4 ms·
Dad doesn't need that every time, but he has some other time when he needs it. A truck can do just about anything you might want of a car, while a car cannot d
by bluGill 2y ago
Dad doesn't need that every time, but he has some other time when he needs it. A truck can do just about anything you might want of a car, while a car cannot do everything a truck can. Cars are expensive, and you pay for them even if don't use them - car payment, taxes, insurance are all prices you pay even if the car isn't moved. If you have a car for each need the cost goes up fast. If the car isn't used much your maintenance costs are more than expected again because things like sun and ozone wear parts out not just use.
People tell me to just rent a truck when you need one. However that is hard and expensive. Most places won't rent you a truck, they will rent you a truck shaped vehicle with restrictions meaning you can't use it like a truck. When you find an exception the costs it very high and they charge per mile rates - it doesn't take many uses to be worth the extra costs of having a truck that does everything instead even before you account for the hassle of going to get the rental truck.
Of course small cars can do more than most people give them credit for but they are still compromise and there are a lot of things that they can't do.
- vel0city 2y ago> Dad doesn't need that every time, Dad probably doesn't really need it, ever. One friend argued he really needed a truck because he bought a lawn mower off Facebook Marketplace and wouldn't have possibly gotten it home without his truck. It's the only truck-like thing he's done in a year or two. Strange, I managed to put a lawnmower in my small crossover/hatchback without any issues. Another argued he needed a truck because he goes mountain biking. No possible way to take a bicycle without an extended cab 6ft bed.
- trimethylpurine 2y agoYou don't really need a car. What's your excuse?
- vel0city 2y agoI do, in that public transportation around me doesn't go to places I routinely need to go and the distances involved are impractical for a bicycle. At the rates and frequency I'd have to pay to take things like Uber, the break-even to own a car is pretty quick. If the public transit here was better, I'd totally be down to ditch the car. I do tend to take transit when its competitive and makes sense. This evening, I have to take the kids and their stuff to visit the grandparents for an overnight. Their home is 30mi away from me. Even though I've got public transit immediately outside my door, there's no public transit servicing their home. I could take the two-hour bus ride for the bus at the edge of my neighborhood to the edge of the public transit network, it's still >10mi to their home. This trip for this afternoon on Uber is ~$40 each way. For one trip I'll make a few times in a month. Or I can take my car and make it a 25-minute trip that costs me several dollars each way. We also go visit some family >70mi each way from us on a pretty regular basis. There's definitely no transit available to get to where they live, and an Uber going all the way over there is >$100 each way. I mostly work from home, the "office" is ~2mi from my home, I love to ride my bike and I take public transit a decent bit, and yet I still manage to put >13,000mi on my car every year. That is how extremely car centric DFW is. Most people I know who "need" a truck would absolutely be able to do everything they use their truck for with a small hatchback to a medium sized crossover.
- trimethylpurine 2y agoIt sounds like you have good reasons. Kind of like many truck owners. What level of sacrifice you make to get what you really need apparently isn't necessarily comparable with anyone else, right? Commuting is a choice. No one is making you work where you do, or live where you do, at least not since 1863. No judgement here, I'm just pointing it out. Is it possible we're all on the same team? Even the pickup owners?
- vel0city 2y ago> Most people I know who "need" a truck would absolutely be able to do everything they use their truck for with a small hatchback to a medium sized crossover. Once again, let me restate that, and maybe it'll sink in. > Most people I know who "need" a truck would absolutely be able to do everything they use their truck for with a small hatchback to a medium sized crossover. These people aren't really doing anything that would seriously impact their lives if they didn't own a truck, but they convinced themselves they needed a truck. I'm not saying this about all truck owners; I know lots who actually do tow campers and boats, who actually do pickup yards of gravel and what not on a regular basis, who literally do live on a ranch, etc. And I know tons of people who own a truck because how else would they get their mountain bike to the trail across town, or who have such a culture deeply ingrained in their mind they couldn't be seen driving a smaller vehicle for more than a day. That they need it because "it's comfortable", as if a luxury sedan isn't comfortable. For many it is a lifestyle choice they choose to make to drive a vehicle massively oversized for their needs, and is not at all similar to the fact I need a car to to most stores and generally function in society because that's how this city was designed. If you haven't been to the Southern United States, you probably just don't understand the truck culture I'm talking about. You may think I'm making some straw man, but I personally know more than a dozen of these people.
- badpun 2y agoIn 20 years of non-truck car ownership, I've never had to rent a truck. I could always just buy a service that e.g. delivers my large goods from the store to my door, or move all my things and furniture when moving apartments etc. What are the use cases when actually driving the truck myself is necessary?
- trimethylpurine 2y agoYour shelter, goods, and services are provided by truck owners. The roof you sleep under, the walls you take comfort in. If you take a moment to reflect, you'll quickly realize that your seemingly truck independent existence is little more than a thin, single layer of obfuscation from a societal framework that affords you such pretenses. You don't need to own a truck because at least 20 other people do, and I think that's your point. You'll rely on them. But think about that point for a second. It's not saying what you think it's saying.
- badpun 2y agoI also don't need to own a backhoe, every time I want to dig a hole I just rent a guy with one. It's very similar to trucks and yet nobody owns personal backhoes, but plenty of people own their personal trucks. It's a waste of resources.
- bluGill 2y agoI know a number of people with personal backhoes. They all have a fair amount of land. It doesn't take long to pay off a personal backhoe if you use them. Though most people don't have nearly enough need for large holes to make it worth it.
- HeyLaughingBoy 2y ago/me raises hand as someone seriously considering it.
- vel0city 2y ago