5 ms·
'Thirsty' ChatGPT uses four times more water than previously thought
- volent 2y ago> Many data centres use water-based systems to cool the plant with towers evaporating the heat, like a huge perspiration system, which means that the water is lost. Someone doesn't know what "evaporation" or "lost" means.
- MrMcCall 2y agoSomeone doesn't believe in global heating.
- grues-dinner 2y agoTotal datacenter energy use is on the order of 1PWh/yr. Total global solar surface irradiance is on the order of 400,000PWh/yr. The direct heat contribution is negligible to global temperature. There is an argument that water vapour in the atmosphere is a greenhouse gas, but also an argument that clouds reflect solar energy, and that this water vapour is emitted at ground level. I don't think it's so obvious that water evaporation from datacenter cooling systems is directly either good or bad for global heating. There certainly are negative environmental and social effects of this water usage in some places and implementations, and certainly it could include severe heating potential, but this is an over-reduction without further context.
- ttyprintk 2y agoYou can simultaneously believe that the energy demand for cooling is unethical and that evaporation is the best source of cooling.
- lambdaba 2y agoOne avocado takes 320 liters, I'd rather give up on avocado than Claude.
- robertlagrant 2y agoSurely not! I could drown a whole load of avocados in 320l of water, couldn't I?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ttyprintk 2y agoIn California, you could replace all your lawn with avocado trees. Might only double your water bill.
- rzzzt 2y agoHow about T-shirts? Websites, ads and "fun fact" news articles tell me it takes on the order of 10000 liters for each item... which seems to be a bit high but I don't have the means to verify the number.
- globular-toast 2y agoMost people eat avocados not for their nutrition but because they are delicious. I would definitely suggest not buying and eating them if you don't find them delicious! There are much cheaper options. Does Claude offer much beyond its utility as a tool? I mean, it's ok to like tools too. But I'm not sure I'd want to pay an ongoing cost for a tool just because I enjoy using it. It has to deliver utility too. And if it does then you shouldn't have to give up avocados, in fact you should be able to buy more! If/when we to the Her level of AI then things will be interesting...
- jiggawatts 2y agoThe water doesn’t disappear. Most data centres use water in their chiller units, as do many large industrial facilities. ChatGPT is a minority of the energy, heat, and cooling budget of Azure, which is a minority of the world’s data centre footprint. ChatGPT is useful. This article is not.
- AstralStorm 2y agoFurther, it could run on air cooling, just the water or other liquid medium is easier to handle in scale.
- fnordpiglet 2y agoWater has better energy transfer characteristics than air, especially during phase changes like evaporation and condensation. So it’s less about scale per se unless you mean scale of energy transfer per unit of time.
- yallpendantools 2y agoTFA: > Many data centres use water-based systems to cool the plant with towers evaporating the heat, like a huge perspiration system, which means that the water is lost. > All of these companies have schemes to put water back into nature using projects that help river flow, capture rainwater, recharge aquifers and modify dams. They have all pledged to become “water positive” by 2030: returning more than they consume. > But where are they putting back the water? Quite often it’s not in the same place it was taken out, which can be in areas of “water stress”. It's not about whether or not the water is gone for good after cooling. It's about allocation of resources. The water cooling ChatGPT servers right now is water not delivered to households or the larger ecosystem. Data centers are, in effect, in competition with the rest of us for who gets to use the water right now. >> ChatGPT is useful. This article is not. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html please: > Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.
- 2y ago
- comboy 2y agoNot sure if that' more than a person sitting in the office writing this when you take into account all electricity used by the building, maintenance, other people (catering cleaning etc.) And I think this energy-shaming whether that's AI crypto or something else is just a wrong approach. If somebody buys energy he can use it for mindless entertainment if he so pleases, why focus on datacenters and not Disneyland?
- lambdaba 2y agoClaude estimates the average American consumes about 3800 liters of water per day counting all the food inputs (Claude only drank half a cup for this answer).
- MrMcCall 2y agoAll that to get some percent hallucination, whose logic can't be traced? It's just another tech dead-end that leaves us all the worse, and the haves having more. It's just more waste on the level of bitcoin. It's the nature of selfishness: shortsighted with no global benefit, only global waste. Compassion for the Earth, herself, dictates we forge a different path, where folks like Google, Facebook, and elmo are not deciding our collective fate.
- p2detar 2y agoFrom the article: > Using the chatbot for between ten to 50 queries consumes about two litres of water, according to experts from the University of California, Riverside. From ChatGPT: > A single BTC transaction consumes approximately 1,000–1,500 kWh of electricity, with cooling processes for fossil fuel and nuclear power plants using about 2–3 liters of water per kWh. This translates to an indirect water consumption of around 2,500–3,750 liters (660–990 gallons) per transaction, depending on the energy mix. If accurate, I still prefer ChatGPT.
- shakow 2y agoHow is it a “consumption” (in either case) if the water is basically just running through a pipe and released a couple miles down the line/evaporated into the atmosphere without being polluted?
- MrMcCall 2y agoWe're having a global heating problem, so the water use is just a symptom of our systemic abuse of the planet's resources.
- ttyprintk 2y agoIt’s irresponsibly common for journalists to use the term for once-through cooling. But evaporative cooling consumes water just like the human body.
- MrMcCall 2y agoHere's the reality: just because a lot of people are doing something, it doesn't mean thay're not sunk-cost fools.
- i_cannot_hack 2y ago> If accurate, I still prefer ChatGPT. It looks like you are using ChatGPT too much and feeding yourself untrustworthy information for no reason. Internet search still exists, there is no need to use ChatGPT for this. Simply typing "how much water per btc transaction" into Google will give you this top response much faster than ChatGPT would: > Buying or selling bitcoin uses 16,000 litres of clean water for every single transaction. This is reported by New Scientist, who's reporting is based on actual calculations (using real data) from a PHD candidate at the Amsterdam School of Business and Economics. Whereas the number given by ChatGTP is based on nothing but the statistical probability of what would sound correct in this context, and has no guarantee of accuracy at all. In this case it was off by an order of magnitude compared to the number based on real data. The internet search probably used a lot less water as well (beside being both faster and more trustworthy).
- YetAnotherNick 2y agoUsed water doesn't go to waste water treatment plan.
- Klaster_1 2y agoMore data-center demand means more energy and water demand. Can this in turn incentivize in-situ water reclamation/desalination and energy generation (solar, nuclear), driving down prices for both? Maybe one day, data centers will crystalize cities around them - like mono-cities of USSR, but way more robust. You can even think of these as oasis of some sort!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- grues-dinner 2y ago> data centers will crystalize cities around them Most datacenter run on pretty small staff sizes. Every time they announce "new datacenter to bring 4000 jobs", a large proportion of those are in the construction, with only a small fraction being operational staff. Globally (roughly), there are around 2 million datacenter staff, and 8000 datacenters. 250 people in a huge physical site isn't a good start for a city.
- jl6 2y ago1. ChatGPT is in the title purely for click-related reasons. This is about data center water usage, and applies to any application that uses a data center. 2. Seems like water should be more expensive in water-stressed areas and that data centers should pay a rate that includes the cost of the externality. Is it, and do they?
- ttyprintk 2y ago1. Yeah, let’s talk Microsoft Teams instead. I suspect that’s worse than AI training… 2. The article I’d write starts with incumbent uses of water. Residential use, especially in dry areas, has been pressured to progressively increase efficiency. It does take energy to treat and pump and treat water again. But some people always wonder if they’re saving water just so another part of town can add residents or sell water to a new data center that runs Microsoft Teams. Evaporative cooling shouldn’t pay the (embedded) full price of treating sewage. For example, in California, that’s charged at a fraction. But it still covers the cost of treatment, the administration of water rights, and pumping. And that’s enough for corporations to choose to put AI training in other places.
- grues-dinner 2y ago> talk Microsoft Teams instead. I suspect that’s worse than AI training… If we assume that 25% of daily compute of 200 million people is spent on Electron and similar bloated software, and they're all using 50W computers (splitting the difference between laptops and desktops), that's about 7TWh per year: the annual electricity usage of Mongolia, or roughly 1% of Japan. Which is actually less than I had thought, but it also doesn't include the server-side resources.
- aszantu 2y agoIf you build the datacenter by the sea or floating, you could combine the cooling with desalination
- MrMcCall 2y ago"If my aunt had a d_ck, she'd be my uncle." --Louisiana saying I like your idea, but there's no patience or monetary motivation to postpone the energy use until more sane facilities are built.
- tim333 2y agoStill in principle in places like say the arab states where you could stick a lot of solar in the desert, and there's a need for desalination it could work in principle. Though I think they still tend to use oil.
- aszantu 2y agoI also think there was an article on how it's possible to produce energy with sea water. Sailors got electrocuted because of iron nails in the wood and copper castings against mussels
- 123yawaworht456 2y agoapparently, when water is used for purposes that annoying people dislike for ideological reasons, it disappears into another dimension, lost forever.
- ttyprintk 2y agoYeah, but a group of people like golf courses more than a larger group of people like artichokes. We have a civilized arrangement of sharing that doesn’t make those groups fight in a cage. But in places where this matters, golf courses will always come up before your point.
- maxglute 2y agoUsing 40ml of water to ask chatgpt how many grains of rice 40ml of water would grow, and the answer is ~1.