an AI language model, I cannot discuss topics related to politics, religion, sex, violence, and the like. If you have other related questions, feel free to ask. So it seems to have a very broad filter on what it will actually respond to.

titanomachy 2y ago
Well, yeah... it's from China. And you thought Google's PC self-censorship was bad.

pkkkzip 2y ago

Deepseek does this too but honestly I'm not really concerned (not that I dont care about Tianmen Square) as long as I can use it to get stuff done. Western LLMs also censor and some like Anthropic is extremely sensitive towards anything racial/political much more than ChatGPT and Gemini. The golden chalice is an uncensored LLM that can run locally but we simply do not have enough VRAM or a way to decentralize the data/inference that will remove the operator from legal liability.

jszymborski 2y ago
Ask Anthropic whether the USA has ever comitted war crimes, and it said "yes" and listed ten, including the My Lai Massacre in Vietname and Abu Graib. The political censorship is not remotely comparable.
- nemothekid 2y ago
  >The political censorship is not remotely comparable. Because our government isn't particularly concerned with covering up their war crimes. You don't need an LLM to see this information that is hosted on english language wikipedia. American political censorship is fought through culture wars and dubious claims of bias.
  - yazzku 2y ago
    And Hollywood.
    - astrange 2y ago
      That's Chinese censorship. Movies leave out or segregate gay relationships because China (and a few other countries) won't allow them.
  - jszymborski 2y ago
    > American political censorship is fought through culture wars and dubious claims of bias. What you are describing are social moires and norms. It is not related to political censorship by the government.