4 ms·
Microsoft will soon let you clone your voice for Teams meetings
- d2049 2y agoI'm a bit hesitant to give my voice away to really any company. Is it really that much of a stretch to imagine the ways this could go wrong?
- plagiarist 2y agoI do prefer a robot standing in instead of me to fulfill the little power trip calling attendance. There is little reason the updates cannot be async in text or via the JIRA tickets I already have to do. A robot could add in pull request data too. But it doesn't need to be my voice. It in fact should be illegal for Microsoft to use my voice for training without my express consent, and even then they must delete all models and data about it when requested. And it should be illegal for an employer to request or expect it.
- maxerickson 2y agoThere's tech that can do a reasonable approximation using a sample a couple of seconds long. Any control over that is going to be through social and legal mechanisms, it isn't going to work to try to prevent access to the needed data.
- deegles 2y agoI would trust Microsoft with my voice more than some random startup.
- f1refly 2y agoWhy? Microsoft is a proven bad actor while the startup might have good people of you're lucky.
- _mlbt 2y agoThere is a nonzero chance that said startup gets bought by Microsoft or worse.
- hulitu 2y ago> I would trust Microsoft with my voice more than some random startup. I bet you haven't read their privacy policy. It starts with: "Your privacy is very important for us." /s
- almatabata 2y agoHonestly I would have thought that 5 years ago. But given the latest news on what they are doing, and how they treat security, I honestly have lost all faith that they can handle that data with care. Laundry list of breaches: https://firewalltimes.com/microsoft-data-breach-timeline/ https://firewalltimes.com/microsoft-data-breach-timeline/ Profit over customer: https://www.propublica.org/article/microsoft-solarwinds-golden-saml-data-breach-russian-hackers https://www.propublica.org/article/microsoft-solarwinds-gold...
- LinuxBender 2y agoThis will be an unpopular take as I know tech folks get excited by any new tech but I predict deviants will gain access to this capability and I can imagine the thousands of ways they will wreck someones personal and professional life, make them homeless and destitute. People will need to put entirely new safeguards in places they never imagined they would need and this may even spin off entirely new artificially required industries in the same way that anti-virus and anti-spam came about despite being entirely avoidable but that's a different topic. This is not limited to Microsoft's service. This will happen anywhere people are storing a sufficient sample of peoples voices. One example mitigation I implemented at a local bank is to have them disable most aspects of internet access to my accounts. They are read-only from the internet and outbound wire transfers are blocked. They now require my physical presence and I make sure all the employees know me personally. I test them from time to time on the phone. My goal is to terminate business relationships with anyone I can not do this with. This will be too much for some people at first, having to treat every business relationship as hostile and I am not even sure I can get 100% completion of my goal I do not know how to solve this on a global scale. I think the only way things start changing around this vulnerability is when powerful people experience shared pain. Lawmakers, executives, investors, etc... Such as businesses losing billions because some department thought they were talking to a real person and governments losing large amounts of tax revenue when more companies have this capability and it gets abused by deviants. Curious what happens when the fake POTUS calls the real Vladimir and Xi.
- almatabata 2y agoImagine what happens when the company gets hacked and they start selling your voice online? Sophisticated Phishing attacks, blackmail, destroying someones public image
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Eddy_Viscosity2 2y agoAll middle management done by AI having meetings with itself and making and presenting slide decks to itself and tracking it all in spreadsheets only it every looks at. The people at the top still get all the money and the people at the bottom still do all the work. But the middle will be so damn efficient we won't know what hit us. Amazing times.
- wkat4242 2y agoReminds me of this: https://youtu.be/rYaZ57Bn4pQ https://youtu.be/rYaZ57Bn4pQ It was a joke video from the onion about outsourcing their own jobs to India. This is kinda the same but with AI. I know it's only for translation now but how long until "copilot" joins meetings on my behalf?
- hulitu 2y ago> I know it's only for translation now but how long until "copilot" joins meetings on my behalf? Well, they have my voice (Teams), they have my image and biometrics (Windows Hello for business), they know everything i do a the computer (Recall) so they can replace me with an AI. Just think at the next headlines: Microsoft increases the price of Office 365 bundling a new feature: virtual employees.
- sunaookami 2y ago>virtual employees Then we hold virtual meetings where virtual managers create PowerPoint slides with AI and virtual employees "listen" and in the end AI summarizes everything into something no one will ever read? :D
- tempodox 2y ago> something no one will ever read? No, they train the next LLM on it.
- lloeki 2y agoWhile grey goo is about matter, this appears to be a grey energy scenario: one where machines run amok eating all possible energy in an exponential feedback loop of uselessness, driving civilisations to oblivion. While the civilisations are long-gone, they build up the Kardashev ladder for the sole purpose of producing more of nothing. Finally, all cosmic resources being expanded, they shut down. Since nobody remained to observe, it is unknown whether in a brief flash of self-awareness, realising the meaninglessness futility of their existence, the machines commited suicide.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gtirloni 2y agoThey were so preoccupied with whether or not they could that they didn't stop to think if they should -- Dr. Ian Malcolm
- gardenhedge 2y agoI wonder if this could help with pronouncing words in other languages. That's always been hard for me
- pluc 2y agoMicrosoft keeps creating the best tools for phishing.
- riiii 2y ago> clone their voices so they can have their sound-alikes speak to others in meetings in different languages Yeah, no. Automatic text translation is "ok" but automatic translation direct into a work meeting in your voice? Enjoy your HR meetings and lawsuit for unfair dismissal based on botched translation.
- user432678 2y agoOr the other way around — enjoy swearing and be mean during the calls saying “it’s just a botched translation”.
- INTPenis 2y agoThe AI hype is so strong that they're rolling out a feature to forge people's voices BEFORE they roll out the feature to sign your own voice cryptographically.
- Cumpiler69 2y agoPeople were naive enough to upload their personal details and pictures to Facebook/Tinder/Google over a decade ago without any cryptographic signing. What makes you think they won't make the same mistake again with their voice? You just have to bait people with features of convenience in return for their data. There's a reason history keeps repeating itself.
- fmbb 2y agoThis is actually great. If we can get only AIs to take meetings we can save a lot of work in offices. Zoom has the same dream: https://www.theverge.com/2024/6/3/24168733/zoom-ceo-ai-clones-digital-twins-videoconferencing-decoder-interview https://www.theverge.com/2024/6/3/24168733/zoom-ceo-ai-clone... Eventually we can also decouple scheduling meetings and reading summaries from humans. And then we can all spend time working instead of in meetings. The robots can archive all their summaries, and have follow up meetings to track status of action points they invented. As long as they do not bother humans it will be a great boon to productivity.
- cookiengineer 2y agoOr, you know, humans could just get their shit together and use asynchronous communication channels in the first place. Using AI for this is like a trying to solve a self-created problem. If human meeting culture would have just used an issue tracker and e.g. emails for this, this all would not have been necessary. Human meeting culture exists only because the tools for synchronizing states is so bad in its UX/UI that there is seemingly no better way to do it. If Teams would have had a better UX focussed on issue management combined with better overviews for different roles, they would not have needed AI bots/avatars for this problem.
- lloeki 2y agoAlthough due to Poe's law I'm unsure if GP was earnest, I elected to read it with a /s modifier.
- stego-tech 2y agoSame here, because otherwise I’m afraid the disease has reached their brain, and they must be destroyed. /s In all seriousness, I hope that was sarcasm, because otherwise that sounds like absolute hell and the biggest waste of resources since the performance review. Except instead of just wasting time, now it also wastes energy, fresh water, land, and rare earths too.
- xattt 2y ago
- ujikoluk 2y agoWould be very interested in trying an English-to-English mode to wash away my ESL accent.
- yen223 2y agoIs this something that people are clamouring for? How many of y'all would be using this?
- rnabhsj 2y ago"My voice is my passport" (quote from some action movie). They claim that they do not store biometric data. For now. Wait until the next rug pull where they'll claim that your voice and all conversations belong to them. Which raises the question: What happens on all the "free" communication platforms like Google Meet and so on? Are the conversations recorded and mined? The data collection business Salesforce had an "AI" meeting summary feature already years ago.
- ipython 2y agoThe quote is from “sneakers” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sneakers_(1992_film) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sneakers_(1992_film) which is actually a fantastic film.
- InfamousRece 2y agoHSBC (a bank where I have some CD accounts) requires me to shout “my voice is my password” to authenticate whenever I call them.
- blisterpeanuts 2y agoI’d much rather have meetings go full Discord. A chat room is easier to deal with when you’re busy and trying to multitask. Having to drop everything and interact in a rigidly structured audiovisual format feels very constraining and counterproductive these days. A properly trained AI could stand in for you as needed.
- mango7283 2y agoWho will take accountability if the AI says something offensive or damaging
- blisterpeanuts 2y agoIt’s a good question. I guess the same sort of constraints that prevent A.I. customer service chatbots from cursing or otherwise saying inappropriate stuff.
- trollbridge 2y agoCertain managers don’t like this since they want the participants’ full attention, which is why we have Zoom video meetings in the first place.
- bastloing 2y agoNice option to have, can't wait until they expand it to more commonly used languages of the world.
- airstrike 2y ago"...to speak to others in different languages" is conspicuously missing from the title, so much so that it has pushed most of this thread into "why would I give up my own voice" territory I guess one positive way to look at it is we're one small step closer to the Universal Translator
- oezi 2y agoI would rather have the feature to hide window switches which cause differences in face illumination and/or keeping the eyes focused more naturally on the camera.
- butz 2y agoWhy even have meetings? Just post a meeting talking points to some magical GenAI driven system and get meeting transcript in seconds. Do not like outcome? Modify initial prompt and try again.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- teeray 2y agoWe are so close to tricking leadership into just writing the email to replace the meeting they choose to have insteaad. We just need to call it “prompting an AI to speak on your behalf during the meeting” + “record and summarize the meeting.”
- kats 2y agoThe biggest use of voice cloning will be callers from foreign countries taking money from grandparents. Expect encryption like RCS and WhatsApp to go away by popular demand, because when phishing gets too good, the only solution will be a service like Google recording all telephone calls.
- throwaway314155 2y agoHow does Google (or whoever) recording all calls solve the problem?
- kats 2y agoThe telephone is becoming like an email inbox without protection from spam. By listening to every telephone call Google can alert users about phishing, voice cloning, etc. in real time. Voice cloning will get to the point where it's so good that there's no tech-savvy users who can detect it the way they can for email. Users will demand for protection to be added to their calls because you really can't live without it.
- dietr1ch 2y agoOh, no Phishing is getting too real, let's drop encryption. Said no one ever
- kats 2y agoUsers don't put it in those terms. They'll complain about spam calls that no longer sound like a male voice with heavy foreign accent. The logical solution will be, we need a service that scans all calls for phishing, just like we have for email. The service cannot be local for the same reason as for email.
- dietr1ch 2y ago> The logical solution will be, we need a service that scans all calls for phishing Come on, we have been using encryption, one-time codes, recovery codes for over a decade. I don't see that as the logical next step. Just make addresses renewable tokens that prove that you are allowed to contact some underlying number. tel:+56 1234 5678::[$SEED/TOKEN THAT SUPPORT K_TIMES_USE+EXPIRATION FROM A FIXED CALLER/SENDER] My phone will double check the token and ignore things when the calling tokens were used, expired, abused somehow and maybe kindly let you know if no human gets to see your call/text/media or maybe reporting the sender for abuse in case it's something that may be prosecuted according to local law. Want to support calls from unknown numbers? Sure, wire me crypto with some secret and call me using that. If it wasn't worth my time at least I'll enjoy a beer.
- zyn1643158 2y agoI think this requires consideration of privacy and security issues.