3 ms·
After reading the post and discussion, my conclusion is that Craigslist is making a policy mistake. They should make the same calculation of public good that e
by stcredzero 14y ago
After reading the post and discussion, my conclusion is that Craigslist is making a policy mistake.
They should make the same calculation of public good that ericd made and license 3rd party websites that add value to Craigslist, provided the 3rd parties do not harm the Craigslist infrastructure or business models. Doing otherwise is just holding up progress, and is a losing game in the long run. Facilitating value to users would be a win for them, as it was in the past.
- debacle 14y agoCreating a site where buyers can browse property listings does harm the Craigslist business model. To say otherwise expresses a lack of understanding of online ecosystems.
- stcredzero 14y agoAs far as I can tell, they aren't posting the full listing. They are only aggregating the material facts about the listing. As far as I can tell, short of actually hoofing it to the place, you still have to get on Craigslist to make contact with the landlord.
- hollerith 14y agoWhat Craigslist is afraid of (probably) is Padmapper becoming the first place most people turn to when looking for an apartment. Once that happens, Padmapper can cut Craigslist out of the loop by inviting landlords to make Padmapper listings instead of Craigslist listings. (Note that once Padmapper become to "go to" place for apartment hunters, Padmapper's refusing to continue to host or "index" Craigslist listings helps towards that goal.) Regardless the morality or legality of Padmapper's latest action, it is pretty clear to those of us who have spent a lot of time observing online ecosystems and software ecosystems that Padmapper's latest action is not in the interests of Craigslist since (even if Craigslist is not out to make money, but rather out to influence the world for the better) the only important source of Craigslist's potential for making money and of Craigslist's influence is Craigslist's being the first place people turn to when apartment hunting and doing other important things. That is why Craigslist is against Padmapper's latest action even if Padmapper never posts the full Craigslist listing.
- stcredzero 14y agoAnd in that, Craigslist is clearly acting in its own interests contrary to the interests of its users.
- jmduke 14y agoContrary to the interests of Padmapper users (some of whom are also Craigslist users.) The vast majority of Craigslist users don't want to use anything else, nor are aware of anything else.
- hyperbovine 14y ago> that add value to Craigslist It should be pretty obvious by now that Craig doesn't give a shit about adding value. (I mean this in a good way.) CL has dominated its space for the past 15 years and shows no signs of letting up, so your claim about losing in the long run would seem to be misguided.
- stcredzero 14y ago> CL has dominated its space for the past 15 years and shows no signs of letting up, so your claim about losing in the long run would seem to be misguided. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
- mdda 14y agoAlthough it's tempting to say that CL should make an investment in these 3rd party sites - the most direct solution is for CL to say "We'll license the content for 30% of your equity". Cash element of zero : CL has already invested in making a site that has the raw content that everyone wants.