6 ms·
Many cultures never invent writing. From well-known 1969 research on 186 pre-industrial societies: [0] * 39.2%: No writing * 37.1%: Pictures only * 23.7%
by mmooss 2y ago
Many cultures never invent writing. From well-known 1969 research on 186 pre-industrial societies: [0]
* 39.2%: No writing
* 37.1%: Pictures only
* 23.7%: Writing
Also of interest (but also a bit dated): "... the making and reading of two dimensional maps is almost universal among mankind whereas the reading and writing of linear scripts is a special accomplishment associated with a high level of social and technical sophistication." [1]
> I think we just haven’t found any of it that survived.
It's an interesting question, but do I think that? That's the thing about science - we need evidence. Otherwise, what we think turns out to be especially unreliable.
[0] George P. Murdock, D.R. White. Standard Cross-Cultural Sample (SCCS). Ethnology (1969)
[1] Edmund Leach. Culture and Communication. Cambridge U. Press (1976)
- mistercheph 2y ago[flagged]
- mmooss 2y agoThere's an old quote among lawyers: If you have the facts on your side, hammer on the facts. If you have the law, hammer on the law. If you have neither, hammer on the table. If I understand you correctly: You have no claim of your own or argument for it, so you are using what you do know, insults.
- mistercheph 2y agoThe claims you are making (unsupported by evidence) are the only thing that's insulting, And with fitting aphorisms exchanged, we can part ways Mr. 40%-of-human-societies-don't-write-according-to-an-unreproduced-survey-performed-in-1969-that-is-not-a-survey-of-human-societies-but-our-own-knowledge-of-human-societies-and-is-confused-about-cultural-boundaries-and-how-to-count-one-society-or-many.
- cogman10 2y agoIn fact, there are used languages today that are not written! I have family that just returned from a 2 year religious mission in pohnpei. The native language there is just barely starting to be written. One of the challenges to learning it is because of it's mostly unwritten nature, the language evolves rapidly. That fast evolution is part of what makes turning the language into a written language difficult.
- simmerup 2y agoThis reminded me of how cyrillic was invented. The Byzantines created the cyrillic alphabet in the 9th century so that they could write a bible for Slavic countries. Blew my mind that they didn’t have an alphabet before that.
- unscaled 2y agoHow is that different from the thousands of different languages that did not have alphabet until recently but then got one created by linguists or missionaries (or often someone who is a little bit of both[1])? Cyril and Methodius (who created the Glagolithic Alphabet, not the Cyrillic alphabet) weren't even the first Chritian missionaries who created a new alphabet for a language that didn't have on in order to spread Christianity. I believe the first one was Armenian (in the early 5th century). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIL_International https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIL_International
- simmerup 2y agoDoes it have to be different?
- ACS_Solver 2y agoIt similarly blows my mind how far back many languages go with written accounts. My own native language wasn't written down until the 16th century, so its earlier forms are basically unattested. And the 16th writing is just a few sentences in official records and translations of certain Christian prayers. It took until the late 17th century to have a translated Bible, and for the first non-religious texts to appear. Meanwhile some other languages spoken next door had centuries old literature by then.