4 ms·
I suspect that the draw of LiveJournal is very similar to the initial draw of AIM, Y!IM or MSN. People tend to go where there friends are. I don't care how mu
by bmelton 18y ago
I suspect that the draw of LiveJournal is very similar to the initial draw of AIM, Y!IM or MSN. People tend to go where there friends are. I don't care how much better or more open Google Talk is, if all my friends are on AIM, it doesn't help me (hypothetically speaking since I can now use GTalk to talk on AIM.)
Another thing to consider is that LJ does do a decent job of aggregating 'friendfeeds' from other LJers (and has been doing this since well before Twitter or FriendFeed existed), so it's really easy to look, at a glance, at what my friends are up to, which isn't so easy from an out of the box Wordpress.
That said, as a long time user, I agree that LJ does suck, and has iterated at a snail-like pace, but it serves a purpose, and has some non-obvious features that make it better than some of its more flashy competitors.
- tptacek 18y agoAIM has a huge network effect. LiveJournal has a very weak network effect (as a minor blog reputation service).
- bmelton 18y agoWhile I agree with that statement in general, LiveJournal has a much stronger network effect than Wordpress does, in my experience. Of course, I've never used the wordpress hosted blogs, so I could be completely wrong, but at least with an out of the box wordpress installation, there's no immediate way to check in on your friends, or see who you're friends with, etc. LJ offers these services in a fairly straightforward fashion.
- tptacek 18y agoWordPress has no network effect, but it's a strong substitute for LJ's crappy publishing platform. Facebook and Twitter have huge network effects, and both link pretty well with WordPress. It's the combination of WordPress+Facebook+Twitter (all free) that seems like the better option.
- GHFigs 18y agoYou're thinking in terms of technology, not in terms of users. Also, when did Friendster wind down? It's still one of the most popular sites in the world.
- blasdel 18y agoLJ has by far the strongest network effect of any blogging service -- Twitter is the first thing to really compete with them on that, and is pretty close. LJ also had an enourmous first-mover advantage, but became stagnant after a while, and then were driven into the ground by SixApart. Instead of improving the service, SA made a tone-deaf clone (Vox), and began directly antagonizing their entire userbase.
- gaius 18y agoThere are a bunch of very obvious things that LJ could have done. For example, it does photo hosting, but there's no way to link a photo with users, like Facebook's tagging. It has a calendar and to-do lists, but has no event planning features (again like FB does). It definitely stagnated, and has definitely annoyed its users, but there's enormous inertia, since people want to be where their friends are. If a migration off happens, tho', for the same reason, it'll be brutally quick.
- thesethings 18y agoI'd compare Livejournal to Tumblr more than any other contemporary tool. They both recognize public/private on a per-post basis (other software makes you all in or all out w/public-ness).