6 ms·
The founder of 3Taps posted this on Quora last year, in response to a question about disrupting Craigslist: ... the postings in question are public facts about
by ilamont 14y ago
The founder of 3Taps posted this on Quora last year, in response to a question about disrupting Craigslist:
... the postings in question are public facts about exchanges. Just as any price/supply/demand in a marketplace is open for any and all to notate and republish, so too is the entire set of Craigslist data -- as these offers between seekers and providers are clearly in the public domain. Historically, Craigslist has attempted to block access by others to the comprehensive use of this data. They block many 3rd parties who try to gain access to the data, and sometimes threaten to sue and bankrupt others as if they themselves created the underlying data and hold copyright like property rights over the same.
But public facts are public property. And while some think that predatory Terms of Use demanding that you hand over the Brooklyn Bridge in liquidated damages if you don't comply with some obscure (and potentially constitutionally void) constraint will stand in court -- such absurdities will break if exposed.
A fear, uncertainty,dread approach over access to data breaks down in a world where Google already indexes all of Craigslist data and caches that information all over the internet (for search performance results). If its possible and legal for Google, then why not for any and everyone else to also index and offer access to the same data. In short, Google doesn't get special secondary property rights to privatize public data to the exclusion of anyone else. Equal access to exchange data and search data is a principle in parallel to the notions of net neutrality.
The points above are not a theoretical discourse. Look at 3taps.com/developers to see the execution of this concept. And look at what a 3rd party application (craiggers.com) can do in recreating the whole of Craigslist in a format that gives access to data in a way that is not remotely possible in the legacy Craigslist offering. Craiggers is a perfect example that the function of displaying Craigslist data (rather than gathering it) is a totally distinct (and competitive) marketplace, even if there are still huge network effects in the gathering of Craigslist postings.
Note, Craiggers does NOT disrupt the existing Craigslist revenue model for Craigslist. It simply opens up the field (along with any other developer building on 3taps assisted access to Craigslist data) that wants to build on top of (rather than compete with) the network effects of Craigslist. Think Kayak and Indeed, but now for the whole body of data covered by Craigslist accessible, rather than just a single vertical.
http://www.quora.com/Craigslist/Why-hasnt-another-product-disrupted-and-replaced-Craigslist/answer/Greg-Kidd http://www.quora.com/Craigslist/Why-hasnt-another-product-di...
- fusiongyro 14y agoIt sounds great on paper, but it's not going to stop Craigslist from C&Ding all the developers using the 3Taps API. IANAL and not sure they even could indemnify their customers, but I know I'd want more than a reasoned argument and bold words from my upstream provider if I were to build a business on the 3Taps-provided Craigslist API.
- CoffeeDregs 14y agoI know the 3Taps people pretty well. They're seasoned entrepreneurs and they definitely know what they're doing with the 3Taps API. One of the founders is a grey haired attorney who's thought this through pretty carefully. They're also prepared to handle any legal issues that arise since they need to be, but also because it would be the best PR ever.
- fusiongyro 14y agoYes, but are they prepared to handle everyone else's legal issues too? Is doing so in the agreement between them and Padmapper? I'm sure they're great guys, but that doesn't obligate them to protect Padmapper from Craigslist.
- flatline3 14y agoAs gray hair as they might be, they come across as rather morally bankrupt and I can't imagine this ending remotely well for anyone in this industry. Either Google will have to begin applying constraints to cacheing, or the websites will have to apply constraints to Google indexing, or the websites will have to enter into an arms race with the likes of 3taps. The end result will be a great deal of wasted money, and if 3taps is actually successful, the decimation of the businesses whose data they rely on. Then what? Is 3taps going to build another Craigslist, for free, and open up their data silo to the internet?
- bhntr3 14y agoI think this is great. Ownership of user contributed content is a big open question. Now everything is becoming social and crowd-sourced. If this pushes the question to the forefront so an actual judgment is made it will put businesses on some sort of solid ground. Right now a lot of people are building on potential quicksand. I like flickr's approach. Users own the content and define the copyright. Flickr provides an open API and a TOU which makes it tricky and/or illegal to source the content directly from their servers. If a billion dollar business relies on people giving them content for free and them keeping the copyright and re-selling the content, then I think maybe they're the morally bankrupt ones. APIs are everywhere now and API use is becoming quite a big sticking point. I think content API platforms are the future of the Internet and a lot of the big names (Facebook, Yelp, Twitter, Foursquare, etc.) But yes, someone needs to figure out how to monetize being a content platform (in a non-Wikipedia way). Assuming you have the right to take the content, resell it and own the copyright seems like a weak assumption that has only worked so far while people were less savvy about it.