7 ms·
Wildlife monitoring technologies used to intimidate and spy on women
- thaumasiotes 2y agoPerhaps there's an inherent conflict between using the forest as a source of resources for the nearby village, and using it as a storage space for tigers.
- pvaldes 2y agoIs a national park. Of course that it should have endangered animals taking refuge there. To protect valuable and unique ecosystems is the main purpose of those areas. If this seems stressing, maybe we need to remind that on Africa the directors of some national parks need constant protection from the army to avoid being assassinated by poachers. In some places intruders found on protected sanctuaries are not recorded with drones, after many rangers killed, they are directly shoot until they quit the area.
- notRobot 2y agoThe forest is for all to use and not exploit
- nine_k 2y agoThat same forest without the cameras didn't exhibit that particular kind of conflict. I suppose the problem is in behavior of particular humans here, not of tigers, the forest, or even the cameras.
- dghlsakjg 2y ago> Nobody could have realised that camera traps put in the Indian forest to monitor mammals actually have a profoundly negative impact on the mental health of local women who use these spaces. Most women could have predicted that spycams in a park, run by a government in a country with known issues around women’s rights, would lead to issues. Even governments with incredibly strict rules and indelible audit trails struggle with men in government using their access to data to stalk women. India is not a country known for these things.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoHere in NY, we had a [very short-term] governor, who used to be the Attorney General, get hoist by his own petard. While AG, he put in place, a monitoring regimen, that caught him, as Guv, using state funds to buy hookers and whatnot. For all I know, he might have gotten away with it, if he hadn’t been using state funds. It kinda ripped the lid off a bunch of fairly misogynistic attitudes, though. He didn’t last long, after that.
- yieldcrv 2y agoConsuming sex work isn’t misogynistic, by definition as it doesnt involve contempt or hate of women, sex workers have a voice too and don’t want to be marginalized by that assumption or dilution of that word Just a view I see lacking and underrepresented in tech spaces But if there are other things you’re referring to with that governor then definitely mention those, separately
- automatic6131 2y ago>Consuming sex work isn’t misogynistic Something very much up for debate amongst leading scholars. I - personally - think buying sex is bad, and degrading to both parties.
- ChoHag 2y ago[dead]
- Cumpiler69 2y ago>Something very much up for debate amongst leading scholars Who are those "leading scholars" and what gives them authority to be the judge what consenting adults do with their body for a living or for entertainment?
- mensetmanusman 2y agoWhat gives anyone authority either way to say whether something is degrading? It comes down to consensus in practice.
- keithnz 2y agoanother article with some other details https://www.enca.com/opinion/wildlife-monitoring-tech-used-harass-spy-women-india https://www.enca.com/opinion/wildlife-monitoring-tech-used-h... seems like they developed a set of principles a while back https://wildlabs.net/sites/default/files/principles_for_the_socially_responsible_use_of_conservation_monitoring_technologies.pdf https://wildlabs.net/sites/default/files/principles_for_the_... But my guess is without strict enforcement of the rules with consequences this will carry on.
- gnabgib 2y agoThat article references this University of Cambridge study.
- nomilk 2y agoSeems a lot of modern tech is (ab)used for the purpose of perving. I recently visited a gym which seemed very social media oriented (not dissimilar to most gyms tbh), but as days went by I gathered the impression something weird was going on. I ended up suspecting (but having absolutely no evidence) that the owner or staff was using the cameras to spy on members. Further oddities exist in the reviews for the place, which includes staff walking into the change rooms (of the opposite sex) with naked people there. That's a really long/specific way of saying: wildlife cameras spying on Indian women is an instance of a more general problem. I feel like plausible deniability (e.g. security/monitoring) is so easy that discovering and alleging wrong-doing would be met with little more than shrugging of shoulders.
- fsckboy 2y ago>I feel like plausible deniability...is so easy that discovering and alleging wrong-doing would be met with little more than shrugging of shoulders. it was not met with shrugs FTA: Young men appointed as temporary forest workers shared the photo on local Whatsapp and Facebook groups to "shame the woman," Simlai said. "We broke and set fire to every camera trap we could find after the daughter of our village was humiliated in such a brazen way," one local told the researchers.
- nomilk 2y ago> it was not met with shrugs That's good news in this instance but not in the case of cameras in gyms and many other cases, unfortunately.
- averageRoyalty 2y agoWhat solution do you propose for private businesses? Having cameras is sensible, if not a must. People are abusive, burglars break in, staff steal, etc.
- casey2 2y agoYou clearly didn't read the associated paper. Employees stealing from a business is a far better outcome than letting people with power abuse it. Worst case in the former: A business fails. Bad case in the later: The business succeeds and perpetuates it's abusive practices Worst case in the later: mass genocide and the total extinction of the human race.
- yieldcrv 2y ago[flagged]
- hackernewds 2y agothey are not just escaping from the men at home. they're actively having illicit affairs away from their men at home, in the privacy of the forest..
- fsckboy 2y agothey should put the women in charge of the cameras and wildlife monitoring
- pvaldes 2y agoYeah, men should be punished for being men, even if 99% of the men are perfectly capable to behave decently. Benevolent sexism is still sexism.
- fsckboy 2y agoit's not benevolent sexism, it's healthy sexism itself that is benevolent; androgyny is malevolent. These men should assume their proper role by confronting these tigers directly, while they protect their wives and sisters by giving them the safer job monitoring the cameras. there is plenty of work to be done, people need to take responsibility
- bilbo0s 2y agoNot as simple as that. Sadly, in addition to men, there are also a lot of women, who abuse women. (And even children.)
- akudha 2y agoYes, but it is likely to be a bit better with women in charge than men. But yeah, there isn’t any easy solution to this
- bigbacaloa 2y ago[dead]
- RobotToaster 2y ago> they feel watched and inhibited by camera traps, so talk and sing much more quietly. Why would you stop singing loudly because of cameras? Even if their singing is bad, they're just inflicting it on someone who they don't like?
- casey2 2y agoPeople won't seriously discuss this because they implicitly regard women as unthinking animals that can't change their behavior through reasoned discussion. If something makes women act in a certain way that is harmful to themselves then that something should be destroyed, be it cameras or men. And men are just violent and controlling enough to act on this impulse whenever it appears, Hence the violent display of destroying cameras on sight and becoming the savior of women from themselves and the lowly men who seek to take advantage of them. It's a fun narrative, but it's quickly becoming boring and antiquated as the years draw on.
- blitzar 2y agoIf only people would not sing and dance when the tiktok camera is on.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoUnfortunately I think that access to all kind of IP cameras is too easy. Normal people mostly don't care to install, don't bother to deal with setting up the recording infrastructure. Creeps, psychos, delusional people go wild with them, including pointing camera at neighbour doors, windows, garages in residential areas. Yes, you can tell them to turn the camera away but they are delusional so discussion rarely makes sense. Some people draw this sick perverted satisfaction in recording their neighbour and sometimes only violence works as an argument.
- pvaldes 2y agoThis excuse has been also used in Swedden to forbid trail cameras in public areas unless the government emit a permit. People has been sued because a woman toke a dump in front of the camera. Is unclear to me if this was deliberated or not. Is a "think on the children", but with women. The fact is that people in public areas can and should expect to be filmed or appear in the background of a selfie. First because is legal, and second because is unavoidable. Without the current "male panic", women shouldn't have a problem with appearing in the background of a low quality photo (that in most cases will show a blurred face). Men don't care about it either, and people don't wander around naked in forests typically. Cameras can have benefits for women also. Will detect presence of wild animals in the area that could be dangerous to women; or criminal activity, like poachers, arsonists or violators. I assume that this is the real problem with the presence of cameras here. That poachers are being filmed They aren't neither bad or good. Is just a tool. The huge majority of zoologists are normal responsible people that would delete any photo with sensitive personal information and never would filter it to internet. The fix is to put banners on the area, but then the cameras will be stolen. Or we could also stop to study nature and let everything go to hell.
- em-bee 2y agoThe fact is that people in public areas can and should expect to be filmed in germany i can expect the opposite because surveillance cameras in public spaces are illegal. this is not a "think of the women" argument, but "think of the people".
- x3ro 2y agoTo be very clear, this only applies to private individuals setting up cameras. The government is very much able to surveil the population to its hearts content [1] (link German). There are plenty of "security" cameras around Berlin, at least. [1]: https://www.bundestag.de/resource/blob/507980/bf8a67c2440522ac5a1ed22dd7164e66/wd-3-045-17-pdf-data.pdf https://www.bundestag.de/resource/blob/507980/bf8a67c2440522...
- pvaldes 2y agoIn most countries, people can legally spend all morning taking photos in a park if they want. But the real problem in this particular case can be spotted from a mile. Crime against nature was so rampant, that the India government must spend money and use cameras, drones and anything to stop it in the protected area. This is really "think of the criminals". The alleged psychological damage done to women because a natural protected area is being surveilled, is clearly an excuse from poachers, unable now to continue their previous activity freely. I will not try to pretend that I know the role of women on Indian culture and how much fragile mentally they are, but I assume that people can understand that scientific work is necessary; and that behind each camera there is not necessarily a rapist (Cambridge has also women doing science also). If this women are so stressed, the most probable reason is that they are poachers also. Either you protect it, or you lose it. My sympathy for the "victims" of protecting nature is low and decreasing.
- _giorgio_ 2y agoI suppose that this is not the right thread to ask about what devices would you use outdoor, but I'll try anyway... Requisites: - battery operated - IP protection - fast shutter (example: moving objects) - wifi? - night mode not important (using it in optimal conditions) Thanks
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nonrandomstring 2y agoFly tipping is a reason that some UK councils hide cameras in woodlands [0]. That's what we semi-confirmed (the council "declined to deny it" in a coded response) in this episode "It is not closed, it is not a circuit, and it is not even television!" For US readers "fly tipping" is illegal dumping of household waste, not giving money to insects. [0] https://cybershow.uk/episodes.php?id=26 https://cybershow.uk/episodes.php?id=26
- mrweasel 2y agoAt this point, this shouldn't really be a massive surprise to anyone. The surprising part comes from the continued inability to predict these scenarios with anything less than 100% accuracy. Does it have a camera, microphone, GPS, lidar or any type of wireless communication, if yes it can and it will be used to monitor, oppress and intimidate.
- JadeNB 2y ago> The surprising part comes from the continued inability to predict these scenarios with anything less than 100% accuracy. I don't think Hanlon's razor applies here. If there's no penalty to the people who establish a system for its foreseeable abuses, then their not foreseeing those abuses isn't inability, it's strategy.