3 ms·
This does not seem like an important distinction. The user implicitly authorized it to be posted on CL by virtue of, well, posting it on CL. They did not author
by eli 14y ago
This does not seem like an important distinction. The user implicitly authorized it to be posted on CL by virtue of, well, posting it on CL. They did not authorize any other sites to post it. Or am I missing something?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- briandear 14y agoI agree. When I post a resume to a job site, that doean't mean I want it posted in other places without my consent. It seems like a dick move to repost people's ads without their consent. If, technically te data belongs to the poster, than it's distinctly dickish to post that data in other venues without their permission. Perhaps someone only wants their add on the Scanton Craigslist and not on other sites. I posted a classified add on a site once selling some furniture (not CL but a hyper local site) and I started getting dozens I calls from buyers after I had removed the ad because some ass thought it was a 'service' to repost my ad, even though the stuff sold via the original site within a day. I don't doubt Padmapper can be useful, but if it is genuinely better, then one shouldn't have to steal CL data to make it work. Build your own damned business.
- jellicle 14y agoIf Craigslist is explicitly disclaiming copyright in the data they post, how can they sue for copyright infringement? The user may be able to. But the users won't do so, at least not in any significant numbers.
- dangrossman 14y ago> If Craigslist is explicitly disclaiming copyright in the data they post, how can they sue for copyright infringement? By having the user sign their right to sue over to Craigslist. They're saying "it's your copyright, but you're giving us the enforcement rights to it". It's in their TOS: > You also expressly grant and assign to CL all rights and causes of action to prohibit and enforce against any unauthorized copying, performance, display, distribution, use or exploitation of, or creation of derivative works from, any content that you post (including but not limited to any unauthorized downloading, extraction, harvesting, collection or aggregation of content that you post).
- natrius 14y agoI don't think that's possible, but I'm not a lawyer. I'm very interested in seeing an example of a clause like this being applied. Another commenter cited the Righthaven case as a counterexample: https://www.eff.org/press/releases/righthaven-case-ends-victory-fair-use https://www.eff.org/press/releases/righthaven-case-ends-vict...
- jessriedel 14y agoI don't think PadMapper puts up the entire post written by the user, just fact that the post exists and is in reference to a particular location. Likewise, it's kosher for me to tell Alice that Bob posted a poem on his window so that she can go read it, even though it would not be kosher for me to make her a copy.