5 ms·
Apple iMac M4 review: who is this for, exactly?
- ogou 2y agoPlaces that have a need for work stations, like offices and academic environments. Creative workers that have dedicated work areas and favor an uncluttered environment. It might not make as much sense for individual consumers, but I still see offices full of iMacs out in the world. Not every company wants to issue personal laptops for workers.
- Hamuko 2y agoBut the iMac is not a workstation. It's even less of a workstation that the Mac Mini, which is available with a faster processor, more RAM, bigger SSD and faster networking. It's basically the lower-tier Mac Mini that's permanently attached to a (relatively small) monitor that cannot be repurposed, and you'd probably be better off getting a separate monitor for a Mini to allow upgrading those separately.
- brianjking 2y agoThis. Especially true with the Mac Studio being available too.
- dagmx 2y agoBoth you and the person you’re replying to are thinking of workstations in the colloquial sense of “powerful computer to work on” instead of a literal station where someone works. For 90% of people , an iMac is less fuss than other devices. This thread reminds me of the Microsoft cloud 365 PC they just launched where everyone was confused by the market for it and really just cemented the fact that a lot of engineers aren’t very in touch with the actual workforce out there.
- stoobs 2y agoIt's not your definition of a workstation, but for many businesses/locations, it is. They're deployed by the hundreds, in one or two configurations, then are replaced after 3/5/7 years. They never get repurposed, they just get recycled/refurbished when they reach end of life or the value has been depreciated to zero.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 2y agoIt feels strange to say this though, because a setup where external monitors can be hooked up into laptops is a better UX for everyone involved for a typical workstation. The company can amortize and maintain the the display’s lifecycle separately from the machines, the employees get dynamic mobility and can take their laptop into meetings and home. About the only use case outside of the already-mentioned reception desk is the one where you don’t want employees taking their laptop home AND everyone is on a Mac which is… a kind of niche market. It’s not like companies want these for their computing power - there are other, more cost effective form factors and designs for that. I think the iMac is kind of a relic from a bygone age where it was more difficult to fit desktop computing power into a laptop form factor. Now that laptops have gotten pretty beefy, the difference in compute between them and something like this is small enough that it probably makes more sense to opt for the mobility most of the time.
- drbscl 2y agoImagine your job being a "tech reviewer" and not being able to fathom the clear (albeit comparatively small) market for a product like this
- LittleTimothy 2y agoSuch a silly framing for a review. The iMac is for someone who just wants a good simple desktop computer. Ah but what if you want customize? Don't. That's not what it's for. Sure, if you're a tech reviewer and you're all jazzed about HDR and mechanical keyboards then this product isn't for you. But then... your job as a tech reviewer is kind of to understand what different customers will want and "I just want a computer" I would say is literally the most obvious market. Who is this for? Someone who wants a computer. Ah, but take away the people who want multi-monitor, take away the people who want mechanical keyboards, a bigger fancy monitor, and what are you left with? Still basically everyone! And it's not like this is the only computer Apple makes. They have 1 basic hardware platform based on the M4, they give you the laptops for portability, the iMac as the basic desktop, the mini for if you want to do all the things that the iMac isn't configured for, and they have the Mac Pro to taunt professionals. It's an incredibly coherent product line up. No one is confused about which one they want. Oh and by the way, it works really well for Apple too, because they are literally just taking the guts from their other products and sticking it in the same design desktop they've had for years. Do you really think that'll be improved by redesigning it and therefore charging 50% extra due to all the bespoke costs?
- wqaatwt 2y ago> Still basically everyone! Desktop is pretty niche these days. Most of those people would buy a laptop and it’s likely that a significant proportion of people buying desktop have specific needs
- Spooky23 2y agoThat’s the genius of the iMac. It’s a MacBook with a nice screen. They deliver the form factor while simultaneously taking advantage of the massive economies of scale brought by their laptops. Because they ship so few models, Apples individual SKUs are typically #1 or #2 in a category despite smaller share. Dell sells 10x computers with 50x SKUs.
- stephencanon 2y ago
- walterbell 2y ago> TouchID is great, and it’s frustrating that Apple put it on the keyboard instead of the power button Or the trackpad. TouchID works well on iPad Air power button.
- propter_hoc 2y agoThe guy actually answers his own question quite effectively: > It really only makes sense if you’re buying a computer for a reception desk or lobby area That's the market. Reception desks.
- washadjeffmad 2y agoMy friend is buying one so his kids can Facetime with their grandparents. I asked him why not get a $500 Mac Mini and a webcam to save half the cost, and he said he thought his wife would like the color. Raccoon coats, I guess.
- fearmerchant 2y agoMy parents in their 70's.
- spicybbq 2y agoAre these for schools, or do most kids get laptops these days?
- dagmx 2y agoMost kids in affluent enough areas get iPads. Less affluent areas get Chromebooks.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago“a beautiful object and a good computer” This is a good summary of the pathos Apple aims for. Good enough computing. Unique form. Occasionally they nail both, not not often enough to say it’s even often.
- floren 2y agoethos, surely, not pathos
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI was thinking authority on taste but pathos works too.
- dagmx 2y agoThis feels like a critique that doesn’t understand people, and instead is trying to consider the product by itself. Who is it for? Well, why not see the actual places buying them. - Reception/lobby/greeting desks because they’re an aesthetic entry point. - families who don’t want to deal with a computer. That’s a lot of people who upgrade once in a blue moon, don’t want to deal with shopping for different components like a display/mouse/keyboard. Over the last decade, ever single friend I know has had their parents transition to an iPad or an iMac. For the last point, it’s not even that they’re technically illiterate. My dad records music in his retirement. My friends dad used to be a software engineer. They just don’t want to futz with stuff anymore.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- BugsBunny1991 2y agoIs there still no easy way to use it as a target display? I'd consider an iMac as my personal computing device, but I'd like to use the display to plug into my work Macbook.
- fragmede 2y agoit works as a monitor via airplay, which kinda counts, but we'll see how that ages in 10 years.
- j0057 2y ago16 GB is criminally under-specced.
- patchorang 2y agoI love that they have affilate links in the article for a product that "wasn’t built for this world".
- tosh 2y agoTo my surprise it’s actually not easy to get a Mac mini, keyboard, mouse and a comparable screen for the price of an iMac.
- ebiester 2y agoI started this and the "comparable screen" is the sticking point. Nobody makes screens in this resolution, and most people have decided even 4k is overkill for this size for reason. You're best going for 4k at 27 inches, I think, and that's $200 and you're under budget.
- jmpman 2y agoI wish they still had target display mode. Then I could connect my work laptop to a “home” iMac. Was a good setup when I could use my iMac as a gaming computer back in the x86 days.
- jdiff 2y agoAirPlay certainly isn't as snappy as a physical connection but it's not bad for just a secondary monitor with secondary materials on it.
- bookstore-romeo 2y agoWhile not as versatile as Target Display Mode, you can use AirPlay over a wired connection from Mac to Mac: https://www.macrumors.com/2021/06/09/airplay-mac-to-mac-external-display/ https://www.macrumors.com/2021/06/09/airplay-mac-to-mac-exte... Weird it's still called AirPlay, but at least it's possible. The video will be compressed, though unlike Target Display Mode
- scelerat 2y agoIt's clear to me both from the reviewer and some of the comments here on HN that some people don't understand that their bubble is a bubble inside of a bubble. most people I know who aren't technical would like a simple, no-nonsense computer.
- dartharva 2y agoI hope those people who only want a "simple, no-nonsense computer" don't get scammed out of $1700 for an iMac when they'd just as easily be satisfied with a computer that costs less than a fifth of that price.
- scelerat 2y agoSincere concern for others exposed to scams is always appreciated, but I think you're still not considering the variety of needs and tastes. It seems clear you are not the customer Apple has in mind for the iMac, but that doesn't mean those customers don't exist.
- fragmede 2y agoThat's not a scam any more than Ferraris and Lamborghinis and Louis Vuitton are. Which is to say, they might be priced high, but at the end of the day, the good being represented is exchanged for money. A scam would be misrepresenting a product aka lying and selling something that isn't as advertised. A scam is a 1 terabyte hard drive that only holds 128 gigabytes, a car that has no engine.
- jtmarl1n 2y agoLess than a 5th? So $340? You think that’s a good price point for someone who just wants a computer and no hassle with other hardware needs?
- dartharva 2y agoYes? Most mini-PCs are between the $100-$200 price range, and there are plenty of functional AiOs below $350 too.
- dartharva 2y agoI remember reading a comment on HN about text rendering being bad in MacOS on external monitors because of a lack of anti-aliasing, so perhaps the new iMac is a better-working alternative to the Mac mini because of the first-party ultra-Hi-DPI screen that comes with it?
- amai 2y agoTry to find an external monitor with the same high quality inbuilt webcam, microphone, speakers and USB hub. I'm waiting...
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoThe iMac webcam has always been quite meh. So is the microphone. Speakers are good for inbuilt speakers which is to say they are average.
- amai 2y agoBut show me an external monitor which has all this inbuilt. Even if it just has average quality. There is nothing on the market. Once there existed a Dell video conferencing monitor. But the quality of webcam, microphone speakers and even USB hub of this monitor was just terrible, much worse than Apple. It seems like everyone likes a lot of cables around her/his monitor and a shaky webcam on top.
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoI quite like having proper sound and a good webcam which sometimes is my phone connected to my computer, yes. Cables are not an issue because I can properly run them being the huge monitor in front of me. Plus I can undock my laptop from the setup when I’m done and you know, carry it with me somewhere else. I can’t believe some people are arguing in good faith here than the iMac is an improvement on this. I find it funny because I thought Apple fanboys somehow died but apparently no.
- amai 2y agoI would be happy to buy an external monitor not from Apple with a good webcam, microphone, speakers and USB-Hub inbuilt. Unfortunately they don't exist.