3 ms·
This graph is of a single data source (tree rings) with no error bars. If the world isn't warming significantly, fantastic, but tree rings is a data source alr
by saalweachter 14y ago
This graph is of a single data source (tree rings) with no error bars.
If the world isn't warming significantly, fantastic, but tree rings is a data source already heavily incorporated into the climate models. Climate models don't just look at one data source -- thermometers, ice cores, tree rings -- they look at all data sources. It's quite possible a subset of the lines of evidence actually indicate cooling, but pulling them out and reporting on them separately isn't breaking the great climate change conspiracy, it's cherry-picking.
And regarding error bars, if you look at the classic hockey-stick graph[1], you'll notice the error bars (grey region) are so huge, especially for times prior to 1600, that the data could indicate a cooling trend. But the un-shown error bars on the tree-ring only graph are going to be even larger, because the tree-rings are a subset of the data going into the hockey stick graph. Not showing error bars on a graph like this is extremely deceptive.
All in all, I don't like the smell of this article. Cherry picking and omitting error bars smells like a hit.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Hockey_stick_chart_ipcc_large.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Hockey_stick_chart_ipcc_la...
- nirvana 14y agoWhat specific models are you talking about? Can you give me links with the lists of the sources of data, the adjustment factors applied, and also the predictive results of the model (forward in time, not backward)?[1] Regarding the chart you link to, it is at least 11 years old, and we don't know what factors were applied to it. It seems to confirm the claims of this article, showing a clear, slow, decline in temperatures up to the point where a different source of data is introduced. At the more resent end, what it could be showing is simply incorrect correction of the differences in results from the new sources of data. [1] Totally sincere question. I am always hearing about these "models" but have never gotten a link to a specific model with an explanation of these relevant issues.
- saalweachter 14y agoFor the sake of argument, let's just say the Mann, et al, 2008 models. [1] They include an updated version of the hockey stick graph. [2] But I'm not actually arguing that this specific model is correct or even that the IPCC's review of the state of the science is correct; I'm arguing that the article on the Register smells like a hit job. Let's just look at the differences between the Register's graph and the original article's graph. [3] First, they've bizarrely omitted the scale from the left-hand side of the graph. Maybe they were trying to save space, since the ticks are each one, but when your story is your graph you shouldn't skimp. The "Reconstruction" has been relabeled "Summer temperature". The "Trend" has been helpfully relabeled the "Cooling trend". The hundred year filtered reconstruction has been left completely unlabeled, despite its prominence in the graph, and as mentioned previously, the error bars have been left off entirely. This looks like an interesting line of evidence, and it may even point towards what the authors of the original article claim (some orbital forcing of climate). But this is only a single line of evidence, so far: Scandinavian tree rings collected and studied by a group of Scandinavian researchers. I would like to see followup studies, by other researchers looking at tree rings in other parts of the world -- and non-tree ring based temperature records! -- before people start jumping up and down declaring the IPCC to be lying liars who lie. A single line of evidence can be wrong; a single line of evidence can mean something different from what you think it means. Only many corroborative lines of evidence can build a scientific consensus. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2527990/?tool=pmcentrez http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2527990/?tool=pm... [2] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2527990/figure/F3/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2527990/figure/F... [3] http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/vaop/ncurrent/fig_tab/nclimate1589_F2.html http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/vaop/ncurrent/fig_tab...
- to3m 14y agoThis sort of article is Lewis Page's stock in trade. (Have a look at his article history to get an idea of the bees in his bonnet.) I wouldn't bother agreeing or disagreeing with it, if I were you, because there will be another one along next week.