8 ms·
NASA: Mystery of Life's Handedness Deepens
- ngneer 2y agoCan someone please explain the big mystery in simple terms? The article sure doesn't. Why does RNA being ambi-valent deepen the mystery? As others have noted, it could have been a toss up early on that persisted. If a coin comes up heads, no one is looking to explain why the coin "favors" heads or is "predisposed" to come out heads. Neither is true. The coin just came up heads. Is the mystery why homochirality persisted?
- ngneer 2y agoThis can easily be solved by calling left right and right left. Voila. Mystery solved :).
- robthebrew 2y agohttps://www.nature.com/articles/s41377-020-00367-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41377-020-00367-8
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoThat's a relevant paper, but this is the one which "deepened" the mystery: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-52362-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-52362-x It asserts: > L-proteins need not emerge from a D-RNA World So if more than one amino acid chirality could have emerged, why did we get the one we got and not several? From the paper in the parent comment: > Achiral linearly polarized light interacts with chiral objects and their enantiomers differently. An interesting example is a light-driven motor. Linearly polarized light can rotate a gammadion-shaped gold structure embedded in a silica block as a motor. Imagine you were using some kind of optical tweezers to manipulate chiral molecules. I wonder if there's a reason that such a device would work better if you had a sample which had the same chirality. Suppose so... If one of your samples made its way to Earth and replicated... Well that would be a reason for earth proteins to be biased in one direction, despite the laws of physics not prescribing such a bias.
- madaxe_again 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_tweezers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_tweezers I suppose there’s no reason you couldn’t use circularly polarised light to achieve the effect you’re talking about.
- throwawaymaths 2y agoWhat is the mystery? Perhaps one handedness was just first by chance and won because it self replicated the other handedness away by consuming it as food.
- griffzhowl 2y agoWell, that's the question isn't it? Is it just a frozen accident, or is there some nonarbitrary reason for the left-handed molecules to be favoured?
- madaxe_again 2y agoPerhaps aliens eat right handed life, but left handed life is poison to them. Seriously. It would be a pretty good selector, and said “alien” need be no more than a snippet of RNA - and it would be entirely gone from earth now, eliminated by us sinister life forms. The only evidence would be the ubiquitous absence of R-entantiomers in life. I think I might be lifting from Asimov - The Left Hand of the Electron.
- Terr_ 2y agoThat kinda kicks the can down the road though, because we are faced with almost the same set of questions except about the hypothetical alien life.
- throwawaymaths 2y agoSure but that might be an unknowable problem. What if the difference in likelihood were 60/40. You could go down all sorts of rabbit holes and none of them would truly be falsifiable unless you observed an enantiomeric lifeform on some distant planet.
- throwawaymaths 2y ago(Comsuming enantiomers and pooping out metabolic fragments in its native chirality)
- alganet 2y ago
- andrewflnr 2y agoWhile all right-handed amino acids would presumably be fine, do we have any idea whether mixed chirality would work? I suspect no, since they presumably have different folding behavior but might be tricky to distinguish chemically during the protein synthesis process, making e.g. different codons for left and right-handed amino acids infeasible to implement. I'd love to hear from a biologist whether any of that is correct.
- fredgrott 2y agofun fact some left handed amino acids are poisonous to most mammals
- gilleain 2y agoSo a couple of things i remember from back in the old structural bioinformatics days... Firstly, there are naturally occurring mixed-chirality (alternating) peptides. They are usually circular iirc. Secondly, no you can't really have larger proteins with both left and right (ignoring glycine). They would not fold into nice helix/sheet strucures and likely just be random coil. For cells to have mixed populations of all-L and all-R proteins would mean doubling up all the machinery for creating them. One theory that I thought was reasonable for why there's a monochiral world is that once the arbitrary choice is made (L or R) then that gets 'locked in' by all the machinery around that choice. As in, L 'won'.
- phkahler 2y ago>> One theory that I thought was reasonable for why there's a monochiral world is that once the arbitrary choice is made (L or R) then that gets 'locked in' by all the machinery around that choice. As in, L 'won'. This seems obviously true to me. Mixed doesn't work, so as molecules and systems of molecules started replicating one chirality won out. It's just chance and there's nothing magical about the chirality "chosen" by the process.
- brnaftr361 2y agoMy initial hypothesis is that there's something present in the early stages of life that has a higher energy state making it unsustainable for use in a certain conformation and so it was nearly immediately selected out. E.g. a ring structure whose substituents are affected by steric hindrance in the left-handed scheme. And the path of least resistance was just to adapt and build around it. Once that precedence was set everything became as such. I expect in the earliest stages of life this would have been an immense factor as metabolism was not nearly as sophisticated as we know it today. And this selective process may have ocurred well before anything we have observed/modeled, and may well be erased. Which is to say I agree, but with the caveat that it was a substrate-dependent mechanism which selected the downstream components rather than random chance.
- westurner 2y agoFrom "Amplification of electromagnetic fields by a rotating body" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41873531 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41873531 : > ScholarlyArticle: "Amplification of electromagnetic fields by a rotating body" (2024) https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-49689-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-49689-w >> Could this be used as an engine of some kind? > What about helical polarization? If there is locomotion due to a dynamic between handed molecules and, say, helically polarized fields; is such handedness a survival selector for life in deep space? Are chiral molecules more likely to land on earth? > "Chiral Colloidal Molecules And Observation of The Propeller Effect" https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3856768/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3856768/ > Sugar molecules are asymmetrical / handed, per 3blue1brown and Steve Mould. /? https://www.google.com/search?q=Sugar+molecules+are+asymmetrical https://www.google.com/search?q=Sugar+molecules+are+asymmetr... https://www.google.com/search?q=Sugar+molecules+are+asymmetrical+%2F+handed%2C+per+3blue1brown+and+Steve+Mould https://www.google.com/search?q=Sugar+molecules+are+asymmetr... > Is there a way to get to get the molecular propeller effect and thereby molecular locomotion, with molecules that contain sugar and a rotating field or a rotating molecule within a field?
- westurner 2y agoThough, a new and plausible terrestrial origin of life hypothesis: Methane + Gamma radiation => Guanine && Earth thunderstorms => Gamma Radiation https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42131762#42157208 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42131762#42157208 : > A terrestrial life origin hypothesis: gamma radiation mutated methane (CH4) into Glycine (the G in ACGT) and then DNA and RNA.
- nativeit 2y ago> “We are analyzing OSIRIS-REx samples for the chirality (handedness) of individual amino acids, and in the future, samples from Mars will also be tested in laboratories for evidence of life including ribozymes and proteins,” said Dworkin. I clicked the hyperlink for OSIRIS-REx samples, and it didn’t contain any information about what kinds of materials were found, but this statement suggests amino acids were collected from OSIRIS-REx—did I miss this news? Were there proteins found on an asteroid?
- nativeit 2y agoIndeed I did miss that, what an incredible find, I can’t believe this never broke through into my routine news feeds! https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2024/pdf/1219.pdf https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2024/pdf/1219.pdf
- jebarker 2y agoHow suggestive is this of life elsewhere in the universe?
- staplung 2y agoOn it's own, probably not that much. We know that amino acids can form in interstellar space and have in fact observed clouds of them in star-forming regions[1]. Finding them on a non-planetary object in our own solar system is certainly very cool but we already knew they existed in this neck of the woods. ;-) 1: https://www.space.com/amino-acid-tryptophan-perseus-molecular-complex-life https://www.space.com/amino-acid-tryptophan-perseus-molecula...
- jcims 2y agoOnly tangentially related, but because they are so amazing here are a few videos that illustrate the process of transcription (creating mRNA from DNA) and translation (creating a protein from mRNA). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMtWvDbfHLo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMtWvDbfHLo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfYf_rPWUdY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfYf_rPWUdY The common complaint with these videos is that everything is more complex. One thing that isn't evident is that these specific videos (built mostly by Drew Barry) actually model a lot of other molecules to create a more realistic physical environment with brownian motion and whatnot. Then the irrelevant molecules are simply made transparent in the rendering. Obviously it's still much much more complex (eg the constant stream of ATP used to drive many of these operations is not illustrated). There are these and many more great illustrations/explanations at WEHImovies on youtube https://www.youtube.com/@WEHImovies https://www.youtube.com/@WEHImovies
- divbzero 2y agoWe would be remiss to leave out the 1970s classic Protein Synthesis: An Epic on a Cellular Level https://library.ucsd.edu/dc/object/bb90484996 https://library.ucsd.edu/dc/object/bb90484996
- throwawaymaths 2y agothese videos are better than most, but are still bad in one sense, they really fail to capture just how random walk the movements are. For example, in the first video the script says "a mediator protein complex arrives" as if it is directed there by some sort of orchestration agent. It's not. It's more like "a mediator protein complex drunkenly stumbles in and connects after a few thousand misses". Of course it's hard to make that into a captivating video. As I said, the WEHI movies are pretty good in that at least they add some random walk into the motions. There was a harvard artist-professor (can't remember who) who literally made videos with exact parabolic and helical trajectories and then was crowing about how beautiful the biological system is.
- mongol 2y agoThank you for clarifying what I have wondered. In most of these videos it appears as if the molecules have an intent and act on a plan. It makes me think "how do they know to do that".
- Mistletoe 2y agohttps://www.smithsonianmag.com/space/must-all-molecules-life-be-left-handed-or-right-handed-180959956/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/space/must-all-molecules-life... More explanation here. >Oftentimes both the left- and right-handed versions of, for example, an amino acid, were found in equal amounts—exactly what might be expected. But in many cases, one or more organic molecule was found with an excess of one hand, sometimes a very large excess. In each of those cases, and in every meteorite studied so far by other researchers in the field, the molecule in excess was the left-handed amino acid that is found exclusively in life on Earth.
- polishdude20 2y agoCould these asteroids be from when the moon was created?
- skykooler 2y agoThe moon was created far before life formed - the best estimates put its formation about 4.5 billion years ago, while life didn't form until 3.7 billion years ago. So any complex molecules from that process would not be present on asteroids of lunar origin.
- gcanyon 2y agoFor a really brilliant visualization of the time scale, I can't recommend this Kurzgesagt video highly enough. It's an animation of the condition of the entire history of the Earth, at 1.5 million years per second of video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S7TUe5w6RHo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S7TUe5w6RHo
- singularity2001 2y ago>> The moon was created far before life formed not in the panspermia theory
- nkrisc 2y agoA better way to put it might be that current lineages of life on Earth arose after the moon was created - the assumption being any life that arose before the moon was created would not have survived a fully molten Earth.
- mannyv 2y agoIsn't it the same reason that the right hand rule works?
- hydrolox 2y agoRight hand rule is just an arbitrary decision defining counterclockwise to be positive, but I guess it's true that it could be "less arbitrary" if certain things are more counterclockwise than clockwise
- hoc 2y agoWaiting for the Creator -> left-handed conclusion...
- divbzero 2y ago> “The findings suggest that life’s eventual homochirality might not be a result of chemical determinism but could have emerged through later evolutionary pressures.” Homochirality resulting from chemical determinism would be the more surprising result to me. The straightforward explanation is that random perturbations early in the evolution of life broke symmetry and led to homochirality of all descendent life, similar to how random perturbations early in the life of the universe broke symmetry and led to our world being made of particles instead of antiparticles.
- roughly 2y agoGiven how much of the rest of the chemical processes of life seem to proceed fairly straightforwardly from the rules of chemical structure and energy requirements for various reactions, I’d almost expect the opposite - that there’s some structure or reaction core to life that’s marginally cheaper or easier with left chirality that caused the divide, and the rest is history.
- andrewflnr 2y agoIt's still not obvious how they could be separated at all by pre-biotic processes. You need to go from (in principle anyway) a pretty well-mixed 50-50 mixture to basically only lefties. I believe this is still one of the bigger problems for abiogenesis, and frankly I think you're being too glib about the antimatter problem too. I expect we're eventually going to find out about specific mechanisms that cause those.
- anlsh 2y agoA very plausible explanation is that the separation was biotic
- andrewflnr 2y agoThere's a bootstrapping problem, though.
- 2y ago
- theodorejb 2y agoWhat evidence would it take for more scientists to recognize that perhaps life didn't evolve through some evolutionary process, but was intentionally created? It seems like few ever consider that their starting presupposition may be wrong.
- bediger4000 2y agoIf we decided that life had been deliberately created, we could get some insight into the god or gods who did it. What kind of a diety creates parasites, for example. What kind of pantheon creates a universe with Goedel's Incompleteness built in, or the difficulty of the Busy Beaver game? Those are fun questions.
- latentsea 2y agoThe real question, according to HN, is why did god create Kubernetes and have every developer glom onto it when only a handful of companies in the universe truly need it? Edit: the follow up question is "why isn't the universe just a shell script?"
- scrapcode 2y agoI certainly am trending that way as I grow older. As I've recently started to re-dive into Christian theology, the fine-tuning argument seems more and more interesting, and it's pretty difficult to find "good" secular arguments against it.
- roncesvalles 2y agoAside from the mountain of actual evidence, just to build a philosophical intuition against fine-tuning - you need to appreciate the enormous scale of trial and error at play. - The Earth seems like the perfect planet but looking out into the sky there are trillions of planets that aren't perfect at all. - Most likely the universe also appears "perfect" for the same reason - there must be a graveyard of universes where the parameters just didn't work out for life. - Evolution is much the same - many mutations occur all the time, most are fixed by cellular machinery, most that aren't are deleterious, but once in a while a helpful mutation emerges. Take a moment to understand the timescale involved. Don't just handwave away 3.8 billion years as some number - feel it, starting at 1 year and stepping up each order of magnitude. You will realize that a million years is essentially "forever ago", and we had 3800 of those to get here. Consider how many species exist that aren't civilizational sentient intelligence.
- beambot 2y agoSounds a bit like playing with ice-nine... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice-nine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice-nine