5 ms·
Nice collection of coincidences and just right configurations that make our universe/existence possible. Strange that the article doesn't also point out that
by xnx 2y ago
Nice collection of coincidences and just right configurations that make our universe/existence possible. Strange that the article doesn't also point out that all of these coincidences are 100% inevitable, otherwise we wouldn't be here to observe them.
- jvanderbot 2y agoI don't see why they must occur, only that they have occurred. Can you explain?
- triceratops 2y agoIf they didn't occur, we wouldn't be here to note that they didn't occur.
- jvanderbot 2y agoThat is certainly evidence that they have occurred but is not evidence that they will always occur.
- triceratops 2y agoIf they never occurred there would be no one to note this lack of occurrence.
- jvanderbot 2y agoAnd we've come full circle back to the anthropic principle, which does not imply that all universes eventually evolve life (it implies that if you are alive, you life in a universe that can create life)... so I am officially being trolled here. The universe (OUR universe) must be configured to allow life to exist (obviously, b/c we do). Not the same as All universes (in any configuration) will allow life to exist.
- triceratops 2y ago> Not the same as All universes (in any configuration) will allow life to exist. Sorry I didn't realize that was the argument being made. I thought it was it's inevitable for there to be at least one universe that will evolve life. Not trying to troll you.
- jvanderbot 2y ago> I thought it was it's inevitable for there to be at least one universe that will evolve life. Oh man, here we go. I'm not sure that's true either. Unless you believe that all possible universes will eventually occur. In which case carry on, no truth/falsehoods exist at that level that I know of.
- zero-sharp 2y agoIf it makes you feel any better, I agree with you and I have no idea what everyone else is smoking.
- GoblinSlayer 2y agoBy our universe you mean the part of the universe that we observe? Like people believed the world ends at the sky firmament? How would you explain them why uninhabitable planets don't exist? If all universes start in the same state and evolve deterministically, then they go through the same evolution, then if one produces life, then all produce life.
- thrance 2y agoIt's the Anthropic Principle[1], basically it's the idea that those coincidences having occured can be explained by the fact that if they didn't, we wouldn't exist, and thus there would be no one to wonder why they happened. In other words, those coincidence happened necessarily, in a way. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle
- jvanderbot 2y agoWhat he said is not the anthropic principle. He said these coincidences must always occur. That's not true. They have occurred in at least one universe, solar system and planet: ours. But these conditions are not inevitable.
- francisofascii 2y agoRight. It sounds more like the survivorship bias fallacy.
- zero-sharp 2y agoThis is such a weird comment. It's like an attempt to trivialize the article by stating something completely nontrivial with a lot of confidence.
- lxgr 2y agoIt's the same feeling I had after reading the article, though, and I'm pretty familiar with anthropic reasoning. The anthropic principle is the most plausible answer we have to the honestly quite reasonable question of "if all of these things are so unlikely, why did they still all happen?", so why not emphasize it more? The idea is also pretty powerful in ordinary/non-metaphysical contexts in the form of survivorship bias, and something useful to keep in mind whenever listening to somebody successful post-hoc explaining how all of their conscious past decisions inevitably led them to where they are.
- zero-sharp 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=42176047&goto=item%3Fid%3D42173316%2342176047 https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=42176047&goto=item%3Fi...
- bena 2y agoI agree, this is in the category of "if things were different, they'd be different". All of these things had to be some way, and in every way they could be there would be something different now. However, they were they way they were so we're here now. It's a lot like saying that it took a string of nearly impossible coincidences at just the right time for you to be born. Which is true. But just because dad plowed mom at half past two instead of quarter past doesn't mean we don't have a person, we just have a slightly different person. And that person would also be the result of a bunch or impossible coincidences. It's basically the lottery paradox. Every individual ticket is unlikely to win, however, it is guaranteed someone will win.
- soulofmischief 2y agoYou're referring to the Anthropic principle, which is a hypothesis, not a law of nature. It also says nothing on inevitability. These things could easily have just not occurred (knowing what we know) and then we wouldn't be here to observe them. The causal arrow is important.
- zero-sharp 2y agoMy understanding is that the principle is just the observation that our existence implies that a certain chain of events occurred in the past. That isn't the same thing as saying that the chain of events necessarily had to occur.
- soulofmischief 2y agoYeah, it's basic conditional logic. If humans, then <chain of events> doesn't mean <chain of events> is guaranteed to occur. We haven't even been able to guarantee the existence of existence.
- lxgr 2y ago"Only universes capable producing/hosting conscious observers can be consciously observed from within them" seems like more than just a hypothesis to me.
- alserio 2y agoA tautology, even
- jvanderbot 2y agoThat's not what GP says. The original post said " all universes must inevitably produce the conditions for intelligent life" which is not obviously true. The anthropic principle does not say that either. Any mention of the anthropic principle w.r.t. the article is essentially screwing up the causality, as correctly stated ITT.
- 2y ago
- jonnycat 2y agoYes, I was surprised to see that there is no mention of the Anthropic Principle (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle), which describes exactly what you're saying. Of course, other kinds of life are possible, which would require other "just right" conditions - but in that case, we'd all be living in that universe, marveling at those coincidences!