7 ms·
It's a US cultural thing to either avoid blaming the police for anything, or make excuses for them. Brutal police behavior is seen as either acceptable, or what
by stavros 2y ago
It's a US cultural thing to either avoid blaming the police for anything, or make excuses for them. Brutal police behavior is seen as either acceptable, or what even desirable. I've seen reddit posts where a protester slightly taunts the police and gets pepper sprayed in the face, and all the commenters were gleefully saying things like "fuck around and find out", without even thinking that maybe there wasn't enough fucking around to warrant any finding out.
When you try and point this out, you're called various names, because apparently you either support the police 100%, or you're a criminal.
- hipadev23 2y ago[flagged]
- Nursie 2y agoDisagree - community moderated quality floats to the top under such systems, exposing the better posts to more eyes and downregulating low-quality shitposting. It can certainly lead to echo-chamber mentality, but without it we'd see more low-effort, low quality posts drowning out discourse.
- bruce511 2y agoYou're assuming that down-votes are used to assess the quality of the post, and not agreement with the content. I would suggest that both appear here. Personally I would prefer votes to be on quality of post rather than popularity of position as that leads to the possibility of examining an issue from multiple viewpoints. (When responding to a post that has been thought out, but down voted, I feel the need to point out that although I disagree, I'm not the one downvoting.) I do think that voting improves the quality overall. But a better system might be separate options for 'agree/disagree' vs 'quality / pithy' posts. (I also thinkbthis would be horrible UI, so meh)
- hipadev23 2y agoYep exactly. I’d argue they create echo chambers far more than we’d like to admit. It’s also not simply voting but also algorithmic of sorting content by likes, and implicitly excluding anything under a certain threshold. I’ve felt this way for nearly twenty years now, coinciding with the rise of reddit, twitter, and facebook alongside the decline of forums, blogs, and rss. On any topic with even slight amount of contention, you very quickly see people aligning toward the one-true-belief because they observe and react to the crowd supporting that opinion.
- Nursie 2y ago> I would suggest that both appear here. They do. It's not a perfect mechanism. > But a better system might be Yeah we've had 20 years or more of sites trying to find a good formula now. Slashdot's ratings and meta-ratings back in the day, where you rated something as Insightful/Informative etc, and then every so often you were asked to review other user's ratings so their future ratings could be weighted ... technically interesting but really cumbersome. I like HN's choice not to display ratings on other people's posts, and I like the simple UI. I think it's better with up and down votes than without... I don't think we're going to find a perfect scheme but that doesn't mean we should abandon the imperfect ones.
- Loughla 2y agoI'm pretty sure there are a number of people in the US who don't support the police in any way at all. There was a whole song a few years ago called Fuck the police, I'm pretty sure. It's like sweeping categorizations of an entire country are usually not accurate or something.
- davely 2y agoThat song was released in 1988 by NWA, a hip hop group from Compton, California. I don’t think it’s too far fetched to think that song was colored by their experiences with the notoriously corrupt LAPD of the 1980s.
- bear141 2y agoI live in America and while I have compassion for some individual cops, I hate them as a whole with a burning passion. I know lots of people that feel this way. It’s almost like social media comments sections are not an accurate representation of a population or something.
- stavros 2y ago> I'm pretty sure there are a number of people in the US who don't support the police in any way at all. Yes, this is so trivially true of any place that it's not worth mentioning, as generalizations are meant as just that: Something that a majority (or at least a large minority) are like. For example, people do say "people in the US speak English", even though there's a number of people that don't. This doesn't make the generalization any less useful than "Americans like baseball" or "Americans wear shoes around the house".
- scruple 2y agoI grew up in a small town and was on the wrong side of law enforcement (sometimes rightfully -- underage drinking, etc., nothing that serious -- but oftentimes not) around 2 dozen times between 16/17 and 21 when I got the fuck out of that town. I haven't so much as spoken to an on-duty cop in over 20 years. To this day I still get nervous when I see a police car. They earned their image problems and they haven't even begun to try to correct it. Even if they started tomorrow, it would still take them decades to fix it. I'm not hopeful that any meaningful change in policing in the US will take place in my lifetime. And, for anyone who isn't reading between the lines here, without a doubt I'm only so lucky as to avoid their attention today because I made it and have spent the last 2 decades living in nice neighborhoods and driving nice cars.
- ClassyJacket 2y ago[flagged]
- jrmg 2y agoAround 1000 people per year, which I absolutely agree is terrible - but at the same time, the population is over 300,000,000 so it stretches the meaning of the word to call it ‘regular’. https://www.statista.com/statistics/585152/people-shot-to-death-by-us-police-by-race/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/585152/people-shot-to-de...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jmye 2y agoThat’s more than two people per day. But sure, let’s nitpick the definition of “regular” because that’s absolutely the important issue, here.
- jrmg 2y agoPerhaps I made my point a little tactlessly - what I meant to imply is that people shouldn’t live in fear of this. While it happens too often, it’s still extremely uncommon.
- stavros 2y agoThe (bigger) problem is that that's the tip of a much larger police brutality iceberg. It's not like the police is 99.9% pleasant and helpful and then just murders the occasional person, the murders are indicative of a disturbing police culture.
- edanm 2y agoAgreeing on facts is always important, because if not, nothing else matters in a discussion. We should never criticize people for actually bringing real numbers into a conversation to clarify things. I didn't know that statistic, and I suspect many "disagreements" are things where if the actual numbers and facts were known to all, they would actually agree.
- mlinhares 2y agoExactly this. There's no fixing the system when there is no onus on the police to act like they care. They enter a home that was a victim of swatting and kill everyone? Tough luck, "it's part of the job", "we told them to stand down and they didn't", "we couldn't risk the life of the first responders". There's always a reason as to why police violence is fine. Its almost as if the police isn't really there to protect normal people.
- stavros 2y ago> Its almost as if the police isn't really there to protect normal people. Well, it's not. Even here, the function of the police is to enforce the will of the state, not to protect people. The protection is a side-effect of the enforcement, but enforcement can also be things like terrorizing minorities.
- ThrowawayTestr 2y agoI've also seen reddit posts where the cop did everything right and people still criticized.
- bcdtttt 2y agoCop didn't do everything right. A cop who does everything right leaves the force.
- kernal 2y agoThe only time I’ve seen police use pepper spray or aggression are when the protesters become violent. Do a YouTube search for Antifa protesters and tell me who the violent people are again?
- archagon 2y agoI see news stories like this all the time: https://abcnews.go.com/amp/US/caron-nazario-army-lieutenant-pepper-sprayed-police-awarded/story?id=96491296 https://abcnews.go.com/amp/US/caron-nazario-army-lieutenant-...
- snozolli 2y agoThe first thing that came to mind: https://www.kxan.com/investigations/everything-we-know-about-the-teenager-officers-shot-in-the-head-with-less-lethal-round-at-austin-protest/ https://www.kxan.com/investigations/everything-we-know-about... I saw countless similar videos of cops violently attacking -- often with permanent, life-altering results -- people who were exercising their constitutional rights or simply minding their own business.