3 ms·

This seems to be the study (gated): https://psycnet.apa.org/buy/2025-40514-001 https://psycnet.apa.org/buy/2025-40514-001 Can somebody see if they asked the sa

This seems to be the study (gated): https://psycnet.apa.org/buy/2025-40514-001 https://psycnet.apa.org/buy/2025-40514-001 Can somebody see if they asked the same students (between 9 and 14, an age range where behavior changes quite a bit)? > The goal of the current work was to understand how the COVID-19 pandemic school shutdowns may have impacted classroom incivility in children and adolescents. > Study 1 compared prepandemic (Fall 2019) to postpandemic school shutdown (Fall 2022) rates of classroom incivility in a sample of 308 adolescents (49.7% boys; 61.0% White) between the ages of 9 and 14 (M = 12.06; SD = 1.38). Classroom incivility was significantly higher postpandemic shutdowns, while bullying, emotional problems, and friendships remained stable. > In Study 2, we surveyed 101 primary educators (95% females; 88.1% White). Findings suggested that young students lacked social skills and knowledge of classroom expectations, contributing to increased classroom incivility. Our results highlight the need to monitor ongoing levels of classroom incivility.

kelseyfrog 2y ago
To me it reads as if this is unpaired data. Though sampling the elementary schools with at 83% participation rate and the destination high school at an 87% participation rate is sure to cover a LOT of the same students. > Adolescents in Grades 5–9 at Time 1 and 8–12 at Time 2 completed both self-report and peer nomination questionnaires as part of the larger study. Research assistants visited classrooms to assist in data collection, and all questionnaires were completed on electronic tablets via the online platform Qualtrics. Active parental consent and adolescent assent were required for elementary students (Grades 5–8) while passive consent was used for high school students. In the first wave (November 2019; Grades 5–9), the overall returned consent form rate was 83.78% (including 77.15% positive consent). Students also provided assent to participate; no students who had parental consent chose not to participate. For Wave 2 (November 2022), consent was only collected for the Grade 8s (86.6% returned), and for Grades 9–12, the consent rate was 98% with a participation rate of 87%. > All measures and procedures received ethical clearance from both the university and school board research ethics boards. I should also point out that this is from five Ontario schools. Any statements about the behavior of students in other regions would be an extrapolation.
- ano-ther 2y ago
  Thanks. (I don’t have access to the full text). So not the exact same population, but still a comparison of “adolescents in grade 5-9 at time 1 and grade 8-12 at time 2”? That would compare a pre-puberty to a puberty population, with the unsurprising result of them being less compliant. But again, I don’t have access to the full text.
  - kelseyfrog 2y ago
    The authors specifically said that the elementary schools sampled at Time 1 fed into the high school at Time 2, but they didn't say that the data was paired ie: the set of students sampled at Time 1 = the set of students sampled at Time 2. The response rate is so high that there is likely considerable overlap tho.

kelseyfrog 2y ago

To me it reads as if this is unpaired data. Though sampling the elementary schools with at 83% participation rate and the destination high school at an 87% participation rate is sure to cover a LOT of the same students. > Adolescents in Grades 5–9 at Time 1 and 8–12 at Time 2 completed both self-report and peer nomination questionnaires as part of the larger study. Research assistants visited classrooms to assist in data collection, and all questionnaires were completed on electronic tablets via the online platform Qualtrics. Active parental consent and adolescent assent were required for elementary students (Grades 5–8) while passive consent was used for high school students. In the first wave (November 2019; Grades 5–9), the overall returned consent form rate was 83.78% (including 77.15% positive consent). Students also provided assent to participate; no students who had parental consent chose not to participate. For Wave 2 (November 2022), consent was only collected for the Grade 8s (86.6% returned), and for Grades 9–12, the consent rate was 98% with a participation rate of 87%. > All measures and procedures received ethical clearance from both the university and school board research ethics boards. I should also point out that this is from five Ontario schools. Any statements about the behavior of students in other regions would be an extrapolation.

ano-ther 2y ago
Thanks. (I don’t have access to the full text). So not the exact same population, but still a comparison of “adolescents in grade 5-9 at time 1 and grade 8-12 at time 2”? That would compare a pre-puberty to a puberty population, with the unsurprising result of them being less compliant. But again, I don’t have access to the full text.
- kelseyfrog 2y ago
  The authors specifically said that the elementary schools sampled at Time 1 fed into the high school at Time 2, but they didn't say that the data was paired ie: the set of students sampled at Time 1 = the set of students sampled at Time 2. The response rate is so high that there is likely considerable overlap tho.