3 ms·
I'm surprised so much has been written on this topic. I'm probably naive in thinking this is overcomplicating things. If you don't control the url to your conte
by xnx 2y ago
I'm surprised so much has been written on this topic. I'm probably naive in thinking this is overcomplicating things. If you don't control the url to your content, you control nothing.
- high_priest 2y agoWkat does URL ownership have to do with control over content? DNS & HTTP hosting are just another services. Maybe a bit less vulnerable themselves, than some social media website. But still, even facebook does routing errors & internet archive gets hacked.
- whyrusleeping 2y agoI tend to agree with this, thats why theres canonical URIs for atproto posts that are agnostic to the hosting provider. The format is at://DID/collection/recordKey. These are used throughout the system, for example if you look at the output of a feed generator, its just a list of these URIs
- wmf 2y agoIn some ways that's worse because it means you can be blocked at the DID layer.
- wmf 2y agoControlling the URL makes a lot of sense if you're publishing HTML that a browser can directly render but ATProto/Bluesky doesn't really work that way. The underlying data is CBOR/JSON that needs to be interpreted by an AppView and client. So you need to control the URL of your data and also control the AppView and client.
- xnx 2y agoRight. There's probably an alternate reality where it's easy for anyone to own a domain and configure CNAME's for services they use like https://bluesky.yourname.com https://bluesky.yourname.com.
- zvr 2y agoBy this metric, you probably never have any control. Even the domain name you're using is not "yours"; you only rent it for a while and you may lose it.
- diggan 2y ago> If you don't control the url to your content, you control nothing. I think you're right in general, strictly and technically speaking. But with that mindset, we basically cannot have any control on the internet unless you own your own IPs and a ASN, but even that is "leased" or ultimately controlled by someone else, it can always be taken away from you, one way or another. So instead the discussion becomes about "degrees of control" if you will. Using Facebook to host whatever would be on the lower scale of "control", having your own website at some hosted service with possible exit would give you a bit more control and having your own domain pointing to a home server would give you even more control, and so on. Same goes for what "decentralized" really means, it's more of a range than a boolean of "yes/no decentralized". Rather than this black and white view of "You control nothing unless you control the URI", (ATProto at least) people are trying to figure out a balance between "You control everything" and "It's a huge hassle to manage everything yourself".